Bill Brink: Good morning and welcome to today's Pirates chat. We'll get going in a minute. Thanks for the questions, and keep them coming.
Bill Brink: OK. Here we go ...
Austin: When should A.J. Schugel and Nick Burdi be ready to join the team?
Bill Brink: We'll know more on both of them this afternoon, when we talk to director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk. Schugel has made three appearances with Indianapolis since shutting down his rehab, but given how much trouble his shoulder has given him, the Pirates will probably be cautious. Burdi had a rehab complication but has pitched twice for Indianapolis since. I'd bet both could come up on or around Sept. 1, when rosters expand.
Bill Brink: Keep the questions coming, but we're gonna pause the chat for a minute. I have to write a quick story about the 2019 schedule, which was released. I told Manfred to wait until after the chat but he did not listen. Pirates open at Cincy, home opener against the Cards.
BobbyToledo: Has the team given up on Hurdle?
Read More
Bill Brink: Don't think so, no.
Austin: Also, do you think guys like Kevin Kramer and J.T. Brubaker could receive a September call up?
Bill Brink: Kramer, almost certainly, given what he's done this year and his defensive versatility. I think Brubaker could as well and he would deserve it but it depends how they want to handle his innings, who they want to take a look at in the bullpen, etc.
Billy: what are your thoughts on the bucs essentially mortgaging their future for a guy who plays every 5 days?
Bill Brink: For years, fans wanted the Pirates to make the big move. Now they do, and they've mortgaged the future. I disagree with that notion. They have Archer under control for three more years. Glasnow was a middle reliever and Baz is 19. I like the move now, after watching Archer, same as when they made it.
Tonylexus: Should we expect kang to be on the team next year?
Bill Brink: I don't think so, no.
Tonylexus: How safe is hurdles job at this point.
Bill Brink: Safe. He signed a four-year extension last September.
Blair: We can assume the Pirates are out of a playoff spot his year. Where do they need to look to add this off season and is signing Dickerson long term part of their plans?
Bill Brink: They'll need a shortstop. Past precedent suggests they won't open the year with Newman as their shortstop, and Mercer and Hechavarria are free agents, so they'll need someone there. Also a lefty reliever.
Bill Brink: As far as Dickerson, I don't know for sure yet whether he's in their long-term plans but he's done well here and they don't have a left fielder for 2020 (maybe Jason Martin or Bryan Reynolds are ready/healthy, maybe not) so they will probably think about it.
Casey: Inconsistent hitting is this team’s MO. Who should the Pirates go after this winter to solve that??
Bill Brink: I haven't done a deep enough dive into free agency/players who might be available in trades to have a good answer just yet; I usually get to that as the end of the season and free agency get closer. Middle infield will need to be priority, I would think.
Harrison: Do you see Joey Cora lasting past this season? His decisions at 3rd base seem to be becoming a problem.
Bill Brink: If it were just the baserunning, or the defense, that'd be one thing, but he's in charge of both, and both have been subpar this year. If there were changes made, that one would make sense.
Paul or Phil: do you expect any expiring contracts to be moved before Sept 1st?
Bill Brink: If they continue to fall out of it, possibly, but both Mercer and Harrison (Harrison's not on an expiring contract but he's got club options for 2019 and '20) are banged up, and they might want to pick up Freese's option, so it's unclear.
Morty: what's the organization's assessment of Archer thus far? He still hasn't produced a single outstanding start and hasn't been appreciably better than any other starter in the rotation aside from slumping Kingham. Buyer's remorse?
Neal H: So I finally made a big boy trade, and initial indications are not good. Please tell me 1) Archers era will get below 4.5 at some point, and 2) meadows will just be average, and 3) Glasnow will return to being Glasnow?
Morty: Who will start 2019 home opener? Has Archer earned that right just because they mortgaged future for his mediocrity?
Morty: Hard to argue Pirates have ruined Archer, but have they helped him at all? I'm unimpressed
Bill Brink: I get it. I watched Archer's starts too and I know what the numbers are. For the first, he was on a new team working with his fifth catcher in five starts; he had food poisoning for the second; the Minnesota start was not great; and he got hurt and left early in the fourth. His batting average on balls in play, his FIP and his strikeout history suggest he'll be better. I know he's not pulling a J.A. Happ and lighting the NL Central on fire, but give him a minute.
Don : Heard Bucs are in talks to bring cutch back.. any truth to that???
Bill Brink: I have not seen that reported anywhere nor have I heard it myself. He was reportedly placed on revocable trade waivers and could be traded, but I would be surprised if the Pirates were involved.
Paul or Phil: What can we make out of Colin Moran?
Bill Brink: Excellent question, and I don't know that we have a good handle on it. He's got a strong, accurate arm and handles balls that he can get to, but the number of balls he can get to is limited. Right now, he's slightly below league average as a hitter. There was more power last year, but that was in the Pacific Coast League, so who knows.
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Sam: I read a story recently on ESPN about a new position many teams were starting to hire in MLB--former players to serve as conduits between the FO and players regarding analytics. Do you the Pirates employ anyone to a similar position?
Bill Brink: The Pirates employ people to assist the players and coaches with analytics, and they employ former players in the front office like Jamey Carroll and Kevin Young. I don't know that they specifically have one point person for this, but they do have similar personnel in place.
Bill: Any word on Marte??
Bill Brink: Nope. Clubhouse opens at 3:30.
Rob: Who's the odd man out for the rotation next year (yes, time to start looking into next year unfortunately)? Seems like Taillon, Musgrove, Archer, Williams,.....Nova/Kingham/Kuhl?
Paul or Phil: Is Archer-Jamo-Trevor-Musgrove-Nova cemented in as the 2019 rotation?
