The MLB amateur draft had barely concluded Saturday night and Pirates director of amateur scouting Joe DelliCarri was already 24 hours into the process of signing the players selected.
“Last night a little bit, then a lot more calls tonight,” DelliCarri said on a conference call Saturday from Pirate City in Bradenton, Fla.
In the fifth draft since the current collective bargaining agreement capped bonus spending, and the final one before the CBA expires in December, the effect of assigned slot values was apparent. Of the 41 players the Pirates selected, six were high school players.
“It’s the new system,” general manager Neal Huntington said. “Get used to it.”
Elite high school players have leverage to ask for high signing bonuses. If they don’t like the offer, they can go to college, mature physically and mentally for three years, get high-level coaching and enter the draft again with the chance of a higher payday. College players don’t have that leverage. The signing deadline is July 15.
“As the industry shifts, you’ve seen high school players go earlier and earlier if they’re signable,” Huntington said. “You’ve got guys that are coming off the board earlier than they would in certain situations because they are signable high school players. Once you get beyond a certain point in the draft, you’re looking at probably 80 percent college and 20 percent high school from the selection pool; at other points in the draft, it’s even heavier than that. It’s not a strategy. It’s the reality of the new system.”
Read More
The Pirates used their first-round pick, at No. 22 overall, on Will Craig, a third baseman from Wake Forest. With three of their next four picks, the Pirates took a high school player: left-hander Nick Lodolo with their competitive balance lottery pick, right-hander Travis MacGregor in the second round and left-hander Braeden Ogle in the fourth. All have committed to colleges with good baseball programs: Lodolo to TCU, MacGregor to Clemson and Ogle to Florida.
“We took players that we like and believe we have a realistic chance to sign,” Huntington said. “There are times where the dollar figure will get away from where we feel it is appropriate. We may end up getting an extra pick next year in the draft [as compensation for not signing a player].”
The bonus system puts guidelines on that dollar figure. MLB assigns a value to every selection in the top 10 rounds, and the total value of a team’s picks in those rounds equals their bonus pool. They can allocate that pool however they see fit, but if they don’t sign a specific player, they lose the value of his slot. If they exceed the pool, they pay a 75 percent tax on the overage, and if they exceed the pool by more than 5 percent, they lose a first-round draft pick the following year.
The Pirates’ pool is worth $7,007,900 this year, which ranks 17th among the 30 teams. Craig’s slot value is $2,253,700; Lodolo’s, $1,576,000; Macgregor’s, $948,000; and Ogle’s, $425,700.
All teams look for opportunities to save money that might be needed to sign high school players away from college scholarships. The Pirates took two college seniors, Michigan State left-hander Cam Vieaux and Morehead State right-hander Matthew Anderson, in the top 10 rounds. With few exceptions, college players are eligible to be drafted after their junior season.
“We believe Joe and our guys do a terrific job of finding players that will help us in some way, shape or form regardless of the pool,” Huntington said. “The pool allotment certainly has an impact regardless of your process.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.