Jim in VT: Is this the bullpen crew for the rest of the year? Or, may they be considering the likes of FA Papelbon or D. Robertson (Cleared waivers)
Bill Brink: I think so, and if so, that's not a bad crew. They quietly have the third-best ERA in the NL this season and the best ERA in the league since the All-Star break.
Kyle (Omaha): Did Hurdle punt the game last night when he decided to have the infield in with no outs and runners on the corners with the Bucs up one? Did he really feel they had to win in that inning or the game was over?
Guest: In the 13th inning with runners on 1st and 3rd and 0 outs, why play the 2b and ss in on the grass. Could have had an easy double play ball, but Harrison had such limited range playing that close. I know we were short on bullpen, but I think that decision cost us the game.
Bill Brink: I don't believe that constitutes punting. I do believe it merits discussion. Hurdle was intent on not using Nicasio or Bastardo and did not want to concede a tying run that would extend the game. He had a lead and he managed to conserve it; it didn't work. I can see both sides.
Guest: I think Arrietta got pulled one batter later, but how come the pirates didn't notice the two mound visits in one inning
Bill Brink: They noticed. Hurdle told us the Pirates' dugout was under the impression one was a visit and one was an argument with the umpires.
Guest: Any chance Marte gets top 15 in MVP voting?
Bill Brink: Someone asked me last week about top 20 and I thought he would get in that range. Looking at where he stands right now among NL players (20th in Fangraphs WAR among position players, as an easy starting point), I think he passes a few of them but also might get bumped down if some people rank pitchers ahead of him, so 15 to 20 is about right.
Andrew: Hutchison looks like he's going to be the next Jeff Locke through is first few outings in Indy except he falls apart an inning earlier. Your thoughts?
Bill Brink: I'll reserve final judgment until I see him pitch live, but the early returns haven't been great. He's got a 5.46 ERA in six triple-A appearances with 14 walks in 29.2 innings. He did just join a new organization, so let's give him a spring training with the club before we write him off entirely.
NickRousseau: I am still aggravated that Hurdle didn't bring in Nicasio in the bottom of the 13th to close the game. WHY DID HE LEAVE IN LOCKE!?
Bill Brink: Hurdle did not want to use Nicasio, who threw three innings and 48 pitches Saturday, or Bastardo, who had either pitched or warmed up in the bullpen five consecutive days. He's been steadfast in these situations for the past few years, especially later in the season.
JIm: Your prediction for next year's starting rotation
Bill Brink: Cole, Taillon, Kuhl, triple-A guy, external acquisition.
Guest: If the Pirates run out of pitching options in an extra inning game, who is the first positional player to pitch?
Bill Brink: Hurdle addressed this once when Harrison pitched in Coors; it needs to be someone who is not an everyday player, in case of a liner off the shin or something to that effect. That's why Hurdle used Kratz earlier this year. I believe he's also mentioned Rodriguez as a candidate.
Andrew: What do the Pirates do work Hanson next year?
Bill Brink: It seems like Hanson's chance to contribute at the major league level is as a utility player who can play quality defense at multiple positions, but Frazier has probably already passed him there.
Darnell Geritt Coles: Did the Pirates get an MRI on Glasnow's shoulder? It seems you'd want to know whether there's inflammation and shut him down to protect your investment. Perhaps they don't want to know, but stringing him along through these awkward start-stop rehab starts doesn't seem to be working.
Bill Brink: They activated him from the DL and Hurdle said he's healthy. The shoulder isn't the issue anymore, it's the pitch efficiency.
Tony Luke: How can the Pirates mgmt say with a straight face they are fighting for a world series championship when they inexplicably traded Caminero, allowed Luebke and Lobstein to hurt the team for months and the continual use of horrible Jeff Locke?
Bill Brink: Love your cheesesteaks, Tony. The points on Caminero and Luebke are fair. Caminero was much better when he returned from the DL and Luebke never really got it going. Lobstein was more a factor of too few innings from the rotation early in the season, forcing the turnover of, and too much exposure for, the middle relievers. Sticking with Locke in the rotation is a fair criticism as well, though I think last night's situation was separate.
Guest: Any chance the pirates sign nova?
Wayward: Bucs think of enough of the early returns on Nova to try to sign him as an FA? What does it take, Happ type of deal?
Bill Brink: Nova is 29, younger than Happ was. It depends on if other teams think enough of Nova to give him a big deal based on two months, like Toronto did with Happ. His younger age might mean the Pirates are more interested in retaining him. He'll want at least two years, I'd think, maybe more. I wouldn't rule it out.
Tony Luke: Why don't beat writers like you press Hurdle on why he wears out the bullpen every year? Our guys are tired and it is showing.
Bill Brink: We press him when required, but his use of the bullpen isn't one that needs pressing. He takes good care of their arms, to the point where I hear more from fans upset he wouldn't use Nicasio or Bastardo last night than that they're tired. They also have the best ERA in the NL since the All-Star break.
Indy Fan: I noticed you didn't include Glasnow in your prediction for next year's rotation? Or did you, when you said AAA guy? Or are you saying it's going to be a fun spring training to see who can lock down that fifth starter spot?
Bill Brink: Options two and three hit it right on the head.
Tony Luke: I don't know maybe it's just me but nothing really I have seen from Josh Bell playing 1st base has convinced me that the Pirates were right in sending him back down for 6 weeks in July and August. That move was really bad because with Bell up the whole time we might be in the playoff game right now. Do you agree?
