Bill Brink: Hey everyone and welcome to this week's Pirates chat. Thanks for all the questions you've already submitted and keep them coming. Here we go ...
BuccoFanFromSpain: Hi Mr. Brink. Always a pleasure to read your chats. The Cutch seems unstopable right now and it's obvious that his value could give the Pirates a big return if they trade him. Even if the division is close i think they will trade him. Your thoughts???
Bill Brink: It depends on the front office's thought process regarding the division. If their models suggest the Cubs are going to get hot, they might still look to trade him. If they look at the games already in the bank and say, we've got a shot at this, they might hold him. It seems more likely than not, though, that they move him.
TN : Would/should the Pirates consider trading Kang?
Bill Brink: They won't be able to find a taker; he still can't get into the country. As to whether they should, it would rid them of a headache but could also indicate to future free-agent targets that the team will cut bait, rather than help a player with personal issues (not condoning them, mind you, but help them).
Rob: Do you see Osuna getting more playing time at first with his performance recently?
Read More
Chuck: Why does Hurdle keep Osuna and Diaz largely on the bench? When they played for Polanco and Cervelli, they hit extremely well. When Polanco returned to the lineup last week, Osuna had more RBIs and home runs than Polanco, yet Osuna has not started until last night for Bell. Diaz ha not only hit well, but he is a very good defensive catcher. I thought that Hurdle believed in playing the players who had the hot bats.
Bill Brink: I don't think they think it's in their best interest to take Bell out of the lineup. Yes, I know his May numbers. He's still a big threat when he's right, and they want to give him the chance to get right so he can play first for them for a while. As far as Cervelli, Diaz has had a hot run with the bat and has a strong arm, but they still feel their best defensive/game calling move is Cervelli, plus he's the one getting paid.
Pirates Fan: Since Stew has been activated from the DL the question has been - "Will the Pirates keep 3 catchers?" The answer that comes up the most is a certain "No." and the likely candidate to depart is Elias Diaz. If this scenario plays out and Diaz is sent back down to AAA because management feels he needs to get his reps doesn't that show that the Pirates organization as a whole really is NOT interesting in winning? In my opinion Diaz is better defensively and from what I have seen has a better bat. Please tell me where I am off in this train of thought.
Bill: The team is going to eventually go back to 2 catchers and being that NH likes to keep assets, I fully expect it to be Diaz back to Indy, which I believe is a mistake. If that happens, doesnt it send a bad message to the younger players in the organization? Come up to MLB roster, perform well and still get sent down in favor of a older veteran player?
Bill Brink: Similar questions, so I'll get to them together. It's about depth. It's not really in question that Diaz provides more to the team than Stewart at this point, though Stewart has more experience and game-calling savvy. The issue is, say they designate Stewart for assignment and roll with Cervelli and Diaz. Then Cervelli's foot acts up, or he gets dinged up in the way that catchers do. Now you've got Diaz and Stallings. Something happens to Diaz, you're starting Stallings and Jackson Williams, and we're back to the Erik Kratz-Eric Fryer tandem days.
On the Clock: Is Andrew McCutchen back?
BobbyToledo: Cutch is back. Jordy is on fire. Cole has locked it down. Marte's return is on the horizon. And the division can be had. Could you give a few reasons on why the FO would benefit from adding a starter and bench piece at the trade line and going for it? Could you give a few reasons on why Cutch, Jordy, and Cole are ripe for trades, so they may go that route?
Bill Brink: The biggest reason to add is that the division is within reach. They wouldn't be giving up assets to roll the dice against Kershaw or Greinke in a wild-card game. But moving McCutchen after this resurgence (or even moving Cole, which I'm not sure they do because they need him if they want to contend next year) would give them a unique opportunity to stock the farm system all at once.
Tyler Blackburn : Just have a question regarding Meadows, do you think he Will be up at some point this year, and if yes when will that be? Thanks
Bill Brink: He will be up at some point this year, but with top prospects, the Pirates generally like to promote them only when they have a chance to play every day rather than sit on the bench. An extended absence due to injury, or a trade of McCutchen, could create that opportunity.
