Bill Brink: Good morning and welcome to this week's Pirates chat. We'll get going at noon. You can submit your questions now, and I'll get to them when we start.

Ryan: Bill, thanks for doing this - do you think NH will trade a BA Top 10 Bucs prospect for help at this deadline? (Backdoor way of asking if we'll go for big upgrade or not)

Bill Brink: They've done it before -- I believe Robbie Grossman was in the top 10 at the time of the Wandy Rodriguez trade -- but not all top 10 prospects are created equal. They would only do it if it netted them someone young, controllable and inexpensive. It's more likely that they don't. They could trade someone far away from the majors like Lolo Sanchez or Steven Jennings, but I'd bet most of the big guys stay (unless they decide to trade from a position of depth and deal one of Tucker, Newman or Kramer, but middle infielders who can hit don't grow on trees, so I doubt it).

DJ Spin: 11 game winning streaks are the time for wild eyes. How far off do you think this is value-wise, and is there a small chance Huntington could get more cavalier, with a moderate chance at the WC and a small-but-increasing chance at the division, given that he has a bunch of controllable talent already at the MLB level?

Advertise with us

DJ Spin: Whoops, I forgot to include the wild eyed trade idea: deGrom for Meadows, Keller, Kuhl, Mitchell/Sanchez, and a lottery ticket.

Bob: Do the Pirates go all in to kick the window open and pursue a DeGrom or knock on the window with an Archer deal?

Cos Nation: Number one trade chip, Meadows. The team has Luplow, Martin, Reynolds, and Swaggerty. Degrom makes them a contender. What will it take if the Mets make him available?

Bill Brink: Skies are about to open up on some parades, I'm afraid. I will never say never, having covered this team for a while now, but it is extremely unlikely they trade for deGrom. Let's start with the fact that the Mets currently have a three-way power-sharing structure atop their front office between Ricciardi, Ricco and Minaya, with Alderson out dealing with his health, so even if the Wilpons OK a teardown that involves trading deGrom or Syndergaard, the person making those decisions might not be in the organization yet. Acquiring a pitcher of his caliber requires an incredible package which the Pirates might not even be able to assemble, and if they could, the track record of this front office suggests they will not.

Morty: Brault has been awfully shaky even in mop-up detail. Does he get pushed out by BP addition?

Advertise with us

Steven Brault: What would you estimate the cost is for Keon Kela, and do you think I'd be the odd man out of the pen if the Pirates brought in a reliever or two?

Bill Brink: Probably Sadler at this point, but if they make more than one move, it's possible.

Bill Brink: Regarding Kela, he's young, controllable and consistently good, so his price will be higher than what people might think for a reliever.

HB: Were the pirates in on nathan eovaldi because it doesnt seem like the red soxs gave up much for him.

Bill Brink: They liked him a few years ago, so I'd have to imagine they checked, but I don't know to what degree.

Advertise with us

Morty: Are there realistic positional upgrades for Pirates or will Neal ride and die with current middle infield?

Bill Brink: Whit Merrifield would make some sense but I think he'll cost more than the Pirates are willing to part with.

BobbyToledo: National pundits say the Pirates can't contend even with this streak, but aren't they forgetting the Buccos were in first place for the first month and a half? Even if they approach that level of play the rest of the way, they surely have a chance. A starter, a reliever and maybe a backup catcher? Is that too much to ask for to make a run?

Bill Brink: It might just be too much to ask for. They made those types of moves, in volume and scope, in 2015, when they were among the best teams in baseball. I don't know that they'll do it now given that even with their streak, they're four games better than .500 and six games out of first. But six games out with a lot left to play, including a bunch head-to-head against the Cubs, is not much, and if they made those moves they'd have a shot.

Morty: If Pirates carry hot streak into August will fans get over their collective disdain for Nutting and support team? TV ratings suggest boost to this year's poor attendance maybe less 'bandwagon' than weak commitment to protesting

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: I learned long ago never to try to speak for the fans, though it is important to my job, to an extent, to try to understand their thinking. My guess would be, they'd be happy that the team is doing well (the result) but not pleased with the trades of McCutchen and Cole and not signing a free agent (the process).

