Andy Castellanos believes he has one of Honus Wagner’s favorite bats, and he’ll sell it to the highest bidder.
Online bidding begins at 8 p.m. today at mearsonline.com for a century-old J.F. Hillerich & Son Louisville Slugger that the Florida man bought on eBay several years ago from a Youngstown woman. So how does he know it belonged to the Pirates’ Hall of Fame shortstop?
Because it has marks indicating it was used as a pro ballplayer’s template bat and it had his picture and autograph on it — until a few hundred well-hit baseballs nearly rubbed it clean.
But the key clue that this 41.6-ounce piece of ash wood was once Wagner’s are some faint black streaks on its barrel. They’re creosote containing coal tar, the same preservative used on the ties and tracks that ran beside Wagner’s childhood home on Railroad Avenue in Carnegie. Hitters used many substances to harden their bats, but only this son of coal miner boiled his in coal tar.
“I wasn’t expecting it. It was a contributing factor” linking the bat to Wagner, said Troy Kinunen, president and CEO of Memorabilia Evaluation and Research Services of Milwaukee.
Kinunen, who recently finished analyzing Castellanos’ bat, will pass it on to the auction arm of his company for the reserve auction, which ends at 10 p.m. July 2. The starting bid is $10,000.
The bat’s owner, who plans to use the auction proceeds to buy a car for his 19-year-old son, also named Andy, believes it could be worth $100,000. Next week, he’ll find out if collectors agree.
“My son is going to college and he needed a car. It was time to let it go,” he said.
Many years ago, Castellanos, 54, of Parkland, Fla., received a bat from his father that had belonged to Hall of Fame catcher Roy Campanella. But when he and his son started collecting bats seven years ago, they were drawn to the oldest, rarest ones used by the earliest Hall of Famers. He has bought bats used by Chicago Cubs infielder Johnny Evers, and Ty Cobb, the Detroit Tiger who joined Wagner in Cooperstown’s first class of inductees in 1936.
The Cobb bat and Wagner’s have decals with the ballplayers’ picture and autograph on them, a precursor to the branded signatures that came later. The Wagner decal and center brand date the bat to 1905-10. Wagner was the first Louisville Slugger, reflecting his move from the Louisville Colonels to the Pirates in 1899.
Decal bats were sometimes sold in stores. Bats with the remains of a Wagner decal have sold at auction for $1,000. Kinunen believes this bat is worth much more because it has lathe marks and coal tar linking it to Wagner.
“He sent it to have more made just like it. That’s pretty special,” he said.
Retail bats are made in large quantities and their lathe marks sanded off before sale. But chuck marks remaining on a bat’s knob and top indicate it was taken on and off the lathe several times as it was replicated, Kinunen said.
When Castellanos saw the lathe marks on eBay photos of this bat two years ago, he knew it might be special. He bid and paid $6,000 to a Youngstown man whose mother had owned it for many years but knew little about it. Then he sent photos to Kinunen, an expert on decal bats who had evaluated and sold his Cobb bat several years before. Kinunen was intrigued by the lathe marks; the owner was more curious about the black streaks.
Castellanos, who owns a wound care practice with several physicians, borrowed a scalpel to scrape off a little of the black substance and sent it to a lab for analysis. When the lab identified it as coal tar creosote, Kinunen recalled that the same substance was found on an even older Lucky Special bat linked to Wagner. It sold at auction for $250,000.
Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1978.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.