Bill Brink: I agree more in the sense that his offense would have helped a good deal rather than that his defense is good. Scouts I talked to said it was as bad as advertised early but has improved a decent amount over the course of the season, and his athleticism allows him to get away with some learning curves. I still see some issues, but it's getting there.
Andrew: Is Jeff locke on the team next year?
Bill Brink: He's eligible for his second year of arbitration, so he's a non-tender candidate at this point.
Jaff Ted Decker: While I'm unsure what the Freese signing means for Jung-Ho, it's definitely an acknowledgement that the Broxton-Jason Rogers trade is a bust. Would you agree?
Bill Brink: I would agree.
Tommy Sandt: Did you ask Marte what happened on that fly ball to left early in yesterday's game?
Bill Brink: No. The game provided many other topics for postgame discussion.
Midre Cummings: I heard Clint is no longer chewing gum. What's the deal?
Bill Brink: I'll defer you to Stephen J. Nesbitt, who was in Milwaukee during gumgate. Sounds like a good question for his mailbag, @stephenjnesbitt on Twitter or snesbitt@post-gazette.com.
JamesinNYC: Will they make an offer to Nova for one year just to get the draft pick if nothing else? Worse case he signs it and you get him on a 1 year deal.
Bill Brink: Good question. My inclination is I don't think so, because they might not want to pay $16 million after two months of good performance, but if he keeps pitching well and they're pretty confident he'll take a multi-year deal they just might.
Tony Luke: Feliz is starting to worry me. It seems like every recent outing is a scary one and he has not looked like the guy early on for awhile now. Should he not be allowed to pitch for a week or so to give his arm some rest?
Bill Brink: I think a rest is coming. He pitched in the first three games of the Milwaukee series and in four of the last five, throwing 29 pitches last night.
Wayward: Kingham have a chance to compete for a rotation spot next year? Also curious about Cumpton, & Sadler whom a lot thought were just AAAA type of guys.
Bill Brink: Kingham, yes. Cumpton and Sadler are coming off serious injuries and don't have as high an upside as Kingham does.
Tike Redman: Marte getting caught in the run-down between third and home isn't his fault as much as it is Cervelli's. Frankly, I'd rather have seen Jordy up in that spot. Cervelli doesn't even have the highest slugging percentage amongst Pirates named Francisco this year (that would belong to Liriano). Isn't it time to move Cervelli to eighth?
Bill Brink: At that point in the lineup, flipping guys won't make too much difference in the long run. The other argument is, you might get better pitches to hit early in the game rather than having pitchers work around you to get to the pitcher.
Guest: Josh Bell play winter ball to get more reps in at 1B?
Bill Brink: Don't think so. He'll have played a full season. I'm sure he'll work on it in the offseason though.
Indy Fan: How many people can the Pirates call up on Thursday? I know we talked briefly about some pitching help coming the bullpen's way, but what about Trevor Williams, or Frank Duncan? Do they pitch out of the bullpen or do they get a spot start or two? Also what about Meadows, will he get his first taste of the big leagues this year?
Bill Brink: They can call up as many as they want, but Hurdle and Huntington say they will only call up as many as they can use. Williams probably more likely than Duncan. Spot starts will depend on Cole and Glasnow's status. Meadows not impossible but unlikely.
Guest: Does Marte have one of the best arms in the league or is there someone that stands out as being better?
Bill Brink: Off the top of my head, it's right up there if not the best. Cespedes has a good one too, and Jay Bruce has always had a strong arm.
Tony Luke: I see a 30 HR 110 RBI season for Polanco next season. What do you think? He can be a full blown superstar next year I believe.
Bill Brink: He's certainly shown the power this season to do it. He's putting together a good start to his career and he's young yet.
Guest: Whats you opinion on Steven Brault moving into September? Does he figure in as a bullpen guy?
Bill Brink: Also depends on Cole/Glasnow and what the Pirates do with each of them.
Jason Thompson Twins: Why is Eric Fryer on this team instead of Elias Diaz? I don't think Fryer has tagged out a single runner on a throw home, and he's got two hits in his last 30 ABs.
Bill Brink: The defensive point stands. But Diaz has a .278 OBP and a .286 slugging since going back down to the minors in late July.
J.G. Wentworth: Any rumblings about the Bucs getting someone off the waiver wire?
Bill Brink: I've heard they're looking, as always, but nothing imminent -- which, with the waiver timeline, they usually happen quickly.
AZ: What does the bullpen look like next year?
Bill Brink: Too soon to paint a good picture. Watson, Hughes, Bastardo, Rivero. Maybe Schugel.
Tony Luke: If the Pirates somehow get into the wildcard game, who starts for them? I'm thinking Nova. Initially it was Tallon in my mind but after his last start I'm thinking he is not ready yet to face that kind of pressure.
Bill Brink: Another good question. My guess now is Taillon, but Nova has more big league experience and they might want to go with him in that setting.
Guest: I'm thinking next years bench consists of Freese, Jaso, Stewart, and Frazier. Who is the fifth spot? S Rod possibly?
Bill Brink: This year's bench is still in flux. Too early to forecast next year's.
Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.
Indy Fan: Great question about which starter to use in the one game wild card game. If Cole is healthy, does he get the nod, or at this point would they prefer a fresh look?
Jim in VT: Cole returns?....
Bill Brink: We'll know more today, when we talk to Cole and athletic trainer Todd Tomczyk. We also don't know what is causing the posterior inflammation.
Guest: Is it plain pizza or cheese pizza?
Bill Brink: I believe the correct answer is pepperoni.
Bill Brink: That's it for today, thanks for all the great questions! We'll do this again next week.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.