Welcome back, mailbag readers. The Pirates are in a critical week. They need to make a reasonable run in the next week if the front office is to add to the current roster. How many games must they win? Well, we know it’s probably more than three. Let’s begin:

@RichardLitt1: Liz...when can we expect to see Kevin Newman? Thank you.

Elizabeth: I expect he’ll be up sooner rather than later. Unless something drastic happens in the next week, I believe the Pirates will try to trade Jordy Mercer before the end of the month and see what they’ve got in Newman (and/or his fellow Kevin, Kramer). If they can’t find a trade partner or don’t deal Mercer for whatever reason, Newman likely would be a September call-up.

Dane Brody: Is it time to shake up the coaching staff? Hurdle was let go in May 2009 by Colorado two months into that season, and less than two years after taking the Rockies to the fall classic. Who even is the #2? Branson doesn't strike me as managerial material and Searage has his hands full.

Advertise with us

Elizabeth: If things continue their downward spiral, one assumes there will be some changes to the coaching staff this offseason. Of course, teams sometimes need somebody to take the fall, but I don’t get the sense that the Pirates blame manager Clint Hurdle for their current struggles. I know reporters keep beating this drum, but Hurdle’s four-year contract, inked last year, indicates that he will be here for a while. The Pirates, presumably, won’t want to pay two managerial salaries, and in any case, a four-year deal seems like a vote of confidence in Hurdle’s (and general manager Neal Huntington’s) process.

As for who the No. 2 in the organization is, that appears to be bench coach Tom Prince, who has taken over managerial duties in the past year when Hurdle has been away.

@MrB_roke: Any updates on Hoglund and what may have changed re: his readiness to sign?

Elizabeth: @MrB_roke is referring to Gunnar Hoglund, a right-hander from Florida picked in the MLB draft, and not, I assume, to Gunnar Höglund (Feb. 18 1923-June 16 1984), “a Swedish actor, film director and screenwriter” whose “1964 film ‘My Love and I’ was entered into the 15th Berlin International Film Festival,” according to Wikipedia.

Anyway, Hoglund (sans umlaut) decided to attend the University of Mississippi rather than sign with the Pirates. The news was something of a 180 from an initial report suggesting — rather strongly — that Hoglund and the Pirates had agreed to terms. But then, reports surfaced that Hoglund had gone to Ole Miss to attend summer school. So, what changed? The answer isn’t clear:

Advertise with us

“We had conviction that we would be able to sign Gunnar when we made the selection but as the signing process evolved, it became clear that Gunnar viewed attending [the] University of Mississippi as the best decision for him at this point in his life,” Pirates amateur scouting director Joe DelliCarri said in a statement. “We respect that decision and wish Gunnar all the best in his future.”

Hoglund also tweeted out this statement:

There’s no evidence directly pointing to this, but Hoglund said he and the Pirates had a deal, and then he didn’t sign, so it’s possible something changed after Hoglund’s physical. Anyway, as compensation, the Pirates will receive the 37th overall pick — one lower than Hoglund went this year — in the 2019 draft.

Lee “Foo” Young: JHay’s contract…For your next chat? Here’s what it says on BRef. 2018 Contract Status: Signed thru 2018, 4 yrs/$27.3M (15-18) & 19-20 team option. If we don’t pick up his option, and I don’t think that a 2bman with a .647 OPS is worth picking up, but these ARE the Buccos, is there a buyout?

Elizabeth: Indeed, Josh Harrison has club options of $10.5 million and $11.5 million in 2019 and 2020, with $1 million and $500,000 buyouts each of those years, respectively. As my colleague Bill Brink pointed out, it seems unlikely at this point that the Pirates (or another team Harrison might be traded to) would pay that salary, opting for the buyout instead.

Advertise with us

@huffakingit: mailbag q which baseball team could use lebron best

Elizabeth: This is a great question, @huffakingit. I’m pretty sure no MLB team would turn down the opportunity to place LeBron James on their roster. But let’s say LeBron played baseball as well as he plays basketball — how good would he be?

Fortunately, baseball already answered this! In 2014, Jeff Sullivan of FanGraphs wrote a fun article about how good a baseball player with LeBron James-level dominance would be. The Answer May Surprise You. (Or not.)

In essence, James would be worth somewhere in the range of 23 and 42 WAR. He’d be a power-hitting shortstop with dazzling skills on the field who maybe also moonlighted as the greatest pitcher ever. Here’s one tidbit from the piece:

When playing the field, the guy hits better than Barry Bonds and fields better than Ozzie Smith. When pitching, the guy still hits better than Barry Bonds, and he doesn’t really ever get removed, and he allows an average of basically one run per nine innings. Craig Kimbrel has allowed an average of 1.64 runs per nine innings. This guy would be a lot better than Kimbrel, and he’d throw nine innings a game instead of one.

Of course, this is all just a fun thought experiment; as one commenter pointed out, it speaks more to the differences in the sports than James’ skills on the court/diamond.

Advertise with us

But one thing is for certain. If LeBron James played baseball, he would definitely be a Yankee.

Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BloomPG.