Joe Musgrove
Joe Musgrove screamed into his glove during Friday’s third inning loud enough to be heard in the upper reaches of PNC Park. He thought he’d struck out Marcus Semien looking to end a rough third inning. Home-plate umpire Jerry Meals disagreed. The next pitch was a bases-loaded ball four.
Musgrove’s bellow of frustration aptly summarized the Pirates’ disaster of a 14-1 loss to the Oakland Athletics in front of an announced crowd of 16,428. Everything went wrong. The Pirates mustered only a run and four hits in six innings against A’s starter Brett Anderson. Errors extended innings. Neither Musgrove nor the relievers that followed could consistently record outs.
“We missed spots all night,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “When you give up 14 runs and that many hits, give them credit. They didn’t miss balls that we left up in the zone.”
The convergence of subpar performance meant that:
A’s catcher Josh Phegley recorded eight RBIs, seven in a three-inning span with two bases-clearing doubles and an RBI single. He added a solo homer in the ninth. Phegley had 13 RBIs coming into the game. He became the first player to record eight RBIs against the Pirates since 1977.
Anderson not only went 2 for 3 and reached on a bunt attempt that resulted in an error, he reached scoring position in three consecutive innings.
Read More
Oakland’s 14 runs were one short of the total number of runs they scored during the six-game losing streak preceding Friday’s game.
The A’s sent all nine men to the plate twice in the first four innings.
The Pirates have now lost nine of their past 11 games and fell under .500, at 14-15.
Six consecutive batters reached base in the second inning before the Pirates recorded an out. Jung Ho Kang’s two throwing errors bookended that stretch. He threw wide of first on Khris Davis’ grounder. Stephen Piscotty and Kendrys Morales singled to bring home one run. An inside cutter ran too far inside on Jurickson Profar and hit him, loading the bases, and Phegley’s double down the left-field line unloaded them.
Anderson bunted back to Musgrove, and here he contributed to Kang’s error. Musgrove threw directly to third … but Phegley wasn’t running. Musgrove heard “three,” meaning throw to third, initially, but by the time he heard Francisco Cervelli yell “one,” he was in his throwing motion. Knowing it was the pitcher running, he decided to throw to third.
“At that point I felt better just making my throw instead of turning and throwing it down the line,” Musgrove said. “It is what it is.”
Kang tried to get Anderson at first but again made an off-target throw, meaning Semien’s grounder drove in another run.
“He’s thrown balls away this year more than we’ve seen in the past,” Hurdle said of Kang.
Musgrove walked the leadoff batter in the following inning and again allowed hits to Morales and Phegley to add a run. With two outs, Anderson grounded a ball deep into the hole that Cole Tucker had no play on; he could only corral it. Then came the bases-loaded walk to Semien, and Musgrove’s night was done. He allowed seven runs, five earned, and six hits in 22/3 innings.
“I’m looking at a body of work of 32 starts,” Musgrove said. “You’re bound to have one or two of these throughout the course of the season. The important thing is being able to put this behind you and move on and be good in your next start.”
The Pirates’ offensive issues are well documented, and Musgrove is right: Even the best have a dud now and then. The fact that the defense continues to plague the Pirates more than a month into the season could be troublesome.
“We did not play good defense,” Hurdle said. “That’s all I got for you. At the end of the day, we didn’t handle the ball very well.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.