The world was waiting with bated breath to see the new, improved Tyler Glasnow make his return to the major leagues Wednesday night in Milwaukee against the Brewers.
It didn’t take long for the world to see that the new improved Glasnow looked a lot the version that flamed out after 12 major league starts and a 7+ ERA earlier this season. Glasnow was demoted to Class AAA Indianapolis in June, and the hope was that a few months in the minors would help him work on his control and confidence issues.
Glasnow was dominant in Indianapolis (93.1 IP, 140 Ks, 32 BB, 1.93 ERA, 0.93 WHIP and .176 BAA) and once again proved he deserved a shot at the majors. The Pirates made the right decision to call him up and see how much he has progressed. He is way too valuable to their future for them to not know the answer.
Wednesday’s performance by Glasnow didn’t exactly instill confidence that he will be an anchor in the rotation for the next five seasons. Glasnow again struggled with control early, and as a result, he couldn’t get out of the third inning. Glasnow went 2⅔ innings, gave up four hits and five earned runs and, most importantly, six walks.
That has to be as disappointing of a development as there has been for the Pirates this season, and believe me, there are plenty to choose from. Glasnow is supposed to one of the Pirates’ best pitchers for the foreseeable future. He has all the tools and natural ability to be a dominant starter, but there are serious questions developing about whether he has the intangibles to match his talent.
Certainly it’s fair to start asking the question of whether Glasnow is a classic “Class AAAA” player. That is to say, a player who is better than Class AAA but not able to cut it in the major leagues.
Read More
Clearly Glasnow is still young enough (24) and inexperienced enough (only 13 major league starts) that the Pirates aren’t going to give up on him, nor should they. There are plenty of examples of power pitchers who take a little bit longer to develop than others, and a lot of it comes down to control of the fastball.
Glasnow will continue to get opportunities to start the rest of this season and he needs to show some progress in each of them. The Pirates, who were long ago out of the playoff chase, have no choice but to keep running him out there and giving him chances to show he can pitch at this level.
This is not just a critical month for Glasnow, it is a critical month for the future of the Pirates rotation. The Pirates need to start thinking about building a competitive team in 2018, and that starts with the rotation.
It is pretty clear that Jameson Taillon, Chad Kuhl and Trevor Williams all are capable of developing into solid major league starters. All three had the growing pains associated with being rookies (and in Taillon’s case, fighting through cancer) and all three need to develop consistency. That will come, though, as they have all had moments of brilliance and their consistency improved as the season wore on.
The Pirates have already begun to give Steven Brault some opportunities to pitch, and it has been with mixed results. Brault probably doesn’t have the stuff to be much more than a back of the rotation starter but every staff needs depth and he can provide it. Brault was brilliant in his last start (6 IP, 1 H, 1 BB, 0 R) and has shown at times he can be dominant.
The Pirates now need to make a decision on what to do with Gerrit Cole, but that decision can only come after they figure out what they have in Glasnow. If they wait too long to trade Cole, they may not get the value in return for him. But they need to make sure they can replace his production before they trade him or next year will likely be another losing season.
That’s why Glasnow’s start Wednesday night and every other start he makes the rest of the season is so important. It is also why his start Wednesday had to set off alarms in the front office because if Glasnow is really as far away from being ready to pitch in the major leagues as it seems, there is no way they can trade Cole.
The Pirates have a chance to build a strong rotation of young arms but it mostly comes crumbling down if Glasnow isn’t a part of the equation.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.