Ah, September baseball. It’s a time for relevant teams to fight for their place in the postseason and irrelevant teams to do their best to bust up everyone else’s chances of doing cool things.
The Cleveland Indians, the small-market team that is the envy of many a Pirate fan, have won 22 games in a row, which many are calling a Major League Baseball record. They clinched a spot in the postseason with last night’s walk-off win over the Kansas City Royals. They’ve got a pretty good shot at returning to the World Series for the second consecutive season. Their Twitter name is currently just a bunch of Ws.
The @Indians are the best story in sports right now.
— Jon Morosi (@jonmorosi) September 15, 2017
The league, however, disputes the Indians’ claim to the MLB record, and here’s where the Pirates come into play.
Let’s go back to 1916: In the midst of an 11-game win streak, the New York Giants are facing the Pirates in New York. They beat the Pirates in the first game of a doubleheader on Sept. 18. The night game, however, is suspended after eight innings due to rain and darkness, with the score tied, 1-1. Back in the day, suspended games weren’t continued where they left off; they were played over.
So the next day, the Giants get another crack at beating the Pirates, and they did just that on their way to a 26-game win streak — which stands as the MLB record. Per MLB.com:
In 1916, there was no “suspension” rule pertaining to called games, where, like today, games are picked up where they left off. (In fact, that's a recent development, having only been implemented in 2007.)
Back then, games were normally replayed in their entirety if the scheduled permitted, and on Tuesday, Sept. 19, 1916, the Giants swept yet another doubleheader from the Pirates — with the first game being a replay of Game 2 the day before — and extended the streak to 14. They went on to win another 12 in a row before finally losing, 8-3 to the Boston Braves, in the second game of a doubleheader on Sept. 30.
Who knows what happens if that 1-1 game hadn’t been rained out? The Pirates maybe win, the Giants’ win streak ends at a lightly impressive but historically uninteresting 12 games, and the Indians could hold the MLB record.
Read More
While some think the Indians’ current streak should represent the Major League record, MLB historian John Thorn isn’t buying it:
“The record is 26, and that's because the [halted game] does not break the streak,” Thorn told MLB.com. “It's the second game of a twin bill after eight innings at 1-1, it started raining, there were no plate appearances and no outs recorded, and by the time it stopped raining it was dark. It's a simple matter. It's the second game of a doubleheader with no impact on the pennant race. It is a no-brainer [to call it].”
Of course, the Indians still have a chance to break the Giants’ record. Then again, that might not bode well; the Giants ended their season in fourth place in the National League, despite a 86-66 record, and did not make the World Series.
Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1750 and Twitter: @BloomPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.