Jameson Taillon pitched seven strong innings Wednesday night against the Cardinals. He threw only 85 pitches and gave up only one run and showed no signs of slowing down, so it seemed like a no-brainer that he’d come out to at least start the eighth inning.
That didn’t happen, though, as Taillon left the game with a 3-1 lead and Keone Kela started the eighth inning. Kolten Wong drew a walk to lead off the inning and Harrison Bader hit a two-run homer to tie the game. Kela did get three of the next four batters out to get out of the inning without giving up another run, but by that point the damage was done.
This sparked the age-old baseball argument about when a manager should lift a starting pitcher who is on a roll. A number of people, at least based on what was posted on social media, wondered why Hurdle didn’t just leave Taillon in.
“I still felt good, but I hadn’t completed seven yet [this season],” Taillon said. “And with those two guys [presumably Keona Kela and Felipe Vazquez] in the back end of our pen, I definitely understood.
“But I felt fresh. My pitch count was in a good place.”
The right answer will never really be known, but anyone questioning Hurdle’s decision to lift Taillon is doing so with the benefit of hindsight and is basing it on the outcome. And if Kela had come in and done his job, nobody would have been calling for Taillon to go longer. Hurdle knows this kind of second-guessing is part of it but said that the decision to lift a starter is always a tough one.
Read More
“You leave your starting pitcher in, if he gives up runs, that doesn’t look good. I think he felt like he competed and got us to a very good spot,” Hurdle said after the game.
And then he added, “I don’t know if he could have [pitched an effective eighth] because he didn’t get the opportunity. When things don’t happen under the decisions that are made, it’s always the manager’s responsibility. Never going to back away from that.”
Hurdle knew the question was coming and handled it the right way. He is absolutely right — the only time a manager gets second-guessed is when one of the moves he makes — especially a pitching change — doesn’t work out. There is no way to know before the fact whether a move is going to work out, which is why basing your opinion on the outcome is dumb.
Hurdle can only make the best decision possible the most times possible, and if he consistently does that, he will come out ahead. It’s sort of like playing a poker hand in that you don’t know and can’t control the outcome, all you can do is consistently make good decisions and you will be profitable in the long run.
I believe Hurdle made the right move for the Pirates by lifting Taillon and going to Kela. I am usually one that advocates pitchers going deep into games and would not have hated it had Taillon come out in the eighth. I just don’t think that was the right way to go.
The bottom line is the Pirates have essentially two legitimate closers in the bullpen to shut down games. Kela will almost always pitch the eighth inning in games the Pirates are leading and Vazquez will come in to close.
That combination of Kela and Vazquez makes the Pirates scary because opponents know they need to strike before the eighth inning. If they don’t get the Pirates before the eighth, they will have a tough time coming from behind to win the game.
The Pirates traded for Kela for that purpose, and Monday in the Pirates’ opening day loss to the Cardinals, he showed just how nasty he can be.
Kela entered the game with the bases loaded and nobody out in the bottom of the seventh in the opener and Cardinals slugger Paul Goldschmidt was at the plate. Kela walked Goldschmidt, so he gave up a run, but he got Paul DeJong to pop out and then struck out the next two batters to end the inning and the threat.
That’s why I had no issues with Hurdle replacing Taillon with Kela. A month from now when Taillon has a few more starts under his belt, it is a little bit warmer and he is a little more stretched out, maybe then I’d say Hurdle should send him out for the eighth.
Wednesday, though, Taillon had done his job and on most nights the formula of starter for seven innings followed by Kela and then Vazquez will yield a win. It didn’t work out that way Wednesday night, but that doesn’t mean it was the wrong decision. Kela is an excellent pitcher, one of the best on the staff. He just made one mistake and it cost the Pirates the lead and ultimately led to them losing the game.
Hurdle can’t control what happens when Kela gets into the game, but that’s not his job. His job is to make as many good decisions as possible, and if he takes that approach 100 percent of the time, the Pirates will come out ahead.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.