As the analytics movement has ingrained itself in baseball culture, the phrase “small sample size” has become ubiquitous to the point of cliche.

At one point, it served as a useful reminder that baseball seasons are long and that it’s difficult to get a meaningful statistical read on a player or a team in the course of a few days, weeks or even a month.

Now, though, it’s used almost reflexively as a catch-all excuse for poor performance, especially in the early days of a season in which things aren’t going well.

Take, for example, the Pirates’ bullpen. It was atrocious in the first week of the regular year, blowing three late leads against Cincinnati and St. Louis to put the team in a 1-3 hole. Manager Clint Hurdle seemed unbothered by it because ...

Advertise with us

“It’s a really small sample size,” he said after the home-opening loss Monday against the Cardinals. “We’ll keep pushing them out there and give them opportunities to build some consistency and some continuity to roles. I’ve got a lot of confidence in them.”

This is a textbook misapplication of the phrase that conflates the statistical reality that bad outings should average out over time with a solution for underlying issues.

If consistency and continuity of roles are the problems, a larger sample size will not fix them. Only the Pirates can do that by achieving consistency continuity of roles.

The fact that they apparently haven’t through six weeks of spring training and one week of the regular season then becomes a question of preparedness more so than math. Consider:

That is a large sample size that illustrates the gravity of what’s actually happened this first week. It was subpar baseball that will require near perfection for the Pirates merely to replicate their record with late leads in a year that they barely scraped past the .500 mark.

Advertise with us

It is reasonable to expect accountability for that. It is not an overreaction to ask tough questions about why it happened.

Was Keone Kela, who walked in a run Monday before blowing the lead in the loss Wednesday against the Reds, as sharp as he should have been coming out of spring training?

Was Nick Burdi, a rookie with two major league appearances to his name before this season, the correct choice to pitch in high-leverage situations Monday and Wednesday in which he gave up the lead both times?

Was this group, collectively, ready to hit the ground running the moment the games started to count in the standings?

The answer to the last question is a definitive “no,” even if things do get better from here. That sample is complete. Which is, more or less, the point.

Advertise with us

“Small sample size” is only a meaningful rebuttal if one is being used to make a sweeping, often stupid statement. Something like: “These three games show that the Pirates’ bullpen is a weakness” despite its strong close to last year. It’s probably not. At least, we don’t have enough evidence to form that opinion yet.

The phrase does, however, become a bad excuse when it’s deployed to dismiss any criticism of results that can have a meaningful impact on the team’s long-term fate.

Remember, the Pirates lost the division by three games or fewer each year from 2013 through ‘15. If they do so by such a deficit again, suddenly that “small” sample size of this past week will look pretty big.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.