Ray Fittipaldo: Ok let's get the chat started. Post your questions.

Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Hi Ray.. Why not many carries for Franklin? Keeping him under the radar and hope he clears waivers? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure about that. He might be someone they want to develop on the practice squad, but it's hard to get a handle on whether he's worth it just from watching him in practices. I'd like to see him in game action. We just haven't seen much of him in that setting.

JQ: Ray - are you seeing anything to be optimistic about for the defense? Looks like anything through the middle, run or pass, will be successful against this defense. Thanks.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: To channel Chuck Noll, the Steelers defense has problems and they are many. At least that was the case in Green Bay. Listen, they were missing a bunch of starters in that game. It wasn't a true test of what they are or what they will be. However, the players who did play missed a ton of tackles and gave up a lot of big plays. That was an issue last season too. They're hoping they can change that in 2018.

Jeff M: A lot of Fitz as the primary KO returner and #2 back on Thursday. Do you believe this is an indication he has is in the lead for the RB3 right now?

Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Tomlin said not to read too much into rotations or assignments in preseason games. Toussaint might make it as the No. 3 back but it won;t be because of his kickoff return abilities. I think that's one of the more intriguing battles right now -- that No. 3 RB behind Bell and Conner. It could be Toussaint, Ridley or Samuels.

Brad B. Iowa: Do you think there is a chance Matakevich could get jumped on the depth chart by Matthew Thomas or LJ Fort?

Ray Fittipaldo: Matakevich is a good special teams player and he knows the defense. I think his spot on the roster is safe for those reasons even though he likely will never project as a starter.

Advertise with us

Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Ray a lot of Pittsburgh's "depth" got exposed last Thursday. Do you think there will be a lot of churn on the roster once teams start cutting players? Think any trades on way?

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe. I think they could upgrade at OLB, ILB and OT.

Ryno: If Bell starts this season the same way as last season, will Tomlin play Conner more until Bell gets up to speed? Assuming Conner looks as good then as he has in pre-season.

Ray Fittipaldo: Conner has looked good as a runner. I don't think they'll hesitate in using him in that capacity if they believe it will be good for the team. Bell and the Steelers offense got off to a slow start last season. They'll want to avoid that this year, but the coaches haven't tipped their hand. Maybe it will mean more Conner, but it also might mean more Bell. People forget he only had 10 carries in the opener against the Browns last year. If you want your running game and your star running back to get going you have to use him more than they did in that game. I'm not saying that was the reason for his slow start. There were other reasons. His teammates have said they weren't in synch with Bell because he missed so much of camp. I'm interested to see what their plans are.

Pammy Whammy: Hi Ray, good piece on Big Dan. What has been his biggest problem in not closing plays? Speed? Footwork? Angles? I'm rooting for him, but time is short for this drafted project player,,,,

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably just playing and getting a feel for the speed of the game. He hasn't played that much despite this being his fifth year. He can collapse a pocket. He can be disruptive. But he has to get quarterbacks on the ground. If they escape, as Aaron Rodgers did Thursday night, it doesn't do the defense much good.

Charlotte John: Hi Ray,

If the Steelers get average middle linebacking play this year, do you believe they have the potential to be very good defensively?

Ray Fittipaldo: Average linebacker play means above average players will take advantage of them. So no I don't think they can be "very good" defensively with average linebacker play. They can be good and win more games than they lose, but I don't think their defense will be among the best in the league with average linebacker play.

Greg: Should we try to trade Dobbs for Khalil Mack?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes!

JQ: Ray - Did you notice any drop in fan attendance at Latrobe this year? Huge decrease in attendance at the Family event at Heinz Field this year.....fan interest waning at all? Thanks.

Ray Fittipaldo: I didn't think the crowds were great this summer, but it rained an awful lot or threatened to rain. I'm sure that didn't help.

Ryno: Your best guess on the Steelers releasing Dobbs versus Dobbs having a phantom injury that puts him on IR?

Ray Fittipaldo: Phantom injury to IR. I've said that since April so I'm not changing my mind now even though others have picked up on the possibility.

Advertise with us

Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Barring injuries, OL depth scares me less than OLB, WR, TE. Where would you rate the weakest positional areas?

