The Pirates finished 25th in baseball with 157 home runs last year. They then made almost no moves in the offseason to address that deficiency. So instead, management has spent the spring telling people that basically the same group of players is capable of much more.

“As you look around the club, [Gregory] Polanco is starting to come into his own,” general manager Neal Huntington said Tuesday in an interview with 93.7 The Fan. “[Starling] Marte is a guy who’s hit 20 in the past. Polanco hit 20 last year before the injury and was really turning into that man that we’re excited about. Josh Bell’s hit 26 and has the capabilities of hitting 30-plus. [Colin] Moran has got into his power in 2017 in the minor leagues.

“[Jung Ho] Kang is a guy who in his best years is a 20-plus home run guy. Adam Frazier started to get into some power. Corey Dickerson, there’s more power. This is a guy who’s hit 30 in the past that hit in the teens last year. Getting more consistency out of him. So it may not be one guy who’s going to hit 40, but we’ve got a number of guys who have the ability certainly to hit 20 if not in the teens.”

That sounds great, but there are two problems with this argument.

Advertise with us

The first is that the 20-homer potential he’s touting doesn’t meet a meaningful benchmark of power in baseball’s current homer-happy environment.

Consider, for example, the Philadelphia Phillies. They finished 15th, smack in the middle of MLB’s 30 teams, with 186 homers last year. They had four players hit more than 20, and one player hit more than 30. It wasn’t nearly good enough. They finished with a worse record than the Pirates at 80-82.

The Chicago White Sox finished right behind the Phillies, in 16th with 182 blasts. Five of their players hit at least 19 homers, and they went nowhere, finishing fourth in the AL Central with a dreadful 62-100 record.

It’s the teams with multiple true boppers that had the most success. Eight of baseball’s 12 playoff teams last year ranked in the top 10 in homers with at least 205 each. Of those:

● All of them had at least one player hit 30 individually. In fact, all but one had at least one player hit 35.

Advertise with us

● Four of the eight had multiple players hit at least 30.

● Six of the eight had no fewer than three players hit at least 25.

So when Huntington says “it may not be one guy who’s going to hit 40,” he’s essentially highlighting a problem he’s failing to recognize. Even if the Pirates are lucky enough to have a half-dozen guys hit 20, they’re still going to struggle to keep up with, say, the Milwaukee Brewers, who had three players account for 103 homers by themselves en route to winning the NL Central.

The second problem with Huntington’s argument is that even if 20 were a significant benchmark, it’d be asking a lot to have five or six players reach it when few of them have demonstrated a consistent ability to do so.

Take Marte, for example. The veteran outfielder did set a career high with 20 homers last season, but he’s rarely come close to that total in his seven seasons. He had 19 blasts in 2015, but otherwise didn’t hit more than 13 before last year.

Advertise with us

Dickerson’s profile is also hit-and-miss. Not only has he not hit 30 homers, as Huntington said, but he’s hit more than 25 just once in six big-league seasons. He had a respectable total of 24 in two others but also managed just five in 69 games as a rookie in 2013 and 10 in an injury-riddled 2015 campaign.

Point being, these guys have shown an ability to hit for a fair amount of power. But they are not reliable home run hitters. Nor is Polanco, who’s topped the 20 mark just twice in five seasons.

Throw in the uncertainty surrounding young players like Moran, Bell, Frazier and a total wild card like Kang, who’s missed the past two seasons with off-field issues, and its questionable that most or all of that group can meet or exceed the 20-homer threshold at the same time.

It is uncommon to see career years up and down a lineup. Dickerson and Bell are themselves perfect examples of this reality, as they totaled just 25 homers combined last year. Someone, and likely multiple players, will have down years, too.

That reality may not, ultimately, sink the Pirates in 2019. There’s a reasonable argument to be made that the club’s strong pitching staff can suffice if the offense, aided by even a modest boost in homers, can improve from 20th in runs scored to around league average.

Advertise with us

The problem with Huntington’s comments is the way they conflate ability with reliability. The Pirates don’t have much of the latter, they did not make any tangible attempt to address that problem, and Huntington will have to own those decisions if the offense falls short of expectations.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.