There is nobody rooting harder for the Penguins to win the Stanley Cup final in seven games than Neal Huntington and Clint Hurdle.

Two more wins and a parade would ensure Penguins fever would last for almost two more weeks. That’s two more weeks when nobody is paying attention to the mess Huntington and Hurdle have made of the Pirates.

The Pirates’ owner/general manager/manager seem to be more enamored with analytics and the bottom line than making logical decisions to help the team. They seemingly can’t decide if they’re trying to win this year or build for next year and beyond. They appear to have no plan for this season — they’re a rudderless ship, if you will.

It’s cute that Hurdle points to the Indians’ use of Andrew Miller as a model for using Felipe Rivero as the Pirates’ closer. It’s a ridiculous comparison because the Indians have an actual closer, Cody Allen, who has 14 saves in 15 opportunities and 35 strikeouts in 22⅔ innings. The Pirates brought in Daniel Hudson and had Tony Watson already primed to be the closer. This was going to be a model franchise for using the best relievers in the toughest situations. Instead, Hudson has been bad, and Watson is either physically burned out or simply not cut out to be the closer. The Pirates don’t have a Cody Allen to give them the luxury of using Rivero like Miller.

Advertise with us

The whole bullpen needs to be blown up and reworked. Rivero should move to closer, keeping in mind a closer can pitch more than one inning per night and can pitch the eighth inning if needed. The next step would be to commit to the bullpen’s future by adding Chad Kuhl and Trevor Williams. That could take place after Jameson Taillon returns and the Pirates promote Steven Brault from Class AAA. The rotation would be Taillon, Gerrit Cole, Ivan Nova, Tyler Glasnow and Brault. Kuhl and Williams seem to be better suited as relievers and are among the Pirates’ best pitchers.

That would give Hurdle three good bullpen pitchers —  Juan Nicasio, Kuhl and Williams — capable of eating innings and getting the Pirates through the sixth, seventh and eighth. Wade LeBlanc could be the mop-up guy, and Hudson and Watson could work their way back to effectiveness in lesser roles. That’s problem No. 1, solved with a long-term solution that doesn’t cost money.

The next solution is for the Pirates to commit to Elias Diaz as starting catcher. It’s his time. Outside of Cervelli’s contract, there’s no logical argument for Cervelli to remain the starter. Diaz is better, younger and the future at catcher. This move would require Huntington to admit he made a huge mistake with Cervelli’s contract, but that’s life in the big leagues.

The Pirates could shed salary by trading Cervelli, Watson and McCutchen. Watson’s value is diminished, but he’s a left-handed reliever with a history of success. If he can move back to his setup role and be effective for a month, he will have some value. Cervelli’s contract makes him a tough sell, but Huntington could always throw in a few prospects to entice a team to take him. Starling Marte will be back in late July, which means McCutchen becomes an expensive luxury. He looks like he’s heating up at the plate, and if he continues to hit he will salvage some of his trade value.

The Pirates need to put the eight best players (Diaz, Josh Bell, Josh Harrison, Jordy Mercer, David Freese, Adam Frazier, Marte and Gregory Polanco) on the field every day. There’s no need to tinker with the lineup every day — just leave it alone and see where it takes you. That team would be young, but that should be the goal because the Pirates’ younger players are probably the best — and cheapest — on the roster.

A youth movement often means giving up on the season, but not in this case. That lineup, staff and bullpen would be good enough to compete for a wild-card berth. That is, of course, assuming that the Pirates don’t fall too far out of contention as a result of bad decisions based on flawed logic.