Neal Huntington said earlier this week the Pirates would put their best 25 players on the major league roster and that salaries and how a player was acquired will not be a part of the equation. He was talking specifically about Drew Hutchison, who has had an awful spring.
As it turns out, Huntington was telling the truth. It turns out a lot of people — me included — owe him and the Pirates an apology. It turns out they’re trying to field the best team possible and trying to win.
Hutchison was sent to the minors Wednesday, and that’s exactly where he belongs. He isn’t good enough to be on a major league roster and hasn’t pitched well enough to justify a spot in the Pirates rotation. Most assumed Hutchison would be on the roster regardless of what he did in spring training. That was based on the way the Pirates have done business in the past. Hutchison was acquired in a trade for Francisco Liriano and receives a salary of $2.3 million. The Pirates have to pay him regardless if he plays at PNC Park or against the Toledo Mud Hens.
The Pirates gave Hutchison every single opportunity to make the team. That included leaving him in Tuesday’s game against Boston long after it was clear he had nothing.
On the Clock: Who should play third base for the Pirates?
Hutchison went 3⅔ innings, gave up 10 hits and nine earned runs against the Red Sox in what was supposed to be his final tuneup before the season.
Hutchison’s failure probably is tough for Huntington because he spent last summer telling the world what a steal the Pirates received in the Liriano trade. He pointed to Hutchison’s past and potential, saying that with a few months in Ray Searage’s lab he’d return to form. That hasn’t happened and, based on what we’ve seen the past six weeks, it doesn’t look like it will ever happen.
Read More
The fact that Huntington was able to admit such a high profile mistake speaks volumes about his integrity. Many general managers believe they’re smarter than everyone else and hate to admit they were wrong. That’s why some players get so many more opportunities to prove they belong than they deserve. That was the case with Hutchison, but in the end, Huntington and Clint Hurdle came to the right conclusion.
Now that Hutchison is out of the picture, the fifth spot in the rotation comes down to either Trevor Williams or Tyler Glasnow.
If you go by merit and how each has performed during spring training it’s easy. Williams has been better than Glasnow and appears to be more capable of being in the rotation. Williams is 2-0 in 13⅔ innings over five games with a 2.63 ERA, 12 strikeouts, only four earned runs and a 1.02 WHIP. Glasnow is 1-0 in 14½ innings over five games with a 5.65 ERA, 23 strikeouts, nine earned runs and a 1.74 WHIP. There is no real argument to be made for Glasnow in the rotation over Williams based on merit.
A few weeks ago, I wrote that Glasnow should start the season in the Pirates’ bullpen as opposed to going back to Class AAA. But that was before Hutchison and Steven Brault flamed out. Neither Brault nor Hutchison were clearly better than Glasnow. That’s why the Pirates are correct to choose Glasnow’s pedigree, potential and talent over the other two.
Brault and Hutchison likely are “Class AAAA” pitchers — career major-league spot starters — and the latter may not even be that anymore.
Even though Williams has been better than Glasnow, he is better served as a long reliever, not a starter. That’s probably where his future is, and he has a chance to be pretty good in that role. So, both Glasnow and Williams should make the 25-man roster. The Pirates should throw Glasnow into the fire as the fifth starter and hope he improves with each start. Williams should begin the season as the seventh reliever. That would mean the pitching staff comprises the 12 best pitchers in the Pirates organization. That’s what Huntington promised, and it appears that’s what he’ll deliver.
Hutchison may be able to work out his issues and, at some point, become a productive pitcher. However, he’s a long way from that and is now a $2.3 million minor-league pitcher. Some see that as failure, but I see it as progress. He’s where he belongs, and the Pirates’ willingness to swallow his salary shows winning is their top priority.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.