Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Jeff Atkins, Squirrel Hill: How are the Pirates ever supposed to get through this season, let alone win games with this terrible defense?

Zeise: The Pirates’ infield defense is indeed a problem. This isn’t a shock, though, is it? Josh Bell is below average in the field, and he is not likely to get much better than that. Adam Frazier is below average at second base. Erik Gonzalez was supposed to be the second coming of Ozzie Smith. Instead, he looks a lot like the second coming of Julio Lugo. I would presume he will get better, but so far it hasn’t been promising. Jung Ho Kang is an average third baseman, Colin Moran is below average. I don’t think this is likely to improve markedly this season, so they need to figure out how to overcome it. I think the thing is if they figure out how to just make the simple plays — i.e., don’t give up a bunch of extra outs every night — they will be OK. They won’t make a bunch of really tough highlight plays, but that is OK provided they make the routine plays. That’s been the problem, they haven’t made the routine plays. The pitching staff is strong and the relievers will be better, but they won’t be good if they have to get 31 outs every day.

Advertise with us

Anthony Febbraro: Is Clint Hurdle mismanaging games more and more because he’s ‘lost it’ or is it because Huntington pressures him into working the analytics and all that crap? He mentioned “eye candy test” the other day in an interview which was a subconscious confession of the pressure he has from the GM

Zeise: I don’t think Hurdle is mismanaging games as much as he is playing percentages. It is clear that organizations are trying to move the power away from the managers, so I am not sure how much of this stuff is his call any more. That’s just the way baseball is going. There are analytics and formulas that dictate almost every move. That’s why I don’t kill Hurdle for a lot of moves that are made — I’m not sure if it was his call or the call of someone above him.

Robert Gateway, Export, Pa.: Why do so many fans put professional athletes "having fun" over winning games? They do know they are being paid to win, not have fun?

Zeise: It is a generational thing. Somehow the fact that winning is the point of any game we play has been lost and is almost secondary. It is ridiculous, but it is just sort of the way it is going. I hate the cliche “everybody gets a trophy,” but that’s the mentality. It used to be winning was the only thing that mattered, but nowadays it seems everything but winning matters. As for the fun stuff like dancing and celebrating, I have always maintained winning is fun. Losing is not. That makes me a dinosaur I suppose, but I just can’t quite wrap my head around the idea of playing for any other reason than to win. All of the celebration stuff doesn’t really bother me, I just wish guys celebrated team accomplishments as much as they do individual accomplishments.

Jared Starks, Green Tree: What do you think the Pirates will do about Josh Bell's horrible defense moving forward? He makes Pedro Alvarez look like a Gold Glover.

Advertise with us

Zeise: Please see the first answer. Bell is not very good and really doesn’t even have the instincts and natural ability to get much better. He is one of the best hitters on the team, though, so the Pirates need him to play every day. It is just one of those things they will have to hope doesn’t hurt them too often this season.

Stephani Herbste, Charlotte: I know it is a small sample size, but the Pirates need to have a better option at shortstop than Erik Gonzalez, right? If he is their starting shortstop all season long it will be a tough team to watch. He is not good enough. What are their other options?

Zeise: I do believe Gonzalez is a good defensive shortstop. I know what we have seen so far, but give him some time to settle in. He won’t hit, but they didn’t bring him in to hit. He has struggled so far, but he is their best option because he at least is — allegedly —very good defensively. Kevin Newman is their other option, and I am not sure that is a viable option, either. The Pirates needed to go get a shortstop in the offseason and didn’t.

BustedLockerPodcast, @bustedlocker: Can you pinpoint the exact time five-inning outings became “brilliant” in Major League Baseball?

Zeise: Yep. It was just about the time that analytics took over the game. That’s when everything that used to be conventional wisdom was deemed to be old, outdated or prehistoric, which is silly. Starting pitchers, the best ones, still are counted on to go deeper than five innings.There aren’t enough good relievers for teams to rely on their bullpens to go four or five innings every night. It is a bad formula.

Advertise with us

Louten Franci, Youngstown: Another injury for the Penguins? Is there something going on with the Penguins? Is the training staff not doing something right? Why are there all these injuries this year? Is it just bad luck? They not only are losing players, they are losing key players.

Zeise: I just think it is bad luck. None of these injuries seems to be of the pulled muscle or soft tissue type. They all seem to be injuries that have come in the context of playing and as a result of contact. That suggests that it is just one of those years where things go wrong. That doesn’t mean it will continue into the playoffs, though. The Penguins need to get Kris Letang and Evgeni Malkin back, as well as Brian Dumoulin. I don’t think any of these injuries were preventable. It is a contact sport and that means guys will get injured.

nolan hindman, @nolanhindman: What does Pitt basketball do with their three open scholarships?

Zeise: The good thing about Jeff Capel is he has said he isn’t just taking a player to fill a scholarship. I do believe he will get a big man, and I bet he uses one of the scholarships to bring in a graduate transfer. He needs to add a little experience to the mix. The third scholarship could go unused if they don’t find someone that fits what they need.

George Trasti, Moon: Where do you think Cameron Johnson will get drafted? Is he a lottery pick?

Zeise: He is projected as a mid-second-round pick. I would think that is about right. He is an excellent shooter with a lot of length, but he is a bit of a one-trick pony. His size and ability to shoot, though, are both NBA-level, so he definitely will get drafted and I’d expect he will find his way onto a roster somewhere.