Advanced analytics can be a difficult sell to baseball fans for a lot of reasons, but players like Jeff Locke and Drew Hutchison, lightning rod starters past and present, are at the top of the list.

On paper, they’re pretty solid for potential No. 5 starters according to an important advanced stat, Fielding Independent Pitching, or FIP, which calculates an expected ERA based only on factors pitchers can control directly: walks, strikeouts, homers and hit batters. Basically, it attempts to isolate a pitcher’s performance by removing factors such as defense and lucky or unlucky bounces from the equation.

Locke and Hutchison perform fairly well in this category historically. Locke’s lifetime FIP is 4.33 while Hutchison’s is 4.25. Most people would take those as ERAs from a No. 5 starter, so it’s easy to see why analytically inclined front offices like the Pirates’ would see these guys as potentially useful even if their ERAs are considerably worse than their FIPs at particular points in time.

It’s a strategy that helped general manager Neal Huntington target and acquire starters including Edinson Volquez, Francisco Liriano and A.J. Burnett, who turned out to be great success stories.

Advertise with us

The problem is that both Locke and Hutchison are highly combustible, as we saw when Hutchison — who was competing for the No. 5 spot in the rotation until he was sent down Wednesday — yielded nine earned runs in just 3⅔ innings Tuesday night in a spring training start against Boston.

Fans don’t like to hear theoretical projections that suggest a guy has the stuff to be effective after starts like that. They want to talk about real-world results, and the results for both Locke and Hutchison are way too often very bad.

This is the reason Locke was highly unpopular in his parts of six seasons with the Pirates. He’d have an All-Star-worthy first half, as he did in 2013, only to follow it up with a terrible second half. He’d post solid starts in which he looked like a viable middle-of-the-rotation starter and follow them up with faceplants.

In the theoretical world, his FIP never fluctuated that much. He stayed between 3.95 and 4.37 for three consecutive years until falling off to 4.84 last season. The real-world routes he took to those numbers, though, were just too inconsistent for Pirates fans and media to take him seriously before he departed for Miami this offseason.

It’s very early, but Hutchison seems to be following this same path.

Advertise with us

His posted FIPs of 3.85 and 4.42 with Toronto in 2014 and 2015, respectively. Pretty solid for a back-end guy in the offensive thunderdome that is the American League East. But his ERAs of 4.48 and 5.57 didn’t come close to matching that potential.

Now he’s had a dreadful spring — he’s allowed at least six earned runs in each of his last three spring training starts — to the point that no one is in the mood to hear about the theoretical, especially considering the trade that brought Hutchison to Pittsburgh in exchange for Liriano and two prospects last summer is very unpopular.

The Pirates may make Hutchison the No. 5 starter at some point this season, and despite what his spring suggests, it wouldn’t be completely crazy. Over the long haul, he’s proven to be a guy who can control homers, walks and hit batters and strike a respectable number of guys out. At least relative to other back-end guys.

If he becomes the choice — if Trevor Williams and/or Tyler Glasnow are first ineffective — management had better be ready for the same hand-wringing that followed Locke through his every start. Even if Hutchison starts churning out a solid FIP that should even out with ERA over the course of a 162-game season, inconsistency in reality will undermine the arguments in his favor at every turn.

On the Clock: Who should play third base for the Pirates?

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.