Bill Brink: Thanks for the questions, everyone, and keep them coming. Here we go ...

Suseck: What plan do Pirates have to improve their offense?

Bill Brink: They just went down and got the two guys who were hitting the best in the minors, so if that doesn't work, they'll need to look outside the organization. But with Marte and Kang unavailable, Freese's injury and Taillon's unfortunate situation, the question is whether they want to. Which brings us to ...

Sean from Cumberland: Hurdle has no consistent hitters and his starting pitching just got weaker, The much talked about farm system is not what they hoped it would be. Will Huntington and Nutting help him out? Can they?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: They can. The question is will they. Huntington speaks each year about how trades early in the season are hard to make (part of this is that teams are in draft prep mode until mid-June) and that teams must overpay to pull them off. The Pirates are not a team that likes to overpay. For them to add to this club they would need to see signs that another player or two might make the difference. They'd probably need to see some better offense and defense from the players they have to believe that.

On the Clock: What's next for the Pirates?

AndrewG: This season is off to a depressing start. Between cheap ownership, poor management by Hurdle and listless play by overcompensated players, it looks like we are starting a losing season. I know it's early in the season but is there anywhere we can find a decent pitcher. Seems like our "big ace" pitchers are big zeros.

Bill Brink: Surprisingly, the pitching has been the least of their problems. Cole has looked like 2015 Cole his past three starts, Nova is still great, I was encouraged by Glasnow pitching into the seventh in his most recent start and I think better days are ahead for Kuhl. The absence of Taillon will of course weaken the rotation. There are pitchers to be had, but it goes back to the point above: What does the front office need to see from the current players to add to this team? This is not to make excuses for the front office, merely to illustrate the train of thought for a team that thinks long-term.

BurghBall: Bill, any sabrmetric data on Won-Loss record on day games in which the team is due to fly away to west /east coast road trip? The Pirates look pretty uninspired Sunday against the Brewers.

Bill Brink: There is always that joke about swinging early on getaway days. I don't have any data handy, though I'm sure someone somewhere has studied it. E-mail me at bbrink@post-gazette.com and remind me, and I'll blog about it if I can find it.

Advertise with us

David: How is Polanco's misjudgment not an "error"? And what is wrong with our defense. Seriously. We have lost like at least five games because of horrible defense this season.

Bill Brink: Everyone is baffled at the defense this year. Some of it is due to Marte's absence, but either way the Pirates didn't have a true fourth outfielder on the roster. That is magnified now. I've been surprised at the defense at second base as well.

Logan: Do you think the Pirates stand a chance at playoffs or even the division this year? Also, any big changes coming up?

Bill Brink: Not as currently constructed, no. They'll need external help, or for like four players to go on a tear and Williams to pitch well in Taillon's absence.

Almost lost hope...: Does the move to shift Polanco back to right field show just how mismanaged this team really is?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: Not the way I look at it, no. They had a plan during the winter, all three outfielders played in the WBC so they didn't practice much and then Marte got popped. I think they're doing what they think is best with the pieces they have.

Kyle from Omaha: What is the pulse of this Pirates team? I've never seen a team look so lethargic. Cervelli and J-Hay are the only guys busting it out there and they look like they are having fun. Cutch looks lost and annoyed. Polanco looks like he's on a Sunday stroll. I feel bad for the pitching staff.

Bill Brink: I'm not on this current road trip, so I can't say definitively right this second, but when I've been around them it has been fine. They want to play better and are frustrated but not down.

Almost lost hope...: The Pirates are 12-3 on games played on weekend series but just 2-14 on games played during weekday series. What do you attribute to this discrepancy?

Bill Brink: As Josh Harrison would say, baseball's a funny game.

Advertise with us

BuccoFanFromSpain: Hi Mr. Brink. Besides the obvious minor league options (Hutchinson, Brault, etc) can we expect some help from the outside?? Fister, Latos...

Bill Brink: Thanks for joining us from Spain! Williams will get some run in the rotation. If that doesn't work out, I think we'll have a better idea at that time, depending on how Brault and Hutchison are doing, where the Pirates are in the standings and what other teams who are out of it might make available.

Cole: Do you think Cutch is gone at the deadline? He predicted a monster year and he's been bad so far. Hopefully he turns it around

Bill Brink: If the season continues in this fashion for the Pirates, it would stand to reason that they would consider moving him at the deadline, same as they considered moving him over the winter.

