CLEVELAND — All things — no matter how good, sweet, enchanting or spellbinding — must eventually come to an end, a fact of life that applies even to an 11-game win streak that defied every bit of logic and conventional wisdom generated up until that point about the 2018 Pirates.

The Pirates lost to the Indians, 4-0, Wednesday at Progressive Field, preventing them from matching a 12-game win streak last achieved by the club’s 1965 team.

“It just showed us that what we did early in April wasn’t a fluke,” pitcher Jameson Taillon said, reflecting on the win streak. “We were able to get back kind of to where I thought we were. Maybe we end up somewhere in the middle. But we’re definitely not as bad as we were playing there for a stretch.”

The bats that roared and befuddled opposing pitching staffs for the better part of the past month were, at least for one afternoon, silenced.

Advertise with us

Jameson Taillon on Pirates' 4-0 loss in Cleveland.

The lack of runs wasn’t even a product of missed opportunities, as the Pirates seldom put themselves in a position to score. Only once did they have a runner advance past second base — Jordy Mercer in the eighth inning — a threat that was ended with an Adam Frazier strikeout. They finished the afternoon with only three hits and, in the process, were shut out for the first time in more than a month.

Barely 15 hours after the final out of their 9-4 victory the previous night, the Pirates fielded a lineup devoid of some of the offense’s more potent forces, due in part to injury. Left fielder Corey Dickerson did not play after feeling discomfort in his hamstring while running out a grounder Tuesday night and Starling Marte left the game Wednesday after taking a 95 mph Trevor Bauer fastball to his left hand in the first inning (resulting in another injury described as “discomfort”). Without them, the Pirates were without their two leading hitters.

Between those injuries and other absences, the Pirates’ lineup for much of the afternoon featured left fielder Jordan Luplow, catcher Jacob Stallings and center fielder Adam Frazier, all of whom have been called up to the parent club from Class AAA Indianapolis within the past 19 days. That same collection of nine hitters also had three players — Luplow (.222), Stallings (.100) and second baseman Sean Rodriguez (.178) — who entered the day hitting below .225.

“I think we did the best we could with what we had and where we were,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “That was the fight. We had a couple of opportunities to push a little bit and [Bauer] responded.”

Together, the Pirates were regularly neutralized by Bauer, who did damage beyond depriving the Pirates of their hottest hitter only two batters into the game. Bauer entered the contest fifth among MLB players in strikeouts (with 182) and kept the Pirates at bay for large chunks of the game, finishing his outing with two hits and 10 strikeouts (to two walks) across seven shutout innings.

Advertise with us

He not only flummoxed his opponents, but he negated a strong showing from Taillon, who pieced together his third quality start in as many appearances, giving up two runs and striking out five in seven innings, albeit with seven hits allowed.

“Trevor Bauer was as advertised,” Hurdle said. “He’s had a strong season to date. I’ve seen this guy be dynamic before. He had pitches working today. The spin pitches, sometimes, it looked like a whiffle ball coming in there.”

Starling Marte discusses his hand injury in loss to Cleveland

An odd aura of invincibility and dominance that had come to define the latter half of the Pirates’ win streak was cracked relatively early.

With teammates on second and third in the third inning, Cleveland’s Edwin Encarnacion roped a single to center field, bringing both runners home. It marked the first time since the ninth inning of a July 15 win against the Brewers — the final game before the All-Star break — that the Pirates had trailed.

Over the course of 238 pitches and 159 minutes of game time, it would prove to be enough, even before a 418-foot, two-run shot from Yonder Alonso in the eighth inning that put a game still within reach firmly out of it.

Advertise with us

The end of the streak brought some disappointment, if only because players had to grapple with a feeling that had become foreign and, at a certain point, even hard to comprehend. The end of the run, however, provided an opportunity to reminisce about a two-week stretch that brought the Pirates from seven games under .500 and only 1.5 games out of last place in their division to the thick of the playoff hunt, only 3.5 games out of the second wild-card spot.

A team once left for dead is now anything but.

“That was kind of contagious,” Marte said through a translator. “Inning by inning and game by game, just seeing us rejoice together and play ball together and have fun, it was a great time.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG