Trevor Williams divined the question before it was finished.

“Striking out more than hitting?” he interjected midway through a question that began with something about the month of April. He turned around at his locker and grinned. “I keep up.”

What Williams already knew is a statistic that has crept its way into the baseball public’s consciousness as the end of April draws near: Teams are on pace to finish the month with more strikeouts than hits. According to the Elias Sports Bureau, that has never happened in a month in major league history.

Entering Saturday, 20 of the 30 teams had more strikeouts than hits; the Pirates (232 hits, 201 Ks) were not one of them. The league-wide strikeout rate is 22.8 percent, up from 17.5 percent in 2008.

Advertise with us

The amazing part is the disparity might grow. Pitchers forced hitters to swing hopelessly despite the cold, rain and snow doing their best to monkey around with their grip.

“Nobody understands how a ball feels in your hand when you’re a pitcher when you’re out there,” pitching coach Ray Searage said. “And it’s slick. And you blow on your hand and then you go back to the ball and then it’s dried already. It’s a crazy feeling. To me, it’s like, I really have a good idea of where I want to throw this ball. I don’t know if it’s going to go there because of the grip.”

After Friday’s games, batters had struck out 6,635 times and recorded 6,265 hits. No season has ever finished with more strikeouts than hits, according to Baseball-Reference’s data, which goes back to 1871 in these categories. The smallest full-season difference was 2,111 more hits than strikeouts. Take a wild guess when.

That’s right, last season, the latest referendum on — call it what you want — the fly-ball revolution, the Statcast era, the age of launch angle, the three-true-outcomes zeitgeist.

“Guys are just trying to hit more homers,” Williams said. “Guys are trying to do damage. No one really plays for three hits to score a run anymore. Everyone’s trying to play for the big inning and string together a few homers and whatnot.”

Advertise with us

The narrative goes something like this: More precise batted-ball data in recent years allowed teams to better position their infielders, playing the percentages while also conceding a less-damaging outcome. Kyle Schwarber’s rocket between first and second base is no longer a single, but a grounder right at Sean Rodriguez, who began the at-bat in shallow right field. Meanwhile, Jordy Mercer might line up on the right side of second base, with third baseman Colin Moran standing at “shortstop.”

This leaves daylight on the left side of the infield and down the left-field line. Sure, Schwarber could bunt or poke a single past third base — known as “beating the shift” — but if he bunts or pokes a single, he doesn’t hit a homer, and most teams are OK with that.

Even the most precise shift can’t defend a double to the gap or a ball in the bleachers, so as hitters and teams figured out how to counterattack, they sought swings that would put the ball in the air and do damage. It’s not for everybody, but more and more hitters seek a slight uppercut in their swing, the better to drive pitches they believe they can handle.

None of this is new, thanks to Ted Williams. And hundreds of other players, coaches, managers and executives, but Williams provides a nice intersection. Cleveland Indians manager/shortstop Lou Boudreau shifted against Williams in 1946, putting his defenders on the right side of the infield. Williams later wrote in the book “The Science of Hitting” about the necessity of a slight uppercut so as to match the pitch’s downward angle.

The book was first published in 1970. The difference is, we can measure everything now. Statcast brought launch angle and exit velocity to the masses. More and more players are trying to put the ball in the air with authority, and coaching staffs and fans know exactly how high and how hard.

Advertise with us

“I think guys are OK with hitting a double and striking out three times, going 1 for 4,” Trevor Williams said. “Teams are OK with that approach.”

As players try to do more damage, it’s getting harder to do so. The average fastball velocity in 2008 was 90.9 mph. This year, it’s 92.7, and it peaked last season at 93.2. It will likely increase this year as the weather improves.

“It’s a scientific fact that there comes a certain velocity that you can’t watch the ball out of the hand or get a good read on it,” Clint Hurdle said. “You’ve got to guess and anticipate. And when there’s something else [like an offspeed pitch], there’s a lot of swing and miss.”

About that weather: As Hurdle succinctly put it, “It’s hard to hit when it’s cold.”

“This has been the most challenging weather I’ve ever been a part of in the month of April,” he said. “And I’m not playing.”

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.

Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.