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. Lack of an experienced swing tackle is cause for concern. But I'm very comfortable with Finney and Feiler as the interior depth players. OLB and ILB are pretty weak because there aren't a lot of experienced guys there. At tight end, at least you have Jesse James is Vance McDonald is hurt.

K Dot: I know its preseason, but are you as concerned as I am about the Defense, in particular our linebacking core?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's hard not to have some level of concern after watching them give up 51 points in Green Bay.

Ryno: Has Big Dan done enough to make the team?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they need a sixth defensive lineman, and no one else has really stood out. So at this point I would say yes.

Devin B: Even as an undrafted 20-year-old, do you believe Ola has a chance to make the roster this year or eventually become a productive player?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes and yes although I believe he could land on the practice squad this year. But don't count him out for the 53-man roster just yet. It's not like the Steelers have a ton of experienced depth there. If they believe he is one of the top four OLBs they'll keep him.

Pammy Whammy: Has Bell said anything in the past about his slow start last year and why doesn't he seem to see the value in camp to prevent the same thing this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: He admitted there were some issues with missing camp last summer. But I don't think those issues were big enough for him to risk injury by coming to camp.

Advertise with us

JoeB: What's your take on the rookie class? Okorafor looks like he will be the real deal, as does Washington. But Edmunds is not impressive. He gave up 2 TDs, missed a one-on-one tackle in the open field, and gets swallowed up by blockers in run support. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: That was a rough outing for Edmunds against the Packers, but he's had a very good camp. Washington, after a slow start to camp, is coming around and looks like he'll be a contributor. Okorafor looks good too although I don't know if they feel comfortable with a rookie being the swing tackle.

Greg: Any chance it makes sense to keep 4 quarterbacks this year so we don’t have to blow a draft pick (maybe 4th round!) on another backup quarterback next year when Jones hits free agency (and wants to compete for a starting job)? It would be like gaining a free draft pick next year.

Ray Fittipaldo: They won't be keeping four QBs on the 53.

Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: What’s the word inside on Sayles? Shot to land the last DT spot on final 53... Your thoughts? Thanks

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: He flashed early in camp, but I haven't seen much of him in recent weeks. Maybe practice squad.

Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Do Chickillo and Matekevich need to pick it up the next two weeks to make the team? Neither has been impressive despite extended PT.

Ray Fittipaldo: The one thing they have going for them is they're quality special teams players. The coaches don't know sure how their competition is when it comes to their work on special teams.

Bud is Weiser: Good afternoon Ray, Dobbs has looked better at this point than Rudolph but having said that, I still think they keep Rudolph and Dobbs will be gone or practice squad. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Dobbs will be cut or placed on IR.

Advertise with us

JoeB: Jordan Berry has been terrible in the first two preseason games. Any chance the Steelers start looking elsewhere?

Ray Fittipaldo: They do have another punter in camp. Maybe we'll see him punt Saturday at Heinz Field.

Schenker: The Steelers led the NFL last season with 56 sacks and also set the team record. So with a healthy Tuitt, Watt and Hilton now having a year experience under their belt and a motivated Dupree, is there any reason they shouldn't be able to do it again and actually be MORE productive??

Ray Fittipaldo: There is a reason it was a record. It's hard to get that many sacks in a season. So no, I'm not banking on another season like that.

Livinthedream: Other than no pass rush, no run stopping and no coverage the defense looked pretty good. What say you?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm reminded of the John McKay quote from years ago when he was asked about his team's execution: "I'm all for it," he said.

Zach B: Hi Ray, Are you like me an believe a 6’7, 352 pound monster is better suited to help us stop the run at NT than an undersized NT who is better suited as the first reserve at DE to rush the passer?

Ray Fittipaldo: I have to admit that was my first reaction when I saw McCullers start vs. the Packers. He's been with the first-team defense in practice some too. But then again, Tomlin said Saturday not to read too much into who is starting preseason games. He wants to give guys opportunities.

Geo Net: Hi Ray. Do you think Marcus Allen will play this week and if so, a decent chance of making the 53?

Ray Fittipaldo: "You can't make the club from the tub." Allen has missed a lot of practice time so I'm not confident right now that he's on the 53.

Advertise with us

Zach B: Hi Ray - Tuitt cannot continue to miss sacks when they are there to be had, has he earned his massive contract in your mind?

