Sort your way through the minutia that has trickled out from baseball’s new collective bargaining agreement during the past 24 hours and you’ll see some victories for both sides.
The players successfully negotiated a less punitive free-agent compensation system, which should result in fewer restrictions on their value on the open market. They also received more days off, provisions for a better travel schedule and a reduction in disabled-list length from 15 days to 10, which they believe will lead to increased recovery time, fewer players lost to injuries and a better product on the field.
Team owners did not get the international draft they wanted, but they still received cost certainty in the international market in the form of hard caps on bonus spending. Competitive balance tax thresholds increased, but not drastically so, and the higher penalties for teams that greatly exceed the tax threshold will create a strong disincentive to field a gargantuan payroll.
Once the owners and players ratify the new five-year agreement, which was reached hours before Wednesday’s midnight deadline, labor peace in baseball will extend from 1995 to 2021. Peace in baseball is not the status quo, but it’s hard to shut down a $10 billion industry that just featured the Chicago Cubs beating the Cleveland Indians in an exciting seven-game World Series.
“Kind of reached a little bit of a boiling point a couple days before the deadline,” Gerrit Cole, the Pirates union representative, said by phone Thursday. “You take those things seriously when some of that lockout stuff comes into the press. You take that seriously because it’s your job but at the same time there’s a lot of posturing.”
Two of the major adjustments to the document that governs the sport — hundreds of pages long and still being finalized — are now intertwined. The competitive balance tax threshold, which triggers taxes when teams exceed it, reportedly increased from $189 million in 2016 to $195 million next year and $210 million by the end of the deal. The tax on the overage, which ranged from 17.5 percent to 50 percent depending on how many years the team surpassed the threshold, will now reportedly have surtaxes that could reach as high as 90 percent for teams that go way beyond the limit.
“That was obviously a big sticking point toward the end of the negotiations,” Cole said. “It is moving. It was stagnant before. It is moving now.”
Reducing payroll beneath the threshold now has more implications than simply avoiding the tax. Should a team sign a free agent that has declined a qualifying offer and that team’s payroll exceeds the threshold, according to several reports, it will lose second- and fifth-round draft picks in addition to international bonus money. If it stays under the threshold, it loses a third-rounder. This is where the Pirates live, so perhaps they could be in play for free agents who decline a qualifying offer knowing they’ll lose a third-rounder instead of their top pick.
“I hope it has a big effect,” Cole said. “I think it was a really important area. I think both sides kind of acknowledge that there were some unintended consequences by the original system.”
Yes, the qualifying offer still exists. The compensation picks do, too, but according to various reports, the new language created an arcane Venn diagram of sorts. Where the former team’s comp pick falls depends on whether that team is above or below the tax threshold, whether or not they receive revenue sharing, the size of the contract the player signed and the former team’s market size. This helps the Pirates, who will fall below the tax threshold and almost certainly receive revenue sharing; they’ll receive higher picks.
What you need to know about these intersecting comp pick scenarios: The Pirates have a better path to signing free agents who decline a qualifying offer while still receiving draft pick compensation for losing their own qualified free agents.
By negotiating for a hard cap — reportedly in the neighborhood of $5 million — for international signings, owners found a way to limit costs and force their general managers to get creative in finding an edge abroad. International teenagers now stand to earn less than before, but the union represents only players on 40-man rosters.
Incremental increases in the competitive balance tax, higher penalties for exceeding it and capped international spending represent harsher restrictions on spending than the players had previously allowed. But the players claimed fewer restrictions to the free-agent process and a more forgiving schedule. A 10-day DL allows teams to be more aggressive in disabling a player and promoting a replacement; with off days and skipped starts, that’s one turn in the rotation for a starter.
“I think the four extra off days, off days are like a godsend sometimes,” Cole said.
And, as Jeff Passan of Yahoo! Sports reported Thursday, at least two seats per player on spring training buses. No stone left unturned.
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.