Austin: With the recent news of the pirate being buyers, do you think that takes out the possibility of Mercer, JHay, Nova, or Freese being dealt?

Bill Brink: At this point, I could see it only in conjunction with an upgrade elsewhere.

Ryan: Thanks for the response, and agreed. Though past precedent indicates future performance, looking at this stretch in a vacuum, what's the biggest addition you think NH could make to the team?

Bill Brink: It'd be hard, but second base could use help. Harrison has a .234/.276/.324 line since June 1.

Advertise with us

Dinosaur: What is the front office going to do in the next week to show the fans that they are interested in winning and winning now? I hope they don’t miss out on this opportunity that the players gave them.

Bill Brink: I'm fascinated by this week. I remember covering deadlines in the past where the Pirates stood pat despite having a good team, and without the GM calling the week before the break a big one, and without them winning 11 in a row. I have to imagine at least some bullpen help is coming.

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Morty: Is Tampa far enough back to consider moving Archer (19 GB in division / 9.5 in WC)? He's the evergreen rumor mill player who never seems to get dealt?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: That second sentence is a perfect description of Archer in trade rumors. I won't believe they move him until they move him, although they did just move Eovaldi.

Constanza: I have trouble keeping this straight. Kramer has the steady glove and Newman has the pop, or vice versus? Where does tucker fit in? Thanks

Bill Brink: Newman is the contact hitter without much pop who plays mostly short. Kramer has the pop and plays more second. They are both in Indy. Tucker is the switch-hitter with speed and shortstop in Altoona.

OHIO412FAN: Will Dickerson be back for the NY Mets series? When do you expect Cervelli to return?

Bill Brink: I'm not with the team in Cleveland, but based on director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk's comments this morning, sounds like Dickerson could be back soon and Cervelli hasn't had any symptoms for a bit, so both could be back soon.

Advertise with us

Pusha T: What pitcher would the Pirates be most interested in (Sonny Gray, Chris Archer or J.A. Happ)?

Bill Brink: Familiarity with Happ and a lower acquisition cost might make him the one they'd be most interested in out of those three.

Chase from Boston: Who are the Pirates untaouchable prospects? Keller?

Bill Brink: He'd be the closest thing to untouchable. He's not only their top prospect but a top prospect in baseball.

The Man in the Clouds: Would you say that the same skies are opening up on the idea of Archer or Fulmer instead of deGrom? The Mets situation is so volatile that who knows what will happen, but obviously Huntington has been exceptionally conservative throughout his tenure. I just wonder if having most of the team locked in place, outside of SS and eventually LF if Meadows was moved, whether he takes a departure from that conservatism and just goes for it? We were apparently pretty in on David Price a few years back.

Advertise with us

OHIO412FAN: What are the most realistic trade targets out there for the Buccos? Is Chris Archer a pipe dream or actually someone to consider?

Bill Brink: Regarding Archer, he's in a similar category, but not quite the same level, as deGrom. If Tampa hasn't traded him yet, they're waiting for a great package, and the Pirates' inclination has not been to offer those types of packages. That could change, but we have to go off of precedent. Fulmer went on the DL last week.

Dinosaur: What’s the update on Kang? I know the injury set him back but at what point does he get the call? And if he does get called up what is his role?

Garrett: Who gets a spot on the 25 man roster first, Jung Ho Kang, Kevin Newman, or Kevin Kramer?

OHIO412FAN: Is it likely the Pirates call up Kang this year? Will he get another major league shot?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: Kang is going to start swinging a bat here soon because whatever was wrong with his wrist has settled down. He could be up in a couple weeks or possibly when rosters expand in September. He'll start as a power bat off the bench and get a start or two, and they'll see where it goes.

Bill: In your opinion what is the percentage that NH makes a deal in the next week? I think another bullpen arm needs acquired at minimum.

Bill Brink: I'd say high percentage they do something, and I'd agree that bullpen is a likely spot to upgrade.

OHIO412FAN: Are the Pirates for real, legit? I always heard the talk from Clint Hurdle before the winning streak about how they believed they had the right group of guys.

