For the past month, there was a case to make that Chad Kuhl was the Pirates’ most consistent starter. During a five-game stretch May 23 to June 15, Kuhl’s ERA was 2.45, he struck out more than twice as many batters as he walked, and he went at least six innings in four starts.

Thursday, however, wasn’t his night. The Arizona Diamondbacks — who possessed the lowest batting average in the league and sat in the bottom half in slugging percentage before Thursday’s game — turned into an offensive powerhouse, making quick work of Kuhl and beating the Pirates, 9-3, at PNC Park.

“Just one of those nights where I felt like no matter what, I just felt like I was getting hit hard,” Kuhl said.

Chad Kuhl discusses his tough start against the Diamondbacks

The Pirates (36-38) dropped their first of four games against the Diamondbacks, who beat them twice in Phoenix last week.

Advertise with us

Kuhl survived just two-plus innings, giving up eight hits and eight runs. He coughed up a pair of homers to switch-hitter Ketel Marte and left-handed catcher Alex Avila, who entered the game with a .109 average. Five of the Diamondbacks’ hits off Kuhl were doubles or homers. Lefty Jon Jay continued his career-long success against the Pirates, doubling in two at-bats against Kuhl. Manager Clint Hurdle pulled Kuhl in the top of the third after a leadoff single and Avila’s homer; his ERA had jumped 0.80 points, to 4.56.

“Behind in counts, elevated, and the execution, location was a little more middle and up than anything,” Hurdle said. “The left-handers put the barrel on him.”

By the end of his outing, Kuhl had walked one batter and thrown 32 of his 53 pitches for strikes. So while finding the strike zone wasn’t a huge issue, the Diamondbacks managed to lay off his pitches away from the zone and jump on pitches they could hit. And they hit him hard all night, with six of their hits against him exiting the bat at more than 100 mph.

“Pitches that I haven’t been hurt on,” he said, “I got hurt on tonight.”

Indeed, Kuhl couldn’t quite pinpoint one thing that wasn’t working Thursday, and he and the pitching staff will get to work Friday to see if they can identify anything.

Advertise with us

There’s the possibility it just wasn’t his night. On the one hand, he said, the ball didn’t seem to be coming out of his hand as well as usual. On the other, location wasn’t a huge problem, and he felt he was “making decent pitches.” While his start was pushed back a day because of Wednesday’s rainout, and it wasn’t ideal that he was warming up for a start one day before, Kuhl didn’t use that as an excuse, either.

Still, Kuhl said he’s had a tell in some previous starts: He was breathing heavily before fastballs, but not before breaking pitches, potentially allowing hitters to identify what was coming. He said he and the coaching staff would look into whether something similar was occurring Thursday.

“It was a couple starts where it was really, really bad, where you could tell the difference between fastball, breaking ball,” Kuhl said. “But we kind of cleaned it up, so we haven’t really had any of these issues, but we’ll see.”

The Pirates had far less success against Kuhl’s counterpart, right-hander Zack Godley, for most of his outing. Through the first five innings, the Pirates produced just four baserunners against him, including two singles, and scored one unearned run.

The third time through the order, the Pirates hitters made adjustments. In the sixth, Austin Meadows collected his second hit — he had three singles on the day — and scored from first on Starling Marte’s RBI double. Marte’s double represented his 800th career hit and 300th RBI. Colin Moran scored Marte with a sacrifice fly to deep center field. The Pirates had runners in scoring position in the ninth but could not bring them home.

Advertise with us

“He made pitches early,” Hurdle said of Godley. “We got aggressive in some counts, tapped some balls and some swings in front of the plate, but just stayed after it, tried to stretch his pitch count up, put ourselves in a position to make a run a little bit.”

The bullpen did not give up any earned runs, allowing just two hits over seven innings. Steven Brault, entering in long relief of Kuhl, threw three hitless innings, although he walked four and hit a batter. Richard Rodriguez, making his first appearance since June 6, threw two scoreless.

Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BloomPG.