David: Is there any chance it will be changed to an error? I really hate how our pitchers are responsible of the runs when it's actually a routine play that our RF/2B mishandled.

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: Referencing Polanco's play last night. Players and teams sometimes will ask for a review of a questionable official scoring decision, so there is a chance.

David: And what about Cutch? I know he's been hitting balls just directly at the shifts, etc. but is he really better than last season?

Bill Brink: The numbers don't show it yet, but he's doing better than last season. He's cut his strikeout rate by 5 percent, his batting average on balls in play is only .231 (career .328, MLB average .290-.300), less soft contact, fewer swings outside the strike zone, more contact overall, fewer swinging strikes, etc.

Shoes: It looks to me like the majority of Pirates prospects who get called up simply aren't major league ready. I don't see this on other teams--might it be time to turn the focus on how the Pirates are developing their talent? It doesn't seem to be very effective...

Bill Brink: I don't know about that. Bostick and Moroff have had two games, I'd give them a little more time. Osuna has looked ready at the plate, Ngoepe in the field.

Advertise with us

Emory: Why doesn't the press in Pgh call out Bob Nutting for being cheap?? According to neutral sources Bucs were 2nd most profitable team in baseball in 2016 and are worth in excess of $1.2 Billion. So enough money to increase payroll doesn't seem to be the issue. Most knowledgeable fans believe Nuttings goal apparent goal if stagnating or reducing payroll is the root of Bucs problems. Why is this issue not continuously reported in and exposed by the press??

Bill Brink: We do. I know fans don't think so, and want it written about every day, but we write about the payroll. We wrote about the Forbes estimates, we wrote about the $5 million or so not being spent on Marte and Kang (Kang' final number is still up in the air).

Nate: What would it take for the Pirates to make a change at coach or even general manager?

Bill Brink: I think more would have to go wrong that was within their control. Marte, Kang, Taillon and Freese were situations not within the manager, coaching staff or front office's control. They did shed light on some things that were (lack of position player depth, especially true outfielders, for one).

PhillyJake: Does the team look lethargic? Or is that just a perception exacerbated by all of the losing?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: I think it's more perception than reality. I would say more sloppy (getting picked off on the bases, making errors) than lethargic.

Mark L: I know that it is a cliche to say that when a team isn't hitting, they should fire the hitting coach. But given the accolades given to the Bucs' pitching coaches, I am wondering about who is coaching the hitters and what they are doing with them. Does Hurdle get involved? Or is it all on Branson?

Bill Brink: Jeff Branson and Jeff Livesey coach the hitters, and Hurdle, as a former hitting coach, can sometimes help as well. Remember, this is the same duo that had the Pirates as one of the best offensive teams in the league at the beginning of last year.

Kevin: Do you think Cervelli has played anywhere near his 2015 season in 2016 and up to this point this year? I'm not talking so much about his hitting, but his catching and handling of the staff. Doesn't seem as good defensively to me as he once was

Bill Brink: The foot pain has limited him somewhat this season, it's true. He remains an excellent framer.

Advertise with us

Mark L: I can't remember the latest on the Pirates' tv contract. With other teams signing billion $ contracts, don't the Pirates need to get a big one just to keep up? When are they due for a new one?

Bill Brink: The current deal expires after the 2019 season.

Cole: Are the pirates going to be sellers or buyers at the deadline? It seems like a fire sale is on the way

Bill Brink: If this current trajectory continues, you could see them move Watson and McCutchen at the deadline. They would need offensive and defensive improvement between now and the deadline to be buyers.

Mark L: Has Cutch's bat speed declined over the last 3 years? What is the consensus about what has gone wrong?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: That's the thing that was interesting last year, I didn't hear a consensus. I'd talk to scouts, other writers and broadcasters and no one unified theme presented itself except for the thumb issue and the elevated strikeout rate. Looking at his peripherals and just watching his at-bats, I'd say improvement is coming for him.

Bob: 29 defensive lineups and 30 batting order lineups in 33 games is absolutely horrendous I understand either the injuries but baseball players are creatures of habit! There is no continuity so there is no comfort zone!!

Bill Brink: It's almost akin to how the Dodgers do things under Friedman and Roberts. They are focused on matching up best that day, not on continuity or set positions/lineup spots.

Ryan: How do you feel about Hurdle's handling of 1st base? To me, if you continue to pull your starters for defensive replacements, you are "telling" them, game after game, that they are no good in the field. I really think it had to get into these guys' heads. Plus, with Pedro and now Bell, you don't have you're biggest bat in late innings to make a 3 run change with one swing.

