Before Honus Wagner was a founding inductee to the Baseball Hall of Fame, he was a pioneer in an entirely different sport.
For as famous as Wagner — a Pirates legend — is, it remains relatively unknown that one of the greatest shortstops in MLB history also played basketball — way back when the game was played in a cage.
“Frankly, he would have been pretty good,” said Dennis DeValeria, a historian who wrote a biography of Wagner that was published in 1996. “Whatever he put his hand to athletically, he was going to succeed.”
Wagner is still regarded among the greatest ever to play baseball. One of his trading cards, the T206, is one of the most valuable in the world, and he still commands in a place in conversations about the game’s all-time greats.
As it turns out, he was a fixture on the court, too.
Records and information on Wagner’s foray into basketball are somewhat scarce today, especially compared to the coverage fans now expect of their stars. If, say, Mike Trout were to have an Ultimate Frisbee hobby, there’s little doubt it would be thoroughly documented.
But this was a different time — one when the game of basketball looked different depending on where in the country you were watching it. Teams were forming in different communities around Pittsburg — briefly without the ‘h’ due to a standardization effort by the United States Board on Geographic Names — and the city’s greatest athlete was not going to be left out.
The account of Wagner’s first game — according to DeValeria — was chronicled in the Feb. 5, 1902, edition of the Pittsburg Post. The story read like this:
“The feature of the game was a one-handed goal from close to the foul line by Hans Wagner, Carnegie’s famous ball player,” the article read. “A crowd of about 500 persons witnessed the game, everybody displaying a great deal of enthusiasm. The roof nearly came down when Hans scored his only goal. He looked as proud as if he had cleared the bases with a home run.”
On that day, Wagner and his Carnegie gymnasium squad defeated a team from McDonald, 9-5. That score alone should be a dead giveaway that basketball looked totally different in Wagner’s days.
Basketball evolved fluidly, with rule changes and innovation coming at staggered intervals, and there’s no guarantee a pick-up game in New York would have looked the same as one in Pittsburgh.
“Basketball at the time was very difficult to generalize about because it wasn’t really one national culture,” said Ohio State professor Marc Horger, who teaches the history of American sport and recreation. “It’s a bunch of little regional subcultures that can be difficult to generalize.”
The game was just 10 years old when Wagner debuted, so some of the core tenets of the modern game were still in their infancy. The ball was made of a smoother-looking leather and had laces. Yale had invented dribbling just five years earlier, and jump balls took place at center court after every made basket.
Even more striking, games were often played inside “cages” made of chicken wire or rope netting to keep spectators from being hit by the ball or interfering. In the cages, Horger said, the ball was always in play.
With the game still growing, Wagner was a beta-tester of sorts for what has since boomed into one of the country’s great pastimes.
With the massive financial investments in today’s professional baseball players, a present-day Wagner might have had a tougher time convincing his bosses to let him play basketball. Most modern contracts restrict athletes from participating activities that could lead to injuries, including basketball.
But just because Wagner wasn’t expressly prohibited from playing doesn’t mean his bosses weren’t still paying attention.
Surely curious as to what their prized shortstop was doing on the court, Pirates president Barney Dreyfuss and manager Fred Clarke went to watch their star play basketball on at least one occasion. They may have picked a less-than-ideal game, though, as Wagner went “scoreless on two shots before being slammed to the floor on top of his throwing arm,” according to DeValeria’s book.
“When he had to retire from the game,” DeValeria wrote, “Clarke and Dreyfuss were beside themselves.”
Wagner kept playing, though — in part because it would help him stay in shape, the book noted. Horger, though, offered another possible reason why Wagner kept coming back to the cage.
“Even famous athletes like Honus Wagner had to do something in the offseason,” Horger said. “Because, by modern standards, they didn’t actually make all that much money.”
Teams could promote Wagner’s name help boost their take, and why wouldn’t Wagner want to pick up a few extra bucks for playing a game he enjoyed?
“It was not at all uncommon for baseball players to do something like that in the offseason,” Horger said. “And if it was something that they could leverage what fame it was they had, so much the better.”
In 1915, Wagner even went on to coach basketball alongside his brother Al at Carnegie Technical Institute, where Honus also served as a baseball coach and a “physical instructor.”
Of course, even while he participated in the game’s proliferation, basketball did not need Honus Wagner to take off in Pittsburgh. But it can’t have hurt the game’s local popularity to have one of the sporting world’s most distinctive stars giving basketball the almighty endorsement of participation.
In that sense, it’s less of a wonder that Wagner played the game than that so few people seem to know about it.
“I think there would be a lot of things that would have been a surprise to sports fans or baseball fans or the public,” DeValeria said. “You know, what do these athletes do in the offseason? And certainly the amount of coverage that sports figures have today, it’s a lot greater.”
Max Bultman: mbultman@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @m_bultman





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.