Felipe Rivero is the Pirates’ best reliever, which is precisely the reason he shouldn’t be the team’s closer, if it must have one at all.

Tony Watson’s ninth-inning implosion Tuesday in Baltimore, combined with his recent struggles, have made his status as the closer a point of controversy for obvious reasons. It’s deflating for a team to blow a ninth-inning lead, as the Pirates did Tuesday when Watson gave up a game-tying homer to Jonathan Schoop before losing in extra innings.

Its chances of winning a given game, however, are higher if it’s leading rather than trailing entering the ninth inning, and using the best reliever before that point is the safest way to ensure a lead exists to be blown.

Consider, for example, how the 6-5 loss Tuesday unfolded.

Advertise with us

Rivero, who has a 0.60 ERA and limits opponents to a .159 batting average in 30 innings this season, entered with a 4-3 lead in the seventh inning. There were two outs and a man on first base. Their lead, at that point, was more tenuous than when Watson entered with a two-run lead and no one on base at in the bottom of the ninth.

So it made sense for Rivero, who got out of the seventh and eighth innings cleanly, to get the ball in the seventh rather than the ninth.

This is, more or less, an example to make the broader case against the traditional closer role’s continued existence. Teams historically have saved their best relievers for the ninth inning when, often, there aren’t ninth-inning leads to protect because a lesser pitcher gave it up earlier in the game.

The Pirates, however, are an interesting case where their closer is objectively a lesser pitcher, at least this season, than is Rivero. Watson has a 3.91 ERA and .283 opponent’s batting average, stats that pale in comparison to Rivero’s.

Which is what makes Clint Hurdle’s Wednesday explanation for maintaining the status quo encouraging. Rather than focus on the flashy title of “closer,” he’s making an affirmative case that Rivero’s current role can actually the most important in the bullpen.

Advertise with us

“Felipe’s pitched more leverage situations than anybody else on our team,” Hurdle said. “There’s a guy in the American League that’s the best reliever in baseball that doesn’t have a save.”

He’s likely referring, of course, to the Cleveland’s Andrew Miller, who has a ridiculous 0.33 ERA in 27⅓ innings this season and who dominated hitters in all kinds of different situations outside the ninth inning during the Indians’ run to within one game of a World Series championship last year.

There are worse models the Pirates could follow with Rivero. Making him the closer is one of them. Hopefully this is a sign that Hurdle, who’s been hesitant to adopt this logic in the past, is beginning to see that light.

Baseball is a stubborn sport. It evolves slowly. The Pirates clearly aren’t ready to ditch the concept of a closer altogether as long as they’re setting aside the ninth inning for Watson and Watson alone.

And you know what? This is fine. There is certainly a degree of leverage to protecting a narrow lead in the ninth inning, something closers have traditionally been paid handsomely to do. If the Pirates want to make a case that Watson is a better player to be handling that role than, say, teammates Wade LeBlanc or Jhan Marinez, there’s probably some legitimacy to their argument.

Advertise with us

It is progressive and smart of them, however, to use their best relievers in the most desperate situations. Whether Hurdle believes they’re the better pitchers or not, the stats say the Pirates are doing that with Rivero, and with righty Juan Nicasio, he of the 1.40 ERA and .213 batting average against.

They’ll be better for it in the long-run, whether Watson’s ninth-inning woes continue or not. Because if they do, it likely means Rivero and/or Nicasio gave the Pirates a ninth-inning advantage to work with in the first place.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.