Bill Brink: I would say Taillon Archer Musgrove Williams Nova for next year, given that Kuhl's coming off an injury. They could move Nova in his walk year if things don't go how they want, or to clear a spot for Kuhl or Mitch Keller.
Sam: Do you see any chance the Pirates pick up Kang's option for next year? He hasn't played in 2 years, but if he can actually play, it's a steal...
Bill Brink: At $5.5 million, no, I don't.
BobbyToledo: Well, has Marte, at the very least, given up on Hurdle?
Bill Brink: He gave up on two plays, for sure. I don't know if he did so because of the manager.
Ryan : I know the Pirates just signed Huntington and Hurdle to four year extensions, but why is Huntington never held to the fire for the pirates poor player development ? Watching the Braves and all of their young talent only makes things worse. All the pirates ever seem to promote are average to below average players.
Bill Brink: Nutting and Coonelly must have felt that Huntington was the best person to move the team forward. Otherwise they wouldn't have extended him.
Michael: I read articles that say the 2109 Pirates’ starting lineup is “set” except for the middle infield. With the offense at times being offensive, and hitters disappearing for weeks at a time, how would there not be more consideration for change?
Bill Brink: I think we can fall into a bit of recency bias here. The offense has been nonexistent for six games, but it's been fine throughout the course of the season. It is set in the sense that there are currently players on the roster who play all the positions, but who knows? Cervelli has had head injury issues. Bell has taken a step back. Moran is a league-average hitter. What's on paper now doesn't necessarily mean that's what they'll roll with.
Wayward: I have always thought of Hurdle as a solid manager but when is he, or someone, held accountable for the poor fundamental play in all aspects of the game (base running, defense, situational awareness)? This seems to be a hallmark if the bulk of his Pirates teams.
Bill Brink: You make a good point. On one hand, the players are the ones not executing, not Hurdle or the coaches. But does that mean the coaching staff needs to find a different way to relay information and teach, because what they're doing isn't working?
Clint H.: How many games will the pirates have to win to get 2nd wildcard?
Bill Brink: They're 63-64 and 6.5 games out. If the Cardinals (70-57) and Brewers (70-58) play .500 ball from here on out, which is unlikely, and everyone above them does too, the Pirates would need to win 89 games.
Bill Brink: They'd need to go 26-8.
Bill Brink: I think. I was told there would be no math.
Paul or Phil: I see the 2019 schedule has the Pirates at the Mets in late July. By that time can we expect Keith Hernandez calling a game where Newman and Kramer are the middle infielders?
Bill Brink: That would be a good assumption given what we know right now.
Martin Reynolds: Who has the more tools and/or potential, Martin or Reynolds?
Bill Brink: The prospect rankings think a little more of Reynolds, and while that's not the end-all, be-all, Reynolds is a switch-hitter with a little bit of a better arm, so I might lean toward him.
Sam: Now that it appears Brault won't be out of options at the end of the year, does he open the year in the bullpen next year? It's pretty crowded, and not as if he's performed great.
Sam: You didn't mention Kingham, who's out of options; does he open in the same role as this year's Brault and Glasnow?
Bill Brink: They could both get long relief roles, but you're right, it's getting crowded. They could also see if someone is interested at the end of next spring.
Joe: If a team is truly trying to win a championship and have the opportunity to claim someone on waivers, even if the intention is only to block your competition from having a chance at a player, why would you not do that? Why let someone like Daniel Murphy and Matt Adams go by so that another team can claim them?
Bill Brink: I haven't asked anyone in the organization this yet. My guess would be some combination of taking on the payroll and balancing playing time. But those guys would help most teams, and if the Cubs and Cardinals got them, now they'll hurt the Pirates.
Paul or Phil: In your opinion, do u think the Pirates did well in the return they got from both Cutch and Cole trades?
Bill Brink: I think they did reasonably well for both. Possibly better for McCutchen given how the industry perceived his value, which is different than how Pirates fans perceive him. Crick looks great and Reynolds has potential. Musgrove was a great acquisition, but Feliz has bombed. Moran, tough to tell. Solid, but unspectacular, and of course we see what Cole is capable of.
Sam: In your opinion, is it right to take a home team away from a team, albeit for a wonderful event like the Little League World Series game?
Bill Brink: I go back and forth on this. I was there last year and it was awesome. I think everyone had fun, and growing the game sometimes can take precedent over one of 162. But I get the concern about losing a home game (Pirates got $$$ for lost gate, but they still had to travel) and the fact that it looks like it might be five teams (Pirates, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, Nationals) who do this every year if they keep doing it.
depressed: The Pirates should fire Jeff Branson today and promote the Indy hitting coach Ryan Long as interim coach and then re=evaluate after the season. Agree? Too many inconsistent hitters on this team and too many regressions including Josh Bell.
Bill Brink: I don't know on that one. Without having spent time around Ryan Long this season, I don't know if he's behind some of the performance in Indy or not, or if that would translate.
Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.
Sam: bWAR, fWAR, WARP?
Bill Brink: bWAR because it uses RA/9, not FIP. I like FIP for what it is, but I think WAR should be based on what's happened, not what should have happene.d
Paul or Phil: Cervi or Diaz in 2019?
Bill Brink: Both.
Paul or Phil: Does Adam Frazier have a starting spot in 2019?
Bill Brink: Probably for a little bit, yes.
Josh: What is the reason for my power slump? The league catching up to my weaknesses?
Bill Brink: Is this Harrison or Bell?
Bill Brink: I kid.
Bill Brink: Tough to tell. Most of the plate discipline numbers are the same. Hard contact has decreased, but so has soft contact.
Bill Brink: That's it for today, thanks for all the great questions and the patience while we took a break. We'll do it again next week, hopefully over some St. Louis BBQ.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.