When the Pirates finish their final game of the season in St. Louis today, they’ll head home. Not home to PNC Park, to prepare for a wild-card game like the previous three years, but their offseason homes, with plenty of time to ponder the descent from 98 victories to this season’s ending.
“There’s some guys walking out now that might have thought it was no big deal to win 98 games,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “It’s hard to win 98 games up here, as evidenced by what we’ve got right now.”
Things clicked near the end of May; then June happened. They clicked again near the end of August; an eight-game losing streak erased that.
“Our offense was churning and our pitching was pitching well enough,” general manager Neal Huntington said of that late-May surge. “And then the offense staggered and our pitching stopped pitching well enough. It’s been a battle for the rest of the year.”
The impetus for that battle occurred in the offseason because the Pirates did not construct a strong enough starting rotation. Underperformance from their stars and highest-paid players added to the problem. The offense improved, but not enough to keep pace with the rest of the league.
They face similar challenges this winter as they did last offseason: uncertainty in the rotation and a Chicago Cubs team, against which they went 4-14-1, that is the best in baseball and isn’t going anywhere. They made at least two contract offers to free agent-to-be Ivan Nova, but offers don’t turn into production off the mound unless they result in a contract. Their payroll has risen in the past five seasons, and they should have some money to spend after shedding Francisco Liriano’s salary.
Read More
Pirates principal owner Bob Nutting was not available for comment.
Expecting the Pirates to repeat their run prevention effort from 2015 was asking a bit much. They allowed 3.68 runs per game last year, the third-lowest mark in baseball, and finished second with a 3.21 ERA. This year, entering their final series of the season, they allowed 4.64 runs per game, 21st in MLB, and had a 4.17 ERA.
Regression seemed inevitable with A.J. Burnett and J.A. Happ leaving. Not only did the Pirates not re-sign Happ, they didn’t add a proven starter. They spent $5 million guaranteed on Juan Nicasio and Ryan Vogelsong, while trading Neil Walker for Jon Niese, to combine with Gerrit Cole, Francisco Liriano and Jeff Locke. And while they knew Jameson Taillon and Tyler Glasnow were on their way, they also knew neither would debut until at least June because of the Super Two deadline.
“We did not anticipate having five different starting pitchers in September than we had in April,” Huntington said. “We knew we had some challenges.”
Niese allowed 21 homers in 110 innings. Nicasio beat out Vogelsong for a rotation spot, but racked up a 5.05 ERA as a starter — “In hindsight, we probably could have and should have kept him in the bullpen, but we felt that what he was showing us in spring training would play over the course of the season, and it did at times,” Huntington said. “Over the course of the year we became very well aware that his best role is out of the bullpen.” Locke posted a 5.86 ERA as a starter and the rotation, which ranked fifth in MLB with a 3.53 ERA last season, ranked 23rd at 4.71 this season entering the Cardinals series.
“The game will always start with pitching,” Hurdle said. “Always has, always will. If you look at it any other way, I think you’re confused.”
They might have overcome these issues had Liriano and Cole pitched like they did last year. Never one with pinpoint command, Liriano suffered a baffling inability to throw strikes. He walked 5.5 batters per nine, his ERA reached 5.46 and he ended up in Toronto after the Pirates dumped his salary on the Blue Jays. Coming off a 200-inning, 32-start season during which he finished fourth in the Cy Young voting, Cole dealt with rib, triceps and elbow injuries and made only 21 starts.
Run prevention requires good defense, too, and again the Pirates took a step back. Their defensive efficiency — the percentage of balls in play turned into outs — was almost exactly the same (67.7 prior to the final weekend) as it was last year (67.9) and in the bottom five in baseball. But last year they ranked fourth in the league with 21 Defensive Runs Saved above average, as computed by Baseball Info Solutions. This year, they saved six runs below average. The Pirates played their outfielders closer to the infield this year to minimize extra bases taken on shallow hits, but that didn’t dovetail with their pitching staff.
“Unfortunately, your pitching dictates some of your outfield defense,” Huntington said. “And if you’re giving up a lot of hard contact, it’s going to be harder for your outfielders to make some plays, even if they’re positioned well, and we gave up more hard contact this year.”
This issue was displayed most egregiously with Andrew McCutchen, who with minus-26 defensive runs saved made him the worst defender in Major League Baseball this season. McCutchen, like Liriano, fell short of his previous production. After five top five MVP finishes in a row, McCutchen entered the weekend hitting .255 with a .337 on-base percentage, .432 slugging percentage and 24 home runs, with a career-high 21.1 percent strikeout rate — a perfectly fine season in today’s offensive environment but below his previous standards.
After trading Walker and getting rid of Pedro Alvarez, removing 43 home runs from the right side of the infield, the Pirates hit more home runs this season than last year. They also scored 4.54 runs per game through Thursday, up from 4.30 last year. In that sense, the emphasis on on-base percentage and reducing strikeouts worked. But in the context of the run-scoring environment, the offense regressed: They ranked sixth in the league in runs per game, down from fourth last year, and were only slightly above the average of 4.44. Even in an era of specialized relievers and hard throwers, offense increased this season.
“Their ability to hit elite velocity is as good as ever,” Huntington said. “Guys come out of college now with the ability to hit elite velocity. You go to showcases, and high school players have the ability to hit mid-90s because it seems like they’re seeing more of it.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.