Pirates Fan: When will the Pirates let Watson return to his role as the 8th inning "get the team to the best closer in the league" role that he was so good at The pst few years? He got 2 big outs last night and getting to Rivero is obviously the biggest hole in the bullpen that needs plugged. Your thoughts?
Bill Brink: When he shows them he's past the issues that he's dealt with this year, especially keeping the ball in the park, and has done it for a little while.
PhillyJake: I understand that lefties are hitting Kuhl very well, but I don't understand why. Can you shed some light on what a lefty sees against Kuhl that a righty doesn't?
Bill Brink: They're crushing his fastball. .480 in April, .333 in May, .625 in June. It's not uncommon for lefties to hit righty fastballs well, but those are dramatic numbers. It suggests a combination of a lack of deception, a lack of downward angle and/or a lack of movement.
Pirates Fan: Has Cutch done enough in the last month make the all-star team?
Bill Brink: I don't think so. Those first seven weeks were rough. Although there are always injury replacements.
Stauver: Do you think there is any hope of Polanco learning how to play his position? It seems that most balls hit in the air to RF are an adventure.
Bill Brink: It continues to be an adventure at times, though there is hope. During the last homestand he made three plays in a a span of two days going back and to his right toward the wall and the track, plays I didn't think he'd make, and plays he wouldn't have made last year.
Pirates Fan: How long will the Pirates wait for Glasnow to be a solid starter? He seems to inneficient to ever succeed in that role. I think he could really help this ballclub out in the pen as setup man. Your thoughts?
Bill Brink: Maybe at some point, but he's still 23, so I don't think they'll pull the plug on starting just yet.
Stauver: After last nights performance I think the only thing Kuhl is lacking is confidence. your thoughts?
Bill Brink: I never like to assume or imply lack of confidence without hearing it from the player himself, but I understand the notion, because he's got the stuff. I've heard a similar argument with Glasnow. I think more than anything, realizing just how good his stuff is without trying to make it harder or nastier will help him. The curve should help too.
Pirates Fan: Are Kuhl and Williams doing enough to keep their spots in the rotation?
Bill Brink: I think so. Williams had one poor start in a stretch of six good ones. Kuhl, you'd like to see more length out of. He hasn't pitched more than five innings since April. Worth noting that three of those starts he was pinch-hit for in the bottom of the fifth with pitches left in the tank because there were runners on, but still. But it's a good question, because ...
Justin: Every time I look, Drew Hutchison's ERA gets lower, although is peripherals suggest his mid-3s ERA is a bit lucky. Do you have any insight on if he's made any strides forward throughout the year? He now might have the highest chance at being a major leaguer of any guy in that trade haha, Liriano included.
Bill Brink: He's gone seven innings in each of his past two starts, struck out 10 without walking anyone in his most recent one and has a 2.14 ERA in June. Keeping the ball in the park has helped, he had three multi-homer games through May and none in June.
PiratesFan4Life: If quality starting pitching is considered a premium in the industry, why are the Pirates continuing to stack the farm system and not trade any of their minor league starters for quality bats? They haven't had a one/two punch since McCutchen has come up. Adams would have fit nicely behind Cutch in the 4 hole.
Bill Brink: The Pirates want to keep their starters for the same reason other teams would want them in a trade, and you're exactly right: good young controllable starting pitching comes is valuable. And pitchers get hurt so often that Huntington likes to have as much starting depth as possible.
Harold H.: Good afternoon, Mr Brink. It appears that, in regards to the PBC closer situation, that upper mgt is calling shots - dictating who they wants to get "saves". I can't imagine that Clint H didn't want to use Rivero to shut the door on the Cubs last week when Nicasio/Watson blew it. Your take?
Bill Brink: It wasn't upper management calling the shots. I liked the call: Use Rivero against the top of the Cubs' order, which had the lefty Rizzo, the switch-hittin Happ, the lefty Schwarber and the lefty Heyward, then let Nicasio (who to that point had been nails) come in and get three outs. Just didn't work.
