The prevailing thought is that the Pirates will be sellers at the July 31 MLB trade deadline. Neal Huntington continues to deny it, but he should stop. This season is going nowhere, so the team might as well try to clear space for younger players and save some money for the offseason.
The problem with that idea: What exactly do the Pirate have to sell? They don’t have enough good players to compete for a playoff berth. They need more talent, but in order to acquire it, they’d have to give up something of value.
The players with real trade value, though, are likely untouchable, which means the Pirates won’t be “sellers” as much as “dumpers.” That’s a quicker way of saying they’ll shed overpriced veteran players and salary without getting a whole lot in return.
Felipe Vazquez is one of the best closers in baseball. He has an excellent, team-friendly contract and is under control through the 2023 season. He would be an incredibly attractive piece for any contender that needs a closer or bullpen help. I’m sure he could bring back a nice haul — or maybe even a couple of solid major-league players.
It would also make sense for the Pirates to move him, since the team isn’t ready to win. A closer is a luxury for a non-contender, and trading him now wouldn’t change the outcome of this season. The Pirates aren’t likely to do that, though, because of his contract. Even if he saves 80 games a year for the next four years, they won’t have to give him a raise.
Outfielder Austin Meadows is one of the top prospects in baseball. Moving him would bring back value, but why would the Pirates do that? Like Vazquez, he is cheap and will be be cheap for a number of years. That is the kind of player they like.
Read More
Jameson Taillon isn’t having a great season. He still has been the Pirates’ best starter, though, and he’s young with a lot of upside. That would make him an attractive trade piece to a team looking for a win-now starter who could develop into a top-of-the-rotation pitcher. The Pirates aren’t likely to trade him either, and for many of the same reasons they won’t trade Vazquez or Meadows.
Once you take those three players off the table, who is left in terms of a good trade piece for the Pirates? There isn’t much, and to be honest, I’m not sure the return would even be worth the effort.
I suppose a team looking for an outfielder may have interest in outfielder Corey Dickerson, especially since he isn’t a straight rental. He has another year before he hits free agency, so a team trading for him could get a long look before deciding whether to sign him long-term. He hits well, gets on base and his defense isn’t a liability. Starling Marte is the Pirates’ best player, but his value is hurt by inconsistency and last season’s PED suspension.
Pitcher Ivan Nova has resurrected his value with his recent performances. There is definitely value in a middle-of-the-rotation veteran for contending teams. Every team needs more pitching, and teams looking to contend are willing to pay for it. He also has a reasonably low price tag, at $8.5 million per year for one more season. That isn’t a lot of risk or money for a contender.
David Freese may have some value as a right-handed veteran bat off the bench. That won’t bring much of anything in return. The same can be said of the rest of the names thrown around in trade rumors. Sean Rodriguez has no value. Jordy Mercer has little value. Gregory Polanco and Josh Bell are terrible defensively and having bad seasons at the plate. Josh Harrison has a high price tag and performance that doesn’t match. Francisco Cervelli is injury-prone and makes a lot of money.
That’s why even though the Pirates may want to be sellers at the deadline, they’ll have a tough time finding takers — unless they are willing to part ways with Taillon, Vazquez or Meadows. And that just isn’t likely.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.