Ray Fittipaldo: You're right. He has to start finishing those plays. Pressures are nice, but he's getting paid to get sacks.

dm from.Indiana: Hey Ray, thanks for your time. From watching both Steeler preseason games the defense and secondary seems a big concern and of course a season problem. Scoring 34 pts was great, but defense gave up 51 ! Secondly, what's your thoughts on these new helmet rules ? With people already getting tired of the NFL these new rules are going to decide alot of games outcome. And the rule of having a player standing over the center really had me confused >>> what's with that rule ? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Art Rooney II warned us at the beginning of camp that officials might throw more flags for the helmet rule in the preseason and early in the regular season in hopes of teaching the players and warning them. But I don't like what I see of the new rule. They're getting just as many wrong as they are right. I'd rather them fine players after the fact that mess with the integrity of the game. The officials just aren't getting enough of those calls correct, and that's a big problem for me. You don't want to see a game decided when an official makes a bad judgment call on the helmet rule.

Paul: Can you explain the strange fascination that the Steeler coaches have with Fitz Toussant? I get that he shows an occasional flash in practice but after 3 plus years, I think it’s obvious that he is a subpar NFL player at best. In his biggest moment he fumbled away a huge game anyway. Why must we continue to see him put in time after time even in preseason?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Toussaint has played well. I think they are comfortable with him. But I don't think he is the favorite to be the final RB on the 53. Heck, they cut him last year and put him on the practice squad for half the season. They won't be afraid to cut him again.

rob: am i crazy to think, we should just throw thomas in as the starting LB next to williams? i mean, he's alteast got a lot of speed. on that long td they had, he came out of nowhere to atleast catch up to the receiver. nice to see he didn't quit on the play. bostic is slow

Ray Fittipaldo: But does he know what he's doing on every snap? He's an undrafted free agent. That's an awful big leap for a coacihng staff to make.

K Dot: Is Dupree starting job on the line? He seemed to play down on 2nd/3rd stringers

Ray Fittipaldo: He's a first-round pick. They have to start him. I am writing about Dupree today. I'll have a story up early this afternoon. I liked what I saw from him in coverage against the Packers and I'm intrigued by him playing ILB in some packages and rushing from there. But he has to be productive as an outside pass rusher in order for the Steelers to excel and in order for him to warrant a second contract. Green Bay left tackle David Bakhtiari shut him down. He's a good player, really good. But Dupree has to start playing well against those types of players. I'm willing to give him a pass for Thursday night. He missed the previous week with a concussion and only had a few practices to get ready for that game.

Advertise with us

GjC: Can you tell we what the coaches likes about out # 1 pick? I thought he looked slow and was beaten badly by very average receivers and tight ends in GB. He doesn’t look like he hits all that hard either

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, he's not slow. I can tell you that. He's quite athletic and he is versatile. I think he'll be a good player in time. His performance in coverage against the Packers, however, did nothing to ease my concerns about this secondary being able to cover well.

Brad B. Iowa: How high of a draft pick could the Steelers get for Dobbs?

Ray Fittipaldo: Why would an opposing team give up a draft pick for Dobbs when they could get him for nothing if he is released?

rob: what's your prediction on the OLB's they keep

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Dupree, Watt and Chickillo. Ola is making a push. I wouldn't be surprised if he's the fourth even if he's only 20 years old.

EM: I really don’t think Darius Heyward Bey should make the team. Why not keep Patterson??

Ray Fittipaldo: They might do that. We'll have to wait and see.

Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: No major injuries yet, thankfully.. but to many minor injuries.. to many guys missing to many practices... Should we be concerned? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: A little bit. It's not ideal that guys like Watt, McDonald and others have been out for so long. But the only thing that matters is their availability for the regular season games. No one will remember that they missed so much of camp if they play well against Cleveland in a few weeks.

TXSTEELER : Why are your in-game tweets always so nagatuve, even on positive plays (ie Dupree’s sack)? 13-3 last year and basically only time you tweeted in game was when things went wrong, even if team was winning

Ray Fittipaldo: I focused in on Dupree vs. Bakhtiari and saw Bakhtiari handle him, oftentimes with ease. I merely pointed out that the sack came against a backup.