Bill Brink: I thought they might not be as good as they were through mid-May and definitely not as bad as they were in June and early July. They will probably eventually lose a game, but maybe they're closer to the early part of the season than June, and an upgrade or two and some health could make them more than that

Advertise with us

Esteban Loiza: Adam Conley is getting some hype. Is there an Adam Conley in waiting out there who maybe hasn't been shifted to the bullpen yet that Huntington can do a voodoo JA Happ initial acquisition on and surprise us?

Bill Brink: Possibly, but those are tougher to predict when teams don't have their staffs working with the guy every day and learning his pysche

Mike: What does it take for a player to be made a “top prospect”? With the way will Craig is hitting do you think he’s on his way to becoming that?

Bill Brink: That's a good question, and I won't have as good an answer as the people who do prospect stuff for a living, but I'll give it a try. It's a combination of proximity to the majors, current skills, future projection and position. Players in the middle of the diamond -- catchers, pitchers, second basemen, shortstops and center fielders -- are more valuable because they're harder to find, and players often move off those positions as they advance through pro ball. A 19-year-old with great raw ability could be ranked below a 23-year-old in triple-A because the triple-A guy has shown he can perform at a high level. It's more art than science. Craig might have some trouble getting there because of his position and his lack of a run tool, but if his bat continues to play like this, he could get there.

Wayward: Am I the only one that thinks NH should pursue marginal upgrades as in the BP rather than some grandiose SP or an impact bat? I still think this teams best years are right in front of them and any trade focused solely on win now is a little misguided?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: In the sense that they won't lose anybody of importance to free agency this offseason, you could be right. Huntington will have to weigh the long-term outlook with the fact that his team is on fire and only six games out.

OHIO412FAN: What do the Pirates need to do in order to get to the postseason?

Bill Brink: Beat the Cubs a bunch of times.

Bill Brink: (Continue to pitch well, add a reliever, get some offensive help from someone in their infield.)

Cos Nation: Alright, since you doused the Degrom dream for all of us, how about Big Game James Shields and joakim Soria. Both are rentals. Half of Shields' contract is being paid by the Padres.

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: The way Shields is pitching now he's not a huge upgrade, but he does push everyone back a spot and add depth, which is important with Kuhl out for a while (and Shields has been much better since April). Soria would make a ton of sense and they're familiar with him as well.

Wayward: Outside of Meadows and Newman, who in Indy has the highest trade value, and what could it get the Bucs?

Bill Brink: Well, Keller, but I don't think he'll be on the table. Newman and Kramer have value. The market changes by the day -- Eovaldi probably already reset it for pitchers -- so it's tough to say exactly what they could bring, and it also depends on how much the acquiring team likes them.

El Coffee: Would you look at Matz as well for a possible LHP with Happ? His talent is undeniable and he would be a great fit in our park in my opinion.

Bill Brink: I don't think they'll get Happ, let alone both of them. Matz is controllable and having both a healthy and a good season, which has been a struggle for him, so the Mets could look to capitalize, but I don't think they'll start trading their young starters without a firmer front-office plan.

Advertise with us

John: Would Tyler Eppler be a candidate for a spot start in the future? Seems to be putting together a good year

Bill Brink: I think so. He's had a nice season, better than his first go-round in Indy last year, and he's doing a better job of keeping the ball in the park.

Dinosaur: Does it help in the negation process if the team you are negotiation with is in town for series at the deadline? I only ask because a few Met’s names have been brought up in conversation.

Bill Brink: Not really. Everything is done via text and e-mail these days. Sometimes free-agent negotiations go better in person, but not trades as much.

Morty: why bring up Frazier? He's hit even worse in Indy than in Pittsburgh? Is it because Moroff was just optioned and can't be brought back yet?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: That is indeed part of it. Moroff can't come back up for 10 days unless someone goes on the DL.

Dinosaur: How will this team be received when they come home tomorrow as they haven’t been in town since the break?

Bill Brink: Given that they'll either have won 12 in a row or 11 of 12, I'd say they'll get a nice reception.

Charlotte John: hypothetical, would you trade the pieces back to Houston for G.Cole

Bill Brink: You'd have to think about it given the way Cole's pitched and the way Feliz has pitched, though Musgrove looks like a solid addition.

Buccoragg: Barring trades, who are the starting 5 pitchers next year?

