Neal Huntington is not a fan of projections that say his team is mediocre. He’d rather talk, as he did last July, about the upside of his fresh faces.

“When you have good, young players, you have more variability,” he told reporters. “When it works in a positive direction, you have a chance to be one of those teams that achieves more than most people expect.”

The 2018 Pirates didn’t. They finished right around where popular statistical modeling said they would, a middling 82-79, and the projections for individuals were mostly on the money, too.

The models for this year are calling for more of the same. Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS projections are the most well-regarded in the industry, and their view of the 2019 Pirates, released earlier this week, is a dim one. He writes at Fangraphs:

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh is excellent at finding just below average to average talent for peanuts, and average or better talent for whatever is a little bit better than that (perhaps Chex Mix?). It keeps the Pirates from ever truly returning to the Kingdom of Reekdom they reigned over from 1993 to about 2010. Having a roster Ryanfull of free one-win players, two-win players who are paid like one-win players, and three-win players who are paid like two-win players means you have a highly efficient roster. But it’s a highly efficient roster that will generally win between 77-85 games.

Seems like a familiar big picture. Dig into the individual projections, though, and there are some interesting nuggets relevant to the position battles we’re likely to see play out during spring training beginning next week. Here are some of the highlights.(Note: Projections for players likely to spend time in the minors are for equivalent production.)

Shortstop

In the absence of an impact free agent signing between now and Opening Day, Erik Gonzalez and Kevin Newman are the team’s best options to replace Jordy Mercer. ZiPS has a clear preference for Newman. His projected triple slash line of .261/.307/.349 certainly doesn’t jump off the page, but the model loves his glove and feels his value will add up to a solid 1.5 wins above replacement. That’s a half-win better than Mercer’s mark last year and more than a full win better than Gonzalez’s 0.4 WAR projection for 2019. Huntington has spoken highly of both players, but it looks like Newman should be the favorite if he can put together a competent spring.

Third base

Most have expected that Colin Moran and Jung Ho Kang will compete for the at-bats in the hot corner, but ZiPS likes a third candidate. A lot. The model projects prospect Ke’Bryan Hayes would produce 1.8 WAR at the position with a full year in the majors, thanks in large part to his highly touted defense. That’s only a hair behind Kang’s projected 1.9 WAR and slightly ahead of Moran’s 1.7. Hayes spent all of 2018 at Class AA Altoona, so it’s hard to envision him making the big club out of spring training. He’s probably destined for Class AAA Indianapolis for at least the first few months of the season. With a solid showing in Bradenton, he could put both Kang and Moran on notice, though.

Advertise with us

Starting rotation

ZiPS really likes the group’s top four of Jameson Taillon, Chris Archer, Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove, projecting they’ll all post ERAs of 4.06 or better and be worth between 1.7 and 3.1 WAR. Beyond that? It really doesn’t like the options to be the fifth starter. It expects no one in the group of Clay Holmes, Jordan Lyles, Steven Brault and Nick Kingham to post an ERA better than 4.53 or be worth more than 0.5 WAR. Rather, it likes top prospect Mitch Keller most, projecting a 4.11 ERA and 0.7 WAR. He will probably start the season in the minors, but don’t be surprised to see him take a step up quickly if the others struggle to assert themselves.

Outfield

We don’t know how long Gregory Polanco will be out with the shoulder injury he suffered last September. We do know ZiPS sees Lonnie Chisenhall as a competent replacement. The model calls for him to post a triple slash line of .267/.324/.422 and be worth 0.9 WAR. Beyond him, ZiPS projects solid years from Starling Marte and Corey Dickerson. It sees them as the Pirates’ two most valuable position players, projecting values of 3.2 and 2.8 WAR respectively.

Miscellaneous infield 

Advertise with us

The model sees no real contest at second base. It projects a solid glove and a slash line of .274/.335/.408 will make Adam Frazier the most valuable player in the entire infield at 2.2 WAR. ... It’s also calling for a bit more power out of first baseman Josh Bell, projecting he’ll bump his homer total from 12 to 17.

Bullpen

Not many surprises here. ZiPS likes Felipe Vazquez and Keone Kela to be dominant at the back end and the combo of Richard Rodriguez and Kyle Crick to provide between a half and full win of value in the middle innings.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.