LAS VEGAS — Wade Miley went through the whole process before starting Game 5 of the NLCS for the Milwaukee Brewers. He appeared, as starting pitchers do, at the press conference the day before. He warmed up in the bullpen before the game. Then he walked Los Angeles Dodgers leadoff man Cody Bellinger on five pitches and his manager, Craig Counsell, took him out.
Insanity, at least prior to this season. But a strategy that the Tampa Bay Rays embraced — and succeeded with — found its way into other rotations and even the postseason. Now the Pirates are considering using this strategy, which is referred to as the “opener,” after their trade of Ivan Nova Tuesday left them without an established fifth starter.
“We’ve got some things to work through,” general manager Neal Huntington said on the second day of the winter meetings at the Mandalay Bay Resort and Casino before stumbling into the inevitable, unintentional pun. “We’re not committed to the opener, but we’re open to the idea.”
For more than a century, starting pitchers worked the majority of the game. Back when men were men and ulnar collateral ligaments were made of adamantium, they routinely pitched all nine innings. As starters began making more and more money, and clubs became savvy to their dip in performance as they pitched deeper into games, managers in recent years have removed starters earlier in favor of hard-throwing relievers.
The opener takes that strategy one step further.
An opener — so named because it is opposite of the closer and not a true starter — pitches the first inning or two of a game. Another pitcher then enters in relief, but pitches the next three to five innings.
Read More
The Rays first deployed the strategy on May 19 against the Los Angeles Angels. Right-handed reliever Sergio Romo “started” the game and struck out righties Zack Cozart, Mike Trout and Justin Upton. Lefty Ryan Yarbrough pitched the next 61/3 innings and only faced that righty-heavy top of the order twice.
“You’ve got to have the right personnel to do it,” said Toronto Blue Jays manager Charlie Montoyo, who spent 2018 as Rays manager Kevin Cash’s bench coach in Tampa. “And the Rays did it.”
The opener gives teams who don’t have five viable starters an advantage in two ways. It allows teams to gain the platoon advantage, as the Rays did by matching a righty against three righties. Miley was an extreme example, but it let Counsell match the left-handed Miley against the lefty Bellinger.
And it prevents the starter from facing the top of the order, the most dangerous part of the lineup, for a third time, when pitchers are fatigued and batters have seen their stuff twice already. Last year, batters had a .700 on-base plus slugging percentage when facing a starter the first time. That increased to .731 the second time through. The third time through the order, it was .784.
“We’ve used our personnel to look at it differently,” Counsell said. “Maybe there’s six outs here. Maybe there’s nine outs here, and there’s four outs here. That’s really kind of the things probably we’re thinking about more.”
The opener also provides a cheaper answer than finding an established starter. Good starting pitchers are hard to find and thus rewarded handsomely. So are closers. Openers, as of now, are not, and they are new enough that the arbitration system and free-agent market have not had a chance to value them. Pulling this off also requires convincing the pitching staff to play along.
“If we go in that direction, it will take some conversations,” Huntington said. “It will take some explaining, it will take some buy-in, not only from those that are involved but from those that are around it. The success that people are having elsewhere helps, but the long-term financial ramifications, that’s not a driving factor, but we do have to be cognizant of it.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.