Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Bingo Smith and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
JosABank, @theJoshBanks: How are the Pirates so consistently bad at the things that should be free, fundamentals, base running, situational hitting? Do they not value these things or do they (gasp) actually think they’re good at those things?
Starkey: Let me first refer you to my friend John Perrotto, longtime baseball scribe who owns and operates “The Perrotto Report” newsletters. Sometime during Sunday’s game, when the Pirates miraculously overcame themselves and the Chicago Cubs to win (and actually score more than one run), Perrotto tweeted the following:
Worth repeating something a scout said to be about the #Pirates recently. "They have absolutely no attention to detail. They're very sloppy." #MLB
— John Perrotto (@JPerrotto) August 19, 2018
Could any rational human being disagree?
All teams experience breakdowns in fundamentals. I get that. We watch the Pirates every day, so we tend to obsess over theirs. I get that, too.
But guess what? The mental errors are real. And frequent. They measure these things nowadays, or at least try to, and you probably won’t be surprised to see this example: Baseball Prospectus rates the Pirates as the third-worst base-running team in the National League, behind only San Francisco and Washington.
Read More
The stat is called “BRR” — base-running runs — and the site explains it as measuring “a player's contributions on the base paths based on activity during the run of play, on stolen base attempts, from tag-up situations, and other advancement opportunities.” The Pirates are -4.8. They ranked in the bottom 10 in this category in 2017 and ’16, as well.
Moving to old-school defensive metrics, the Pirates have the third-most errors in the National League. They also had no range in their infield for much of the season. Not a good combination. (Ed. — In new-school defensive metrics, the Pirates aren’t much better. Four current everyday players have negative defensive WARs, per FangGaphs. Josh Bell (-12.0) and Gregory Polanco (-7.3) “lead” the way there.)
When you’re a low-payroll team, you better take care of every small detail, and the Pirates decidedly do not. In Sunday’s game alone, you saw Gregory Polanco misplay a fly ball into a double (great arm, still can’t track fly balls), the Pirates fail to retire a runner caught between second and third, the Pirates get picked off first and the Pirates fail to execute a simple sacrifice bunt.
You also saw Polanco and Starling Marte both take off (from second and third, respectively) on a ground ball to the first baseman with no outs in the sixth inning of a 1-1 game, then Marte fail to get in a rundown after his mistake. He just gave up. Oh, and you saw third-base coach “Go-ey” Cora finally tell somebody to stop — he held Polanco on third — even though it was scatter-armed left fielder Kyle Schwarber positioning himself under a fly ball.
Yes, Schwarber and his relay man later threw out Kevin Newman at home, but it took a great play by catcher Wilson Contreras to do so. Schwarber might beat you once (with lots of help), but he won’t do it twice — and if Cora sends Polanco earlier, the second play wouldn’t have mattered, if it ever materialized.
Did I miss anything?
Oh yes, Marte, who turns 30 in October, still has to be reprimanded for not trying. He jogged to first base on his first two at-bats Sunday — at which point manager Clint Hurdle should have gotten in his face and said, “Guess what? Our pitcher (Joe Musgrove) sprinted out a bunt last night. Why don’t you take a seat next to him for the rest of the day?”
On the radio pregame show Monday, Hurdle didn’t seem to like broadcaster Greg Brown asking about the team’s base-running woes.
Brown started by mentioning Elias Diaz getting picked off Sunday, then said, “Were there other base-running situations … ?”
Hurdle interrupted and snapped, “Why don’t you bring up the base-running situations you’re talking about?”
Brown should have said, “Because we don’t have enough time to get to all of them.”
Jon Linder, @LinderShowMiami: Will you buy tickets to see the 2025 touch football Pittsburgh Steelers? That’s where we’re headed. Play by play guy: “Looked like he got him with two hands” Analyst: “No. You can see the left hand misses his t shirt completely. This is a touchdown!
Starkey: I will combine this question with the next one …
Josh Herrit, @JHerrit: Has the new helmet rule effectively taken the QB sneak out of the playbook? They always go head first. How else can you do it?
Starkey: All I can say is this: The NFL’s new helmet rule is downright ruinous. We will never watch football the same way. On every play, we will wonder if somebody committed a penalty — and on every play, based on the wording of this ridiculous rule, we will probably be right. This must be changed before the season begins.
Healthypghnerd, @HealthyPghNerd: If you had to build a basketball team from 93.7 The Fan staff, who would make the cut?
Starkey: My team is on the floor …
- Center: Paul Zeise. Played college basketball at Point Park. Finally back in shape.
- Power forward: Jim Colony. Guessing he has one hell of a knee brace.
- Small forward: Poni. Counting on him for lots of steals.
- Shooting guard: Mullsy. In case we need nine straight 3s.
- Point guard: Me. I can still find the open man and get to the hoop — whether I’m in drive time or not.
- Sixth man: Vinnie Richichi (you didn’t say it had to be current 93.7 The Fan personalities). Lord willing and if the (Kyle) Crick don’t rise, Vinnie will give us some quality minutes.
Katiekelly, @ktCakes: What number am I thinking of? Hint it’s between 5 and 5,909
Starkey: 5,908.
michael griser, @steeltown67: Joe, what are your Mt Rushmores for each of Pittsburgh 3 pro teams? Pens seem very obvious but the other two are very interesting.
Starkey: I will stick to players only, excluding coaches and executives. My teams are on the floor …
Penguins
- Mario Lemieux
- Sidney Crosby
- Evgeni Malkin
- Jaromir Jagr
Steelers
- Joe Greene
- Terry Bradshaw
- Ben Roethlisberger
- Franco Harris
Pirates
- Roberto Clemente
- Ralph Kiner
- Willie Stargell
- Paul Waner
Scott Nelson, @Piratefan1970: Should the Pirates go back to 1979 and bunt every leadoff base runner into scoring position on the off chance someone else might get a hit?
Starkey: Hit? What is this concept you speak of?
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.