Gerrit Cole did not put up a fight. When manager Clint Hurdle ambled to the pitcher’s mound in the fifth inning Thursday at PNC Park, Cole handed over the baseball and retreated to the home dugout, his head down. Cole had been thoroughly socked by the Miami Marlins, chasing him less than halfway through the game after five consecutive singles were sent to the outfield.

On a night when right-hander Edinson Volquez tossed seven scoreless innings and the Marlins won, 7-1, the chief concern was Cole. He was clobbered for seven runs on 11 hits in 4⅔ innings, a line he later described as “poor” and then “very poor.” It wasn’t only a bad start, though. It was another data point in a troubling trend for the Pirates’ opening-day starter.

In his past four starts, Cole has been charged with 23 runs on 39 hits in 19⅓ innings, a 10.71 ERA. The stretch is particularly vexing because Cole was in fine form through his first nine starts this season, enduring only one awful inning — a five-run fifth on opening day in Boston.

Since May 22, Cole’s ERA has climbed from 2.84 to 4.83.

Advertise with us

The problems, so far as Cole can tell, center on his inability to consistently repeat his delivery. He is without the usual downward angle on his pitches. He’s left fastballs elevated in the strike zone, breaking balls hanging over the plate and every pitch far flatter than is typical for him.

“The last two starts, in specific, there have beens parts where [the stuff] has been very crisp,” Cole said. “But you’ve got to make more than one quality pitch each hitter. You may throw a good one the first pitch, but you’ve got to throw that consistency and quality out there. It’s not happening. It’s not very good. I haven’t really gone through something like this before.

“That’s certainly the furthest thing from an excuse. I’ve got to turn things around.”

Gerrit Cole discusses rough outing vs. Marlins

The Pirates (26-34) collected only four hits, three of which were against Volquez. The Miami right-hander threw a no-hitter Saturday against the Arizona Diamondbacks. His former team was able to watch some of his start — a two-walk, 10-strikeout gem — and “were pulling for him then,” Hurdle said before Thursday’s game. “I don’t think we’ll be pulling for him tonight.”

Volquez needed little support. Any dreams of a second consecutive no-hitter were dashed when Josh Harrison bunted for a base hit in the first inning, but Volquez caught Andrew McCutchen looking at strike three with the bases loaded to end the threat. Undeterred, Volquez plowed ahead. He sent down 12 hitters in a row from the second until Harrison doubled in the sixth.

Advertise with us

For Cole, a storm brewed at the beginning. The Marlins’ first three batters each came around to score. Dee Gordon started the game with a perfectly placed bunt down the third-base line. He swiped second and took third, too, when catcher Elias Diaz’s throw sailed into center field.

Cole’s first mistake was losing Giancarlo Stanton, walking him despite securing two quick strikes. Christian Yelich smacked a double to right field to drive in the game’s first run. Cole nearly was out of the woods after back-to-back strikeouts, but Derek Dietrich laced a two-out, two-run double off the Clemente Wall. Before the Pirates’ first at-bats, they trailed by three.

“The failure to execute in the first inning complicated some things,” Hurdle said. “The three runs, you got the two big strikeouts, you get back in the hunt, you look like you’ll minimize the inning. And then we leave a changeup up in the zone for Dietrich.”

Cole called the pitch a “piss-poor changeup.”

After Gordon’s bunt, Miami’s next five hits — from the first inning to the fourth — were doubles. The extra-base streak was snapped when the Marlins torched Cole for five consecutive two-out singles in the fifth. They showed no mercy. After Stanton and Yellich had grounded out, Marcell Ozuna knocked a base hit to right field, and the next four singles went to left field.

Advertise with us

It was an example, Cole said, of his pitches missing their typical downhill action.

“That fifth inning there were a lot of base hits that were not necessarily scorched, as compared to earlier in the game,” he said, “yet I failed to get them on the ground. I’m looking for those to be hit on the ground to shortstop instead of lofted six feet — 20 feet, whatever it was — over the infield.”

Added Hurdle: “Balls are just elevated. Those balls, if they’re down in the zone, they’re mishits. They’re fisted. But when they’re up, they find outfield grass versus being on the ground. At the end of the day, it’s 11 hits. Only one walk, five strikeouts. There were some signs of some good things and then, yeah, the lack of consistent execution caught up to him.”

Cole claimed there are no issues physically. He does not intend to run wild searching for opinions about what has gone wrong: “The last thing you want is 50 different cooks in the kitchen,” he said. He also is without his regular catchers, as Chris Stewart and Francisco Cervelli are injured. Is Cole at a loss for answers, or has he pinpointed a few solutions?

“As of right now, I don’t have anything for you,” Cole said. “Sometimes a lot of dips you go through during the season are about persisting through the process and trusting it. There’s hard work to be done, which I’ll do.”

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.