Pirates third base coach Rick Sofield has been criticized a lot over the past two seasons because of his perceived penchant for being over-aggressive in sending runners home and getting them thrown out.
The list of critics, by the way, includes me. I penned this column a few weeks ago when Sofield got Sean Rodriguez thrown out at home in the top of the ninth in a 6-2 loss.
I got the chance to talk to Sofield a few days ago about some of his decisions. Here’s what I learned: being a third base coach is a heck of a lot harder and far more complicated than it seems. It’s mostly a thankless job, and, as Sofield said, the only time anyone ever brings up the third base coach is when he makes a mistake — or a runner is thrown out.
In retrospect, I would have preferred talking to Sofield before I wrote that column, but then again, I’m not sure our conversation would have been as productive, insightful and informative as it turned out to be. Sofield had seen the column and obviously wasn’t thrilled about it, but rather than be confrontational about it, he was gracious enough to spend some time talking about the job, everything that goes into it and why it’s more complicated than anyone who hasn’t done it could ever know.
It was a fascinating discussion because there are so many different levels to that job I’ve never considered, and there are so many variables that there are very few times two situations are exactly the same. All of that enlightenment came before I even turned on the microphone. We spent some time talking about the column, and he even said, “I respect that you have a job to do and that kind of criticism is a part of life in the spotlight for those of us in the profession. It’s just part of it.”
Even if I don’t agree with all of his decisions, Sofield is a stand-up guy who has no issues taking responsibility and being accountable for his mistakes. Those are admirable qualities, and when you combine them with his outgoing personality and sense of humor, it’s easy to see why he’s a clubhouse favorite when players need someone to talk.
Read More
Sofield said he immediately knew it was a mistake when he sent Rodriguez home in the ninth inning in Philadelphia. He chalked it up to a learning experience and said mistakes are sometimes made because the job requires so many split-second decisions. Considering the Pirates scored 722 runs this year, Sofield obviously made a lot more good decisions at third base than bad ones.
“It’s a lot like umpiring. When a guy does a good job nobody notices them,” Sofield said. “It’s the same thing at third. We’re trying to contribute and be a part of the solution, not a part of the problem, but when mistakes are made, well, everyone sees them, and then you just feel really bad about it.
“You just do the best job you can. When I make a mistake, it’s very visible, but when I do something good it’s more oriented to the player’s success, which is how it should be. They should get the credit when they score.”
The other point he made is that the Pirates have a lot of runners — Starling Marte, Josh Harrison, Gregory Polanco and, to a lesser degree, Andrew McCutchen — who are challenging to try to direct because they’re all aggressive and think they can take the next base regardless of where the ball is. Sofield hasn’t just had to spend the past two years learning the nuances of the the job as third base coach, he’s had to learn how to try and rein in a number of those runners without taking away their aggressiveness or instincts. That’s a lot tougher of a task than it sounds. Those players want to try to make something happen, and Sofield has to weigh that in his decision to send them, but it’s always a split-second decision. That’s where things get complicated.
“The guys that run well, they think they’re Superman,” Sofield said.
Sofield, 59, has been a baseball coach/manager pretty much since he was a player in 1981 and has aspirations to be a major-league manager someday. He said the experience he gained the past two years is invaluable. He’s knowledgeable, and his energy and passion are easily detected. He admits his passion gets the best of him sometimes, which can lead to bad decisions.
One thing he made clear, though, is that he’s OK with his reputation of being too aggressive — he’s not-so-affectionately known as Rick “Go”field by some Pirates fans — because that fits the Pirates’ overall philosophy and personnel. He laughed when I asked him if he had ever heard that people refer to him as the “windmill” because, well, he is seemingly always sending runners home.
“No, that’s a new one,” Sofield said. “But I can appreciate it, and I understand it, too. Fans just want their team to win, and believe me, so do all of us in here. And when I make a mistake, or feel like I made a mistake, it eats at me, but I have to let it go and move on.”
Sofield said he works hard to study film and learn about different situations in order to cut down on mistakes on the base paths, but he said experience has been his best teacher.
“We want to be bold and aggressive,” Sofield said. “But the other side of bold and aggressive is stupid. Are we trying to make something happen that is clearly not there? This is the big leagues, and those mistakes and learning opportunities need to be made in the minor leagues.
“I can live with aggressive mistakes, but aggressive mistakes that take away opportunities to win — like the one in Philadelphia — I’m not good with that. That bothers me, but I learned from it, and I’ll never make that mistake again.”
Sofield said his instincts and experience have carried him this far, and for that, he has always been and always will be thankful. He isn’t worried about his job because he and Pirates manager Clint Hurdle talk often, and he has gotten good feedback, even after those times he made mistakes.
I’m obviously not privy to the inner workings of the Pirates, so I have no idea what’s next for Sofield, but I do know that thanks to him, I will never watch baseball the same again. I now have a much better understanding of how hard that job is and how much it entails.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.