Outside of the Sharks and their fans, the group happiest that San Jose managed to win Game 5 and extend the Stanley Cup final until Sunday had to be the Pirates.

If they weren’t, they should be. And they way things are going, they probably should have rooted for a Game 7 too.

The Penguins’ quest for a Stanley Cup served as a very nice distraction, and thus most people haven’t yet noticed that the Pirates are in the midst of quite a meltdown.

The Pirates have lost five in a row and have lost 12 of their last 16 and have fallen into third place in the National League Central.

Advertise with us

They are now 11½ games behind the Cubs and three games behind the Cardinals, and their pitching staff appears to be in utter disarray. This is a dangerous, dangerous time for the Pirates and their playoff hopes.

Yes, it’s still June — but this stretch of games the Pirates are in isn’t very forgiving, and if they aren’t careful they could get to the All-Star break and be buried for even the wild card.

In case you missed it, Francisco Cervelli is out until after the All-Star break with a broken bone in his hand, Gerrit Cole is likely headed for the DL and Francisco Liriano might not be far behind.

And just in case that’s not enough, the All-Star center fielder, whose slow start was supposed to end by mid-May like it always does, looks kind of lost, too, and his slow start has now extended into mid-June.

The Pirates have been very, very good over the last three years at navigating through choppy waters and regrouping just when it looks like things are going south, but this feels a little different than most of the slumps they’ve been through recently.

Advertise with us

Most of their slumps in the last few years have been more about losing games or having those stretches where the ball just doesn’t bounce their way; this is fueled by bad pitching and injuries.

There isn’t really much anyone can do about injuries. To be honest, the Pirates have handled them about as well as any team and have been very good at manipulating their roster to navigate through the times they are shorthanded.

But in those times, they had depth, and that’s something that I’m not really sure they have right now, especially when it comes to the pitching staff.

The Pirates are a team allegedly built on their pitching and its depth but as of today they are ninth in the NL and sinking in team ERA (4.24), they are 11th in batting average against (.262), 11th in on-base percentage (.338) and 12th in WHIP (1.40).

Let’s assume that the recent outings of Jeff Locke (4⅔ innings, 11 hits and 11 earned runs) and Jonathon Niese (5⅓, 11 hits, 8 runs) were just a bad day at the office and they are healthy and will bounce back next time around.

Advertise with us

That gives you two pitchers out of your five who you can rely on right now. The other three spots are right now very much in question.

Cole left Friday’s game with some sort of triceps injury, and while Neal Huntington said it is muscle related and not ligament related (which means surgery isn’t likely), he is still likely headed for the DL.

Liriano had his last start pushed back three days, and he was better than he had been. But he still lost (he was a victim to some bad defense) and he wasn’t terribly efficient (103 pitches, 58 strikes in six innings).

It appears that Liriano is healthy, but if he has a couple more tough starts, it won’t shock me if he heads to the DL with some sort of mysterious arm discomfort so he works out his control issues.

And then there is Juan Nicasio, who appears to be headed to the bullpen, but his first stint as a reliever came Friday night and it was a disaster (one inning, four hits, six runs).

Advertise with us

I know Jameson Taillon will be back (likely as soon as Cole to the DL is official) and he obviously has talent, but he is a rookie and he looked like a rookie at times in his debut last week. He will get better as he gets experience, but the Pirates don’t have the luxury of having a guy learn on the job in this stretch of games given how far back they’ve fallen in the standings.

After Taillon, though, what’s the next answer for the rotation?

Tyler Glasnow sounds like a supremely talented pitcher who has yet to develop all of his pitches enough to the point where Huntington and company believe he can get major league hitters out consistently.

That means as of right now the rotation is a shaky Liriano, Niese, Locke, Taillon and, um, Nicasio ... or maybe Glasnow?

And this is the staff the Pirates will take into a stretch of games against the Mets (who they at least generally play well against), Cubs, Giants, Dodgers and Mariners.

Advertise with us

We haven’t even touched on the bullpen, which has become a revolving door of Lobsteins, Camineros, Luebkes, Scahills, Schugels and now Nicasios, and none of them seem to be very good in large doses.

Even Tony Watson has had some rough outings recently, but at least Jared Hughes, Neftali Feliz and Mark Melancon have been pretty good.

I’m not one to sound the alarm in June. I’m not a doom and gloom guy. I’ve never been that guy and never will be. But I don’t think it is unfair to suggest that the Pirates have some real issues and there don’t seem to be a lot of solutions.

The Pirates can turn this around, and in the past three years, it’s just about this time that they have turned it around. But they are going to need a couple of guys to pitch much better than they have, and they need McCutchen to get back on track.

If those things happen, they can at least stay afloat until they get healthy again. But if they don’t, they will sink, and this year they may not be able to recover.