Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Jason Lynch, Hazelwood: The Pirates got Felipe Vazquez into the All-Star Game and he deserves to be there. If you had to put a second player from the Pirates on the All-Star team, who would it be?
Zeise: It will probably be easier to first eliminate the players who absolutely should not be considered. The entire pitching staff, aside from Vazquez, is out. There aren’t enough fancy advanced stats out there to justify putting another pitcher on the roster. And that probably explains a whole lot about why this team is where it is. I’d say Josh Bell, David Freese, Josh Harrison and Jordy Mercer are definitely not worthy of consideration. Colin Moran has been a nice story as a rookie, but I’m not sure how many other teams in the National League would start him at third base. He is a solid player and nothing more. Gregory Polanco has woken up a bit, but again, there is no way he is worthy. That leaves, in my mind, Corey Dickerson, Starling Marte and Francisco Cervelli. I could make a case for all three, but have a space limit, so I’ll just say if it was me, I’d go with Marte based on his WAR. (FanGraphs has him at 50th among position players, ahead of guys like Kris Bryant and Matt Kemp, who was voted in as a starter.)
JT, @JTBurghProud: Since the Pirates aren't worth rooting for, which MLB team is worth my time?
Zeise: Well, if you want to root for someone else and hope they win, jump on the Yankees bandwagon. Why not, everyone else does! I’m sure if you are a Pirates fan, though, it is hard for you to root for the Yankees, Red Sox, Cubs, Dodgers or any of those other huge-market, large-payroll teams. The Astros just won the the World Series so they aren’t very interesting, either. That leaves me with one of two teams — the Indians or the Brewers. They are both small-market teams that are currently in first place. They represent hope for Pirates fans. If one of those teams wins the World Series, it proves the Pirates (with the right moves and maybe a different owner) could win some day as well.
Carlo Gambino, @Gambino_166: The Pirates are becoming unwatchable and so is the rest of MLB. Will legalized gambling create a buzz that will bring back the walk-up fan or just the degenerate gamblers?
Read More
Zeise: I don’t think so. It may help a little bit, but legalized gambling isn’t going to change the world of sports nearly as much as some people seem to believe. There are a lot of gamblers who already bet with their local bookie, and I just don’t expect a rush of converts now, just because it is legal. I expect some sort of increase in interest and ratings, but not nearly as much as others.
Greg Cullton, Morningside: If this season continues to go as it has and the Pirates finish with say, 71 or 72 wins or less, how is it possible for Bob Nutting to bring back Neal Huntington and Clint Hurdle? One or the other has to go, right?
Zeise: This is a good question. I am not one to call for people to be fired, but how could an organization maintain credibility after these past three seasons if there aren’t some major changes in the front office and coaching staff? I would think that if Nutting is forced to make a change, one of those two would make the most sense and become the fall guy.
Dan, @DanInPittsburgh: Meatballs or sausage on top of pasta? OK, actually, do you know when the Pirates get their season-ticket projections in? I’m wondering at what point of the year they will be concerned if they continue to see more cancellations than renewals. Not until after PiratesFest?
Zeise: Meatballs, without a doubt. The Pirates already know what is happening with their season-ticket base. They also know this season hasn’t helped. I think they are already extremely concerned about it and will try to address it way before PiratesFest. They just can’t continue to lose season-ticket holders every year.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.