BALTIMORE — The baseball gods are cruel, and they possess a keen sense of timing. Hours after manager Clint Hurdle placed faith in Tony Watson, affirming that he would retain the closer’s role despite recent struggles, Hurdle called upon the lefty in Wednesday’s ninth inning.
Watson entered the game with a four-run lead. When he left, it was tied. Two innings later, the Baltimore Orioles won for the second game in a row in walk-off fashion at Camden Yards, 9-6, this time courtesy of a Trey Mancini home run. Mancini homered twice, once against Watson to tie the game and in the 11th off Wade LeBlanc to end it. Watson’s issues, and Hurdle’s deploying him, cost the Pirates a lead and a game for the second consecutive night.
“I make decisions,” Hurdle said. “When they don’t work out, they’re on me. It squarely falls on me. I believe in the men. I don’t put it on them. I make a decision, it didn’t work out.”
Johnny Barbato started the ninth ahead 6-2 and put two men in scoring position with a walk and a double. Watson relieved him and allowed two runs to score on a sacrifice fly and a double by J.J. Hardy. He struck out Caleb Joseph swinging at a high fastball. Mancini came off the bench to pinch-hit for lefty Seth Smith.
Watson got ahead 0-1 and 1-2, then evened the count. Mancini fouled off two sliders and a sinker before Watson left a changeup in the middle of the plate. Mancini drove it out to right field to tie the game at 6-6.
“This isn’t spring training, we’re not out there working on things,” said Watson, who blew his fifth save of the year. “We’re trying to compete, and being the closer, you’re supposed to close out games. No excuses. It’s not happening. It’s inexcusable. We’ve got a lead there late and the guys put up runs. You’ve got to get the job done.”
Read More
The Pirates lost three of five games on the road trip and fell to 26-33, last in the NL Central. They trail the first-place Milwaukee Brewers by 5½ games.
The Pirates discussed giving Watson a brief break or using him in lower-leverage situations, Hurdle said, and they will revisit those discussions. The bullpen contains two other viable options at closer: Felipe Rivero, a demonstrably better reliever, and Juan Nicasio, who has pitched well this season. Rivero pitched a scoreless 10th Wednesday.
Watson has allowed six homers and 32 hits in 26⅓ innings this season, with a 4.44 ERA.
“It’s always difficult,” he said. “Personally it’s not easy to give up runs, but when you’re doing it in the ninth inning and you’re not closing out games and there’s 24 other guys that are fighting, it’s defeating. I’m a team guy so it hurts that way. That’s why we play 162 of them. There’s going to be nights like this. You just can’t let it snowball.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.