AugustWest: Do Ola Adeniyi (sp?) and/or Michael Thomas make the 53-man roster? Who are the "surprise" cuts?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's Matthew Thomas and I don't know if there will be any surprise cuts. I mean, would you be surprised if Keion Adams is cut? He's never played an NFL game.

Ken: Can we give it a rest with the defense!! Last year defense was No. 5 overall and No. 7 in least points per game. Take away 7's two pick 6s against Jacksonville early on and defense would be at least 5 in least points allowed per game. 7 had 5 interceptions in Jax game early in season and 2 turnovers leading to TDs in Jax playoff game. I'm not here to bash 7 BUT the defense is much better according to the facts. You might say it was bad in run game but it was No. 10 in rushing yards per game. Defense had most sacks in history!!! Get rid of 7's turnovers in first Jax game and Steelers might be 14-2; get call correct in NE game and Steelers might be 5-1; and eliminate turnovers in Jax playoff game and Steelers win. So I am optimistic about the D in 2018. Rebuttal welcomed.

Ray Fittipaldo: Wow. A defense for the Steelers defense. Listen, I know the stats, but the players and coaches admitted the defense was lacking late in the season and especially in the playoff game. If you'd like to whistle past the graveyard then go ahead. I'll continue to do what I'm doing.

Ryno: Your evaluation on Chickillo? Does he show improvement from year to year, or has he peaked?

Ray Fittipaldo: He's their most-experienced reserve at OLB. I don't think he's future starter material, but for that role he's fine.

bruce: who has a better chance at making it, matthew thomas or damon patterson?

Ray Fittipaldo: Patterson, but Thomas has a chance too.

PS n VA: There was a lot of buzz coming into camp about the expected development of both Cam Sutton and Artie Burns, but we have not heard much lately. Have they progressed or fallen short of expectations?

Ray Fittipaldo: Burns has been solid, maybe more than solid. Sutton has come on in recent practices. Both are trending up.

K Dot: 92, 46, 20, or Fort - on defense who has the best odds at starting?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably none of them this year.

Scott: Pull the tag from Bell and trade him for kalil Mack. Roll the dice with running back by committee.

Ray Fittipaldo: If they could sign Mack to a long-term deal I'd do it in an instant and move Dupree or Watt to ILB.

Mountain Gus: Is switching sides really going to benefit Dupree? How hot of a seat is he on? Is his rear-end seared yet?

Ray Fittipaldo: This is a big year for Dupree. He knows it.

Mark in KY: I know it was still a poor performance, but to be fair the defense gave up 37 points in Green Bay. 14 of the 51 came courtesy of the offense.

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure that fact is allowing Keith Butler to sleep well. Really? Giving up 37 points in any game is OK?

AugustWest: When Cowher cut Huey Richardson in his first camp, it sent a clear message that on-field performance will be the criteria by which players are measured. Are the current coaches guilty of letting draft pedigree cloud their judgment? Based on a small sample, it seems like Dupree is being outplayed by a 20-year-old undrafted rookie from the MAC.

Ray Fittipaldo: I can't see them making that move for the opener. In the middle of the season? Maybe, but Dupree would have to be doing really bad for that to happen. He's a former first-round pick. They're not going to give up on him that easily.

Jimmy the Greek: Can the Steeler defense be "better" than it was last year if the team finishes 12-4 or worse?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sure. They might be better than last season and finish 10-6. As long as they are playing well at the end of the season, that's all that should matter.

Ken: Yes, a defense for the D!!! But my point is that the stats tell you how good it was compared to all other teams AND that there was a big contributing factor in the Jax games, namely turnovers; the turnover ratio being the most dependable predictor of the final outcome.

Ray Fittipaldo: I understand that, but the run defense was bad in both games vs. Jacksonville. They were terrible on third downs and allowed big plays late in that game. I know Roethlisberger put them in a bad spot, but the defense didn't do anything to help either.

Rich: Hi Ray thanks for your work! The Steelers lofty goal of 30 points/game last year seems like it might need ratcheted up this year, with this current defense. Agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: Do I hear 35 a game?

Taz: Is it just me or are Burnett's tackling angles just horrendous (good tackling, though, when he can engage)?

Ray Fittipaldo: I thought that was Mike Mitchell when Burnett missed Davante Adams Thursday night. Hopefully, that doesn't continue. I think he's better than that.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do it again next week.