POLL: Will the Pirates finish .500 or better? A. Yes (6%) B. No (94%)
Bill Brink: Welcome to the four games under .500 edition of the Pirates chat.
Maz: Did the Pirates years ago buy a bunch of pre-made lineup cards with Cutch batting third and now the Nuttings won't let them purchase blank ones? I don't want to get into the analytics of him batting third, but why is it he is the only one who can't be moved around? We've seen Polanco bat cleanup, and 8th. Just seems ridiculous, and frustrating.
Bill Brink: The analytics of him batting third are actually somewhat important. He's doing less damage by hitting poorly there (as strange as that sounds) than he was hitting second, and given his production in the past five years, he has earned the spot in Hurdle's eyes. In the grand scheme of things, lineup construction doesn't make a ton of difference over the course of a season.
Mike Z.: Will Nova get shut down after official elimination, or start regularly. Will he be re-signed?
Bill Brink: I see no reason why he'd be shut down, and he'd be a good candidate to re-sign. It depends on how his market develops. Happ got three years and $36 million and he was three years older than Nova, so if the market approaches that level, history suggests the Pirates won't do it.
Read More
Had Enough: When are you writers going to start calling out Mr. Nutting for ruining a 98 win team in 1 year, mainly because he doesn't want to spend money? This team right now is an embarrassment.
Bill Brink: I've written a lot this year about how the rotation caused such problems, and that was in large part because it contained Jon Niese, Juan Nicasio and Jeff Locke, and those were front-office decisions. One of the best run-prevention teams a year ago had a lot of trouble with it this year. But the team has also struggled because the players Nutting did spend money on, McCutchen and Liriano, performed very poorly.
Had Enough: Does anyone with half a brain expect the Pirates to resign Nova? This organization didn't even resign Volquez for 2 yrs, 20 million and let Happ walk. He would be the kind of pitcher we need to stabilize the rotation don't you agree? Chances on him coming back?
Bill Brink: I'd say slim, given his age and performance and what Happ got, but he would be a really nice addition to a rotation that right now is Taillon, Cole and possibly three triple-A guys (Kuhl, Glasnow, Williams, Brault, etc.)
Tdippo: Who is this teams leader? Their has been no effort the last week, the body language is terrible, and they look like they've quit. It's been embarrassing to watch.
Bill Brink: The body language has been troubling in the past two weeks. They have different leaders for different units; Cervelli is important in the clubhouse, as is Watson, and McCutchen leads by example, which is when bad body language can be an issue. Guys like Vogelsong and Freese aren't necessarily leaders per se but have been around for a while and can be helpful.
Had Enough: Cole looks really bad. Is this a mental thing now or is something wrong with him physically? He certainly isn't playing himself to a big contract in a few years.
Bill Brink: I can't imagine his elbow is all the way healthy the way he pitched last night. An offseason of rest should help that. But it's also been two months now since he pitched well and healthy and that can creep into the head after a while.
Bill: What's worse -- the Pirates misses on new off-season acquisitions or the unexpected poor performance/regression from 2015 roster. New FAs - Freese, Jaso, Rogers, Niese, Feliz, Vogelsong vs dramatic cliff drop from Cole, McCutchen, Harrison, Kang, Liriano, Locke (who thought he had room to regress?). This team has found an implausible number of ways to disappoint this year.
Bill Brink: That last sentence is a good one. They're both troubling -- the Niese trade looked OK at the time, when you figured you were getting 190 innings of league-average production. Feliz has been pretty good, and I'd say Freese was a great move. But putting Nicasio in the rotation, the way Niese pitched, the past few starts from Vogelsong have all been bad. Regression from McCutchen and Liriano was surprising and hard to find a reason for. I'd say that was worse because the team was built with production from them in mind.
Tachobill: Do you think that it would be more beneficial for the Pirates to go all-in and spend money and/or trade young talent for controllable starters as opposed to (seemingly) being more focused on developing their own players with the hopes that they become quality players? It seems that the result of the second option is hovering around .500 and barely making the playoffs, if that.
Bill Brink: I don't think it's time to blow up the model yet. They won 98 games last season using this organizational strategy and had a lot of things go wrong this season, some of it their fault and some of it not. I agree that getting a controllable starter, especially the way their rotation is shaping up next year, is important, but I don't know that I'd sell the farm for multiple starters.
Had Enough: I watched Davis from Oakland hit his 36th HR last night and I could only drool. If we had 1 guy like that, even with all our struggles this season we might be in the wildcard game at this point. This small ball approach isn't working and the Pirates are only doing it because it is cheap. Do you agree?
Bill Brink: In a sense, I do. Power is hard to find and therefore expensive. Small ball can work at times -- look at the Royals from last year -- but there is a lot less margin for error. Power can clean up mistakes in a hurry, and in a season where the Pirates have had a lot go wrong, they haven't had a power guy who can save some games.