Bill Brink: Taillon Nova Musgrove Kuhl Williams? I don't see much change. Keller will be banging on the door and it's possible Kingham outpitches one of them.

Cannonball: Is Dickerson starting to enter NL MVP conversation?

Bill Brink: It's wide open in the NL, and he's having a good year, but I'd still have him behind several players. If he keeps it up he could get some down-ballot votes, though.

Drew: Given the way he has swung the bat all year and the with streak he is on now, should the Pirates be looking at signing Dickerson for the near future and make sure they have depth in the outfield with Marte, Polanco, Meadows and Dickerson.

Bill Brink: I don't think so, because all three are starting-caliber players. It's tough to rotate them through. They're probably better served moving one and improving a weakness elsewhere.

Facts!: A few chats ago, a chatter made the comment that the Pirates "slashed" payroll after 2015, and you basically said there was validity to their question. This narrative couldn't be more wrong, and when I see someone perpetuate it, it bugs me. Sure, you can question whether the moves were right, but the Pirates increased payroll a lot during and after 2015. The madness needs to stop!

Bill Brink: Hi, Ethan, good to have you with us. According to the AP's reporting of season-ending salaries, the Pirates finished 2015 at $98.9 million. They opened 2016 at $98.7 million and ended it at $99.8 million. They did not slash it, you are right. What they also didn't do -- and what the answer was intended to get at, though why should I be precise with words, it's not like I write for a living -- is sufficiently add talent to a 98-win ballclub.

Bill Brink: Whoops.

Bill Brink: $95.9 million for end-of-year 2015, an increase of $7.6 million from opening day.

Cannonball: Is this winning streak saving Hurdle's job?

Mark: If Pirates make post season, does Hurdle get manager of the year?

Bill Brink: Hurdle wasn't going to get fired. He got an extension last season and short of some massive issue or insubordination I don't think this front office would want to pay two managers. Manager of the year voting is tough to quantify, but he'd probably end up in the conversation -- though, before you all come at me with torches and pitchforks, I'm not saying deservedly so.

Wayward: Given your list of next years SP, Glasnow done as a SP?

Buccoragg: Glasnow’s future as a Pirate?

Bill Brink: I'm uncertain as to what he could show them in spring training next year as a starter that would convince them to put him over one of the other guys. I'll never say never, but I see it as less likely.

Dinosaur: With the game starting in 15 minutes have you ever considered doing an in game chat?

Bill Brink: We did one several years back for the World Series and there wasn't much interest, possibly because the Pirates weren't playing in that particular World Series. Is that something you guys would like? The trick is it can't be a game I'm covering, because then I wouldn't be paying full attention to the game, and now that Liz is going Good Will Hunting on us those are fewer than in the past.

Bill Brink: Yes, I know Will Hunting worked at MIT. I couldn't think of another movie about Harvard.

Bill Brink: Stealing Harvard.

Bill Brink: Love old school Jason Lee. Anyway.

Cannonball: What do you think the chances are of the Pirates catching the Cubs? I like them to pass the Brewers in the standings over the next 15 games or so

Bill Brink: Despite losing two in a row, the Cubs are playing good ball, so it'll take some doing. They'll need to take the two-game series here next week, then do well at home in mid-August. Who knows where everyone will be when they head to Wrigley in the final week of September.

Cannonball: What does it say about Pirates ownership that the Rooney's are willing to pay Lev Bell an insane amount of money and completely overpay and Nutting does not want to pay anyone over 11 million a year?

Bill Brink: It says the two leagues operate with a different economic structure. There are several legitimate criticisms of the way the Pirates spend their money -- I've included some in my work, our columnists have written about others -- but the apples-to-oranges comparison between sports is not one I find compelling.

Cannonball: What percentage of questions do you get that you cannot use because they are pranks?

Bill Brink: It's funny, I answer some of the prank questions because I don't know they're pranks or don't get the jokes, and some legitimate questions are so bonkers I leave them out because I think they're pranks. I do get texts from friends from time to time asking why I didn't answer their questions.

Bill Brink: That's it for today, thanks for all the great questions! We'll do this again next week and dissect all the moves at Tuesday's deadline.