Pitt.Strong : Do you think we should pick up the newly DFA'd Saunders or Gomez for help in OF or help in the pen?
Bill Brink: If the Phillies deemed them unworthy of continuing to hold a roster spot, I can't imagine the Pirates would offer them one, and they've already been down the road with Gomez.
Stauver: Of the three catchers, who do you think is the most reliable physically>
Bill Brink: Probably Diaz simply because he has the least mileage. Cervelli and Stewart have been behind the plate getting beat up for a long time.
PiratesFan4Life: If the Pirates are smart they lock Cutch up for the rest of his career. IMO there's too many looking at the return rather than the player they already have. I don't see any team giving up a ton for Cutch like the Pirates think. You need veterans to win in the playoffs, just making it there is not enough. Why not package a couple prospects and see if they can pick up a bat or bullpen help?
Bill Brink: They generally don't like to pay for past performance, which is what they'd have to do with an extension. Getting a bat or some bullpen help, or a stater, would help the club; for the Pirates to do it, they'd need to convince themselves they have a legitimate shot at the division.
Marvin: If the Central Division remains close, will the Pirates try to trade for a dependable somewhat expensive starting pitcher?
Bill Brink: Too soon to tell. Depends on how Williams and Kuhl do going forward, and if they're not good, the Pirates might not be in the mood to add anyway.
Steve Kemp: Do you believe Cutchs surge is directly related to moving to 6th hole? Thanks.
Bill Brink: Not the sole reason, but yes, related. McCutchen said he has more of a chance to see what the pitcher is throwing that day with five batters ahead of him rather than two. He used to hit in the first inning every game and might see three pitches, all fastballs, before his at-bat.
Harold H.: The Pens and Steelers goal - every year - is to win the league championship. How can the PBC change fans' (like mine) opinion that they are just interested in staying somewhat competitive - and then hope for the best after that?
Bill Brink: Think back to the past two years. 2015, they had a great team and then had some injuries, so they went and got Soria, Happ, Ramirez and Blanton, adding roughly $8 or $9 million in payroll, won 98 games and then ran into Arrieta. I think they made a good case there that they wanted to win. Then the following year they package two prospects in a salary dump and the perception changes. I think they have proved they want to win but it goes season to season.
PhillyJake: Meadows is only 22. If he's not getting the job done, why rush him up to the majors this year?
Bill Brink: I don't think they will rush him. They'll call him up if there's a spot to play and, ideally, if his minor league performance means he's earned it.
LA Matt: When it comes to catching and "game-calling," is it the catcher who actually decides what pitch and location to call or is it someone on the bench making the actual call? It seems to me from watching TV broadcasts that the catcher always looks to the bench first and then signals the pitcher.
Bill Brink: Little bit of both, depends on the situation. You see more game-calling from the bench in the amateur and college ranks, in the minors maybe, and less with more experienced catchers. With the Pirates you see pickoffs and back picks called from the bench sometimes.
Nate: Can you think of any contending teams that would actually have room/interest in Cutch? What would that team have to offer?
Bill Brink: The Dodgers could make some sense. More likely you could see a contender that loses an outfielder in the next month be a player for him.
FrankieD: Watson: going through a one-year rough spell, or losing the battle against overuse / father time / cooked arm? I believe I read somewhere that Watson leads all MLB League relievers in innings pitched since 2012.
Bill Brink: He told me in Baltimore that he didn't think the use over the years had affected him, but it's hard to ignore. Off the top of my head, he's had at least 67 appearances in each year since 2012. I don't think he was overused, but the innings do add up, and it might be affecting him without him being "hurt" if that makes sense. It's also possible he's searching for something, like he was at the start of 2013, and hasn't recovered his previous form.
Bill: Do you feel that Brault will get a look in the rotation? I keep going back to thinking how good Kuhl could be in the pen in short outings
Bill Brink: Hard to ignore Brault's 1.29 ERA and .195 batting average against since May 6. The Pirates could swap Williams or Kuhl and go with Brault or Hutchison if they don't feel Williams or Kuhl are getting it done.