Bill Brink: That's a good point. It's not ideal, but I think it's Hurdle being pragmatic. He knows Jaso is better defensively than Bell and he needs to win ballgames.

Advertise with us

David: I know it's tough; we don't have 2 of our starting players and 2 of best hitters this season. We don't have 4th OF. I know all this but Hurdle's lineup, strategy has been questionable. I get why Cervelli got a rest, JHay was forced to rest, but that Sunday lineup was the worst. Brewers game is much more important than Dodgers game. Why couldn't we have a better lineup then? Why didn't we use a pinch hitter for Jaso in the 9th inning? Why did we just give up that game?

Bill Brink: The coaching staff and front office plan long-term, so sometimes you'll see bad lineups like that because they believe the rest will pay dividends down the road.

IndyFan: Any word yet on how long Taillon will be out?

Bill Brink: None yet. In speaking with a urologist the other day (who didn't diagnose or treat Taillon, so he was talking in generalities), more treatment is sometimes required if the cancer has spread, and sometimes (15-30 percent of the time) there is microscopic spread that doesn't even show up on a scan, which could require treatment or surgery. No way to know just yet.

David: I don't understand why people think we'll sell all our players. Including annoying NY reporters writing about how they'll get Cole from us. We have much better lineup next season and soon Reds/Brewers will finish their rebuilding. In my eyes, next season is the best chance we can compete. What's your opinion about my argument?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: I would agree with the argument that next year's lineup should be better, with Marte and Kang back full time. The discussion surrounding trading Cole is about both value (he's young, controllable and very good) and the fact that, as a Boras client who is young and very good, the Pirates almost certainly won't re-sign him.

David: Why is Bell not swinging at any balls that come near to the zone after 2 strikes? He gotta protect. I think I saw him just striking out looking like that for more than 5 times. Mercer used to do that in the beginning of the season and now he doesn't. Bell relies on his eyes way too much.

Bill Brink: I'd need to do a deeper dive on the pitches Bell sees and swings at in two-strike counts, but the .133/.224/.217 line with two strikes this year isn't great.

BW: Frazier stole 2nd today and looks good. How soon will we see him back up and i'm assuming he'll be in RF? I believe his bat could really help things too

Bill Brink: Pretty soon. I believe this is his second game on the rehab assignment, so after a couple more, he should be good to go. His bat will help, no question.

Advertise with us

BW: Sorry Bill, I meant LF when asking about Frazier.

Bill Brink: As we've seen with Hurdle's lineup and defensive flexibility, I'm sure he'll see a little of both.

Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.

BW: Joe Terdoslovich? What's his deal and where does he fit in? He's batting well at Indy

Bill Brink: He's doing OK -- only three extra-base hits in 52 plate appearances. No obvious fit right now, though that could change with injuries.

Advertise with us

Ryan: Favorite press meal in the league?

Bill Brink: Probably Philly. So many options. Used to be Houston before they moved to the AL. Giant chocolate chip cookies that were to die for.

BW: Brault was being considered out of spring for a starting role, why didnt they bring him up to replace Taillon?

Bill Brink: Williams was also considered out of spring, and he made the active roster, so they're going to give him a try.

doyle37: When does Jaso get DFAed? When Freese returns or sooner ?

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: Probably not until they're convinced Bell is ready to play first base the entire game, or until they're well out of it, selling, and good with Bell playing late in close games.

Ryan: Do they still have free beer in Baltimore press room?

Bill Brink: I don't know, but I'm going there in June so I'll find out.

(Michael and Tyler: No I won't).

David: Why are they not convinced with Bell's defense? He's doing well. He has positive DRS and UZR.

Bill Brink: He is doing well, considering he only picked up the position a few years ago. Jaso in their eyes is just more of a sure thing.

BW: Tyler Eppler. Has looked pretty good so far after 5 games for Indy. Its a small smaple size but could he be considered to be brought up this year?

Bill Brink: At some point, yes, but he has only five starts above double-A. He has been very good, but they'll want him to get more time in triple-A, so you could see him as a September call-up potentially.

David: I expected Kingham to be called up this season but with that DL trip, is the chance diminished/gone?

Bill Brink: No, it's not. He's stretched out to five innings in extended spring, so an assignment to an affiliate is not far off. If he does well upon returning to Indy, he, too, could be in line for a call-up later this season.

Bill Brink: That's it for today's chat, thanks for all the great questions! We'll do it again next week.