It is one weekend of games — three games total — so there is no need to overreact or make definitive statements about the Pirates. They are 1-2 and they’ve played some great baseball at times and not so great at other times.

The two things that shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone that has paid attention, though, is that the Pirates got great starting pitching in all three games and were poor defensively in all three games.

All three of the Pirates starters — Jameson Taillon, Trevor Williams and Chris Archer — gave the Pirates a great chance to win. I think Archer needs to be more efficient and get deeper into games than just five innings, but he shut out the Cardinals for the five innings he pitched. But this is what we expected, as the starters were supposed to be the team’s strength.

On the flip side, we knew the Pirates defense (and base running, for that matter) would be below-average, and that’s probably being kind given the way they’ve fielded the ball. The Pirates are below-average on the right side of the infield and a little closer to average on the the left side. There is nothing we have seen from the Pirates so far suggesting that characterization of their fielding is unfair.

Advertise with us

The Pirates have made errors and poor plays that don’t count as errors but lead to runs, and they have made erroneous throws. They have also allowed a few too many passed balls, so even Francisco Cervelli has gotten in on this act.

The starting pitching will be solid all year, at least from those first three starters, and while the defense will be below average, it isn’t going to be as bad as it has been so far.

One thing that cannot continue if the Pirates want to have any chance to compete for a playoff spot is the bullpen blowing leads. As columnist Gene Collier pointed out Monday, the Pirates played 161 games last season and lost the game six times when they had the lead after six innings. They have done it twice in the past three games.

Some of that has to do with the defense, I get it, but some of it also has to do with relievers not getting the job done. And that cannot happen because the bullpen is supposed to be a team strength. If the bullpen isn’t a strength, we can all go home now because there is nothing left to see this season.

The formula for the Pirates winning games is simple: get a good, strong start from your starter and then make it really difficult for teams to come from behind in the later innings. This isn’t a team blessed with a great lineup that is going to score a ton of runs.

Advertise with us

Pitching is the key to almost any team’s fortunes, but the Pirates — and any team that lacks power and isn’t going to score a lot — especially need to pitch well to have any chance of winning any game.

Kyle Crick was really good for one inning, but he was only in the game for one inning, Richard Rodriguez and Francisco Liriano created a mess in the seventh inning and gave the Cardinals life, but then Keone Kela came in and was brilliant cleaning it up. Nick Burdi then created another mess and Felipe Vazquez had to come in and clean up the eighth.

Vazquez is the Pirates’ best pitcher and there is no reason to worry that he won’t be dominant. Monday, however, he had a chance to shut the door in the ninth and he didn’t get it done. It is true his defense let him down as Erik Gonzalez made an error and Gonzalez made a bad throw on an attempted double play. Vazquez then threw a wild pitch that allowed Paul DeJong to get to second.

All of that is true, but there is no law that says Vazquez has to then give up an RBI double to Jose Martinez that ties the score. Vazquez is the master of striking guys out in big spots and getting outs and protecting one-run leads. He will do it all this season, but Monday he didn’t.

Steven Brault and Nick Kingham also pitched, neither particularly well, and Brault took the loss.

Advertise with us

I’m not worried about Vazquez at all. Kela is excellent, too. I think Crick has been very good since he’s arrived, as well. That’s three pitchers the Pirates have in their bullpen they can count on and will count on.

The issue is Clint Hurdle needs more than three relievers he can trust or it is going to be a long, long year. The bullpen needs to be better than it has been because the Pirates cannot and will not win many games if they can’t hold leads handed to them by the starters.