Andrew McCutchen is playing his way out of town.

He is hitting .400 with a 1.239 OPS (on-base plus slugging) in the 23 games since moving to the sixth spot in the batting order. He has sparked the Pirates offense, put himself in the All-Star discussion and revived his trade value.

On the Clock: Is Andrew McCutchen back?

He’s the Pirates’ highest-paid player at $14.2 million. The Pirates hold a 2018 club option for $14.5 million. They would owe him $1 million in a buyout if they decline that option. That contract, combined with his age (30), makes him a prime candidate to be moved. It’s unlikely the Pirates can re-sign him to a long-term deal. By trading him, they would save about $8 million this year. It makes perfect business sense for the Pirates. It may even make perfect baseball sense if the deal is strong enough. It isn’t without some risk, though, and the Pirates should proceed with caution before trading McCutchen.

The Pirates had the best young outfield in baseball just a year or two ago. McCutchen was flanked by two young studs, Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco. The Pirates had their heir apparent to McCutchen in the minors in Austin Meadows. Marte and Polanco were supposed to be stars by now, and Meadows was supposed to be tearing up the minors and pushing for a spot on the major-league roster.

Advertise with us

That was the plan, but it hasn’t worked out. Marte is serving an 80-game suspension for using performance-enhancing drugs. Polanco is one of the most underachieving and disappointing players in recent Pirates history. He has not come close to living up to his hype, currently hitting .249 with a .317 on-base percentage and .685 OPS. In 201 at-bats, he has only four home runs and 17 RBIs, despite batting mostly in the middle of the order. He’s also a disaster in the field and on the basepaths. He doesn’t seem to be improving in either area. Meadows is 22 and has talent, so there’s no reason to give up on him. However, he may need more time than originally thought. He’s hitting only .249 with a .314 on-base percentage and .674 OPS in Class AAA.

The uncertainty surrounding Marte and the struggles of Polanco and Meadows should give the Pirates pause in their zeal to trade McCutchen. It may be wise for the Pirates to at least try and hold onto McCutchen until next year’s trade deadline.

McCutchen had very little trade value a month ago, when he was flirting with the Mendoza Line. He looked lost at the plate. There was talk of his bat speed being too slow. He was an aging player whose star had faded. No team was going to give the Pirates anything of value — if anything at all — for him. That’s changed. McCutchen is now hitting .268 with a .343 on-base percentage and .843 OPS. He has discovered his power again and has eight homers in his past 23 games. He has provided stability in the outfield and at the plate. The Pirates probably could trade him for a nice return, but that could leave them in a worse position for the short term if Polanco and Meadows continue to struggle.

If the Pirates trade McCutchen, the outfield for the rest of the season will be Marte, Polanco and Adam Frazier. That’s not a stellar defensive outfield and leaves the platoon devoid of power. If McCutchen keeps this up, Frazier could move to a super utility role. Marte playing in left would be a major upgrade defensively over Frazier.

A long-term deal is not likely to happen with McCutchen, but the Pirates would be better for the rest of this season with him. Don’t forget they’re only four games out of first place. The Pirates could pick up McCutchen’s option for next season and hope Meadows improves to major-league quality. McCutchen would be a straight rental player at next year’s trade deadline, and that would hurt his value. But if he continues to hit like he has the past month, he will have value, and the Pirates will at least get something decent in return.

That is the Pirates’ best-case scenario — one that seems to look more and more attractive with each passing game.