Harold H.: Josh Bell's natural position is in the outfield. The amount of time spent trying to make him a first baseman could be impacting his hitting. Your thoughts? Possible solution?
Bill Brink: This is the fourth calendar year he's played first , so I don't think that is the issue.
BW: What do they do with Frazier once Marte comes back? He's a good leadoff hitter and you hate to remove his bat from the lineup
Bill Brink: They can get him some starts at second or third, and the occasional spot start, but Marte will bump him.
Behind Enemy Lines in Baltimore: Hi Bill: If the Pirates make a deal to add to make a run, who in the system do you think they'd be willing to give up?
Bill Brink: It all depends on who they get, and for how many years that player is under team control. They don't like giving up top guys, so I can't imagine Hayes/Newman/Keller and those types would be on the table, especially considering they're still under .500.
joe from FL: Is period of time a player is under team control or contract impacted by suspensions (marte) or Kang's situation? In Kang's situation, I know they aren't paying him for this time, but is he also expiring time on the existing contract?
Bill Brink: Players are on the restricted list do not accrue service time, so their free agency status is adjusted accordingly. Marte will lose half a year of service, though he's on an extension so it doesn't matter as much. Kang's free agency will be pushed back, but he also has a clause in his contract stating that he would be released upon its completion, so that will be interesting to see how those intersect.
Stauver: last night Watson threw 10 pitches, Hudson 13 and Nicasio 18. Do you think that any of them could have pitched into the following inning and save Rivero especially with a 4 run lead?
Bill Brink: Watson would have been the most likely candidate, but Hurdle has used all three of those guys as one-inning relievers and probably would not have wanted to deviate from it if he didn't have to and/or without talking to them about it first.
Bill: Take a gamble on Feliz again?
Bill Brink: It's been a rough go with the walks and homers, so I don't think they would see him as an upgrade over their internal options.
Mark: Why is there only talk about unloading Cutch's contract at the deadline, why not Cervelli too. Aren't they similar in age and salary?
Bill Brink: Cervelli's three-year, $31 million extension began this season, while McCutchen has a $14.5 million option for next year. The main issues are depth and years of control. The Pirates have Cervelli for three years, and don't have much behind him other than Diaz. They have options to play the outfield without McCutchen.
Pirates Fan: What do you think it would cost to lock up Cutch for the rest of his career in Pittsburgh? He basically resurrected the franchise. His wife's family lives 2 hours away. And he seems like a guy you would want on your team even late into his career. Your thoughts.
Bill Brink: Looking at other outfield contracts, you've got Hunter Pence at five and $90 mil, Jacoby Ellsbury at seven and $153, Adam Jones at six and $85, so it would be expensive.
LA Matt: Best guess: 2017 NL Central Division champs?
Bill Brink: Cubs
BW: To follow up on the Frazier question...if they're in contention for the division, how do you sit a guy who is hitting well for someone who can't play in the post season?
Bill Brink: They might need Marte to get them to the postseason, and if September rolls around and they need to keep Frazier involved for possible playoff games, they'll happily cross that bridge when they come to it.
Fish Monger: I think there are way too many dreamers in this chat. The Pirates are still under .500 and have been very inconsistent. Wouldn't surprise me in the slightest if they lose the next 2 games against Milwaukee and fall 6 games back again. Do you really think this team with it's cheap payroll has a chance to win the division?
Bill Brink: Sure, they have a chance, but that's assuming the Cubs and Cardinals continue to play like this and I'm not sure that's feasible.
Pirates Fan: Do the Pirates have a better chance to win the division or playing well and catching a team from the west who falls back to reality?
Bill Brink: Good question. I'd say the division, because if they're over .500 and in play for the division title they might make a move, whereas I don't think they would for a wild-card berth.
Bill Brink: Good chat today. Thanks for all the great questions! We'll do it again next week.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.