If it’s seemed at times this season like every good thing the Pirates do is balanced out by a bad thing, it’s not just you.

A study by FiveThirtyEight.com published Monday found that the 2018 Pirates as closer to average than any team in the modern history of baseball. Add up their 64-67 record entering Tuesday, their nearly dead-even scoring differential and their undistinguished performance in a few other key areas, and author Neil Paine writes that, statistically, they’re Major League Baseball’s most mediocre bunch since at least 1901.

Their lack of distinction also holds up very well across the sports spectrum, too.

Using a formula that included subtle tweaks for each sport, Paine found that the Pirates are the most average of any team in the four major professional leagues this year. And since 1971, only the 1984 Cincinnati Bengals, 1976 Vancouver Canucks and 2008 Nashville Predators have been closer to equilibrium in their respective leagues.

Advertise with us

Of course, the Pirates’ path to this point has been a winding one. There was a torrid start to the season followed by a prolonged lull, then an 11-game winning streak preceding an August-long funk. At times, they’ve looked like a playoff team. At others, fans have called for them to be completely broken up.

It’s that streakiness that could put their historic run in jeopardy over the last month. The 1923 Brooklyn Robins are the next most average MLB team on Paine’s list, and they finished 76-78 with a run differential of plus-12. Another streak one way or the other for the Pirates, and they’ll be just another ordinary baseball team.

If you’re rooting for them to retain their title, though, take heart. General manager Neal Huntington has been telling us they’ve been projected to win 78-82 games. He’s designed a team built for this kind of run, and the only thing we have to fear is that it might overperform like he hoped it would.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.