The Pirates’ series victory against the Cardinals in St. Louis over the weekend was one of the highlights of their season to this point. It was also a microcosm of a problem that’s statistically likely to catch up with them over the course of a long season if they can’t find a solution for it soon.

The club’s run differential of minus-37 entering Wednesday is the third-worst in the National League, better than only the San Francisco Giants at minus-40 and the Miami Marlins at minus-95. The St. Louis series actually contributed to it substantially, as the Pirates were outscored by seven runs despite winning three of the four meetings.

That will happen when the one loss in question comes by a 17-4 margin and the three wins by a combined six runs. So what? The Pirates have been resilient and overcome big losses like that all season to post a respectable 21-18 record through the first month and a half. Who’s to say they can’t keep that up?

Well, math. Specifically, the Pythagorean theorem of baseball, which states that “runs scored compared to runs allowed is a better indicator of a team's (future) performance than a team's actual winning percentage,” according to Baseball Reference.

Advertise with us

No less than sabermetrics pioneer Bill James developed one of the formulas to calculate what a team’s record should be based on its differential, and on average, most teams’ records tend to finish a season within about three games of the record the formula would expect them to produce. That’s bad news for the Pirates.

Baseball Prospectus’ formula finds that they’ve overperformed their expected win-loss record by 5.5 games through Tuesday, putting them on course to exceed expectations by 22.8 games when extrapolated over a full season. Historically, that is a near-impossible pace to maintain while consistently getting outscored to this degree.

B-R notes that some of the biggest overperformers in recent history — the 2005 and 2007 Arizona Diamondbacks and 2012 Baltimore Orioles — only finished 11 games ahead of their expected W-L record.

It’s not out of the realm of possibility that the Pirates could join them this year. The problem is that even overachieving to that degree still probably wouldn’t get them very far. Their expected — or first-order — winning percentage of .398 would be good for only 64 expected wins through 162 games. Tacking 11 onto that would yield 75, not nearly enough for playoff contention.

Adding factors to the formula doesn’t improve the outlook much, either.

Advertise with us

Baseball Prospectus’ second-order winning percentage substitutes projected runs scored for actual runs scored. This change helps the Pirates, as their futility in bases-loaded situations this season has suppressed their offensive output relative to what would be expected.

Even if that production evens out, though, it only gets them to an expected .456 winning percentage, which translates to a 73-win expected record. Eleven wins tacked onto that barely gets them to the .500 mark.

Third-order winning percentage produces a similar outlook. It adjusts for quality of opponents and other underlying statistics, and it pegs the Pirates as only a 74-win team. Eleven wins added would produce an 85-win team. That’s probably good enough for contention, but little else.

The Pirates need to cut the differential down substantially to have a realistic chance of staying in the playoff race.

While it may be true that a few blowouts have accounted for most of the deficit, the theorem makes a pretty convincing argument that those wildly inconsistent results in St. Louis will level off, and that this team will post something closer to its expected record.

Advertise with us

The only way to avoid that fate is to play well enough for that expected record to improve.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.