Nicholas: Do you expect Nick Kingham to be in the rotation towards the middle of next season? Cole, Taillon, Glasnow, Kingham, who ever would be an intriguing rotation to finish a year if every one i healthy
Bill Brink: He should be ready, with a half-season of triple-A under his belt, by then, should there be a need due to injury or ineffectiveness. He's pitched well this summer after returning from surgery but against lower-level competition.
Had Enough: My guess is that McCutchen comes back for 1 more year, the Pirates hope he rebounds and Meadows plays well in Indy. Then they deal Cutch at the end of next season and put Meadows in the outfield full-time. Am I onto something?
ta: bill, if you were the GM, what would you do with Andrew? What will NH do with Andrew this offseason? Thanks!
Bill Brink: That's the thing. If they move McCutchen, they can move Marte to center -— he's already the better defensive outfielder — but they need someone to play left (or right if they move Polanco over). I think you're onto something with Meadows' development. They could also try to re-sign Matt Joyce and play him more regularly.
I don't think they'll move him this offseason because they probably want him to rebuild some value by playing well early next year. If they move him now, they might be signaling to other teams that they think this is the beginning of the end rather than a blip.
21 in RF: Do you feel the Pirates are showcasing Josh Bell in the outfield for a possible trade of him or one of the other three outfielders? It has always been reported he was going to be the 1B of the future and he has spent very little time there since he has been recalled.
Bill Brink: This has more to do with Marte being out and the Pirates needing Polanco in left than it does any kind of showcasing. I think he'll play first base almost all the time next year.
Bill: Has McCutchen's regression potentially damaged his value as a trading piece? He's only 29 but he's declining like he's 32. He should be at peak value but we're all seeing the troubling trend. Foot and bat speed suspect. Rising K rates and falling hard hit contact rates. Not htting to all fields. Poor defense. It's like invasion of the body snatchers. I feel terrible for Cutch. He's been too good to slide this dramatically
Bill Brink: I'd have to think so, yes. Scouts see the same thing you do, and other GMs are not going to give up as much as they might have after last season to get him. Letting him build some value early next year by (hopefully) playing well will help.
Had Enough: Bill I know you don't know all the specifics but please give me a reasonable answer as to why a billionaire owner can't add an additional 20-30 million dollars to the payroll? Hasn't he made record profits the past few seasons?
Bill Brink: I don't have access to the books, so it's tough to give a reasonable answer. Maybe he chooses not to because he wants to continue to make profits. Maybe he prefers to put profits toward the farm system and other aspects of the organization. I will caution that the Forbes franchise valuations/profit predictions, industry people say, are not always accurate, because Forbes also doesn't have access to the books.
ta: if epic collapse 3 continues is Hurdle/staff safe?
Bill Brink: Hurdle is safe, and I believe most of his staff will be. The Pirates have run the bases poorly this season and that is Rick Sofield's responsibility, so that's one I would watch.
Bill: Chances of resigning Joyce, Nova, Rodriguez? Chance of dealing Jaso?
Bill Brink: I'd say low for Joyce (probably can get more playing time elsewhere) and Nova (he'll get a contract they won't want to match). Decent for Rodriguez, who seems to really like it here and Hurdle likes him. Higher for dealing Jaso, because they won't want to carry two first basemen next year.
Had Enough: It's strange but sometimes DL stints really help a player tremendously. It happened to Marte I think 2 years ago or last year and now it has helped Kang. Maybe the 15 days allowed him to rest and focus because he looks like the Kang of old. Too bad we didn't have this guy all summer.
Bill Brink: Kang was good, then terrible, then great after the DL, and he'd actually started hitting a little bit before the DL stint. He said when he came back that he felt refreshed, and I bet we see more of this next year, when he has a full offseason to rest and work out rather than rehab his reconstructed knee.
Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.
AndrewN: Chances that Cole is dealt at deadline next year?
Bill Brink: I'd say very low. If he's bad, he won't have much value; if he's good, they'll need him to compete.
Had Enough: Locke back next year? Please please please say no
Bill Brink: He would appear to be a non-tender candidate given his role and that he's entering his second year of arbitration.
Bill: I still think arrow is pointing up but the rotation looks less than settled. Is FO concerned about the logjam of young pitchers arriving at the same time. Even Mets struggled with this for a few years. Would rather see of mix of young and established arms, ,but Locke and Liriano did them no favors this year.
Bill Brink: The caliber of arms the Pirates have arriving isn't quite like what the Mets had. Contrary to concern, they're glad they're all ready or close to it; pitching depth is crucial.
ta: will we be a contender in 2017? the reds of a couple years ago had a TON of talent and were bottom feeders...June and sept have me very discouraged about the future
Bill Brink: There's a path to it. McCutchen and Cole rebound, they sign a good starter in the offseason, add a bullpen piece, Bell hits well and handles first base OK, Kang returns to his usual self ... things have to go right, but there's a path.
Bill Brink: That's it for today, thanks for all the great questions. We might have a time change next week because I'll be traveling to Milwaukee on Tuesday, but we'll still chat away.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.