Bill Brink: Thanks for the questions, guys, and here we go...
Nicholas: Who do you see being our catcher after Cervelli's extension ends? Diaz, McGuire, or someone we don't have yet?
Bill Brink: It's hard to predict what will happen 31/2 years from now. I continue to hear from evaluators that McGuire's defense is as good as was advertised when he was drafted, and that if the bat catches up, he'll be great. That alone should get him to the majors. He'd be my long-range pick, but it could be a tandem of McGuire and Diaz.
MFlynn6: Good Morning/Afternoon, I have 2 questions, first being since Reese McGuire should hopefully be ready in a year or two, and Cervelli locked in for 3 years, does this spell the end for Elias Diaz? The second is how long do you think in reality they wait to bring up Glasnow and Taillon?
Bill Brink: Organizations hate to part with catching depth because of the injury rate at the position. They take a beating back there. I don't think so.
In reality, they'll wait both until there's an opening in the rotation, either due to injury or ineffectiveness, and until they think the Super Two deadline has passed, maybe early to mid-June. But those two things might not happen at the same time.
Dusty: As for Vogelsong getting hurt yesterday...are the Pirates going to bring up Taillon or a another top prospect to fill the void while he is gone?
Bill Brink: I don't think so. Vogelsong was not in the rotation, so they don't need a starter, and they want Taillon to keep getting experience every fifth day in the triple-A rotation. They will probably bring up Luebke, Schugel, Scahill, etc.
Matt: Concerned over Reese McGuire's offensive struggles? Seems like he has MLB starter upside just with his defense alone.
Bill Brink: With the caveat that I haven't seen McGuire in person since spring training, no, I'm not concerned. He doesn't have much power, but he's only 21 and that's not really one of the tools that makes him valuable anyway. The 15-to-8 walk-to-strikeout ratio and .363 OBP at Altoona have me encouraged.
Matt: If RV needs a DL trip, who gets the call for bullpen help? Maybe Schugel?
Bill Brink: Maybe Schugel. Luebke, Lobstein and Scahill (maybe two of them) are possible. I discussed that a bit in this blog post.
Matt: When they fly to Denver for the makeup game might they leave some guys back in Pittsburgh? maybe the following day's starting pitcher?
Bill Brink: Maybe the following day's starting pitcher, yes. Can't see a reason to put him on two cross-country plane rides in 24 hours.
Matt: Is Matt Joyce playing himself into a starting OF job somewhere in MLB next year?
Bill Brink: At the least, maybe an everyday platoon player who starts against righties. He's making that .564 OPS in 2015 look like a fluke, and doing it with sporadic playing time, which is really hard to do.
Sweens: Who do you think we'll see coming up in the mid-June callups, and when do you think they'll start coming? Also, do you make anything of Boscan being the first pitcher to arrive in Pittsburgh?
Bill Brink: Other than the relievers we might see this afternoon, it's tough to tell without knowing the state of the major league team. We could see Hanson again if something happens to a middle infielder. Jaso has been so good, I don't know that we see Bell right away. One of the two starters -- three, really; Chad Kuhl deserves some love -- could come up at some point, but I think that depends more on the major league rotation at this point.
I don't make much of Boscan being the first one up, other than he's had his experience in triple-A and he's not a prospect like Taillon or Glasnow, so they aren't worried as much about a major league stint interrupting his development.
Guest: Is Vogelsong still in a coma? I'm very concerned about his long-term health and immediate health.
Bill Brink: To our knowledge, he was never in a coma; he was conscious as he left the field. His wife tweeted that he is "stable and will be OK." Really good news, considering what could have happened.
Guest: Do you expect the Buccos to retaliate by hitting a Rockie next time we play them?
Bill Brink: I don't. I don't think anyone judged intent on an 0-2 pitch to the starter with the bases loaded. A pitch got away from a young starter who hasn't had great command, and I don't think retaliating would even any sort of score.
Guest: What is the name of Sterling Marte's new baby? I like what he named his last kid - Smerling.
Bill Brink: His baby daughter's name is Tiana.
Guest: Was Mickey Mantle the greatest switch hitter of all time?
Bill Brink: I'd have to think he's on the short list, with Chipper, Beltran, Tim Raines, Ozzie, Pete Rose.
Guest: The pirates play a bunch of games in a row now - is that a good or bad thing?
Bill Brink: In their eyes, it kind of is what it is. It can be good in that it keeps starters on their fifth day, which some of them really like, and keeps the hitters on time at the plate.
Guest: Hey Brink, I know that in previous chats you've belittled the importance of the draft in MLB. However, it is coming up - any idea what positions or prospects the pirates might target?
Bill Brink: At no point did I belittle the draft — I said it's tough to predict who a team will take 22nd. MLB.com's mock draft has actually linked the Pirates to Pitt righty T.J. Zeuch. I've also seen Virginia catcher Matt Thiass (ESPN's Keith Law) and high school outfielder Taylor Trammell (Baseball America). Their recent history indicates they like good up-the-middle defenders who can make contact, so that's what I'd look for.
Bill Brink: Relax about Mantle, people. I listed some other good switch-hitters for context.
Guest: Fun question - in your humble opinion, which Pirate has the best walk up at bat music?
Bill Brink: I'm a big fan of Mercer's: "The Fire," by The Roots with John Legend.
Todd in Ny: If Taillion called up where do they put him in rotation?? Between Locke and Neise?? Thinking Nicasio goes to pen to help there! What say you?
Bill Brink: That's a good notion; splits up the lefties, strengthens the bullpen. I still think it depends on the state of the rotation -- who's pitching well, who's not -- when the Pirates deem Taillon ready for a promotion.
Tim: I really like the position player lineup even w/o a true power hitter. So you see this continuing in the next couple years with the core 8 locked up?
Bill Brink: I do, because, while people are taking steps forward, nobody is performing in a way that says, "No way he keeps this up." And McCutchen still isn't hitting like he can and has.
Nicholas: Kuhl possibly coming up to start or bullpen this year? Or is he more likely next year
Bill Brink: Huntington mentioned both starting and the bullpen when we talked about Kuhl on Sunday. I could see later this season if his performance keeps up, certainly in September when rosters expand.
Sweens: Are you putting anything to McCutchen's struggles yet? I know he struggled last year, but then it was due to the rib injury coming out of spring training, and he was back to the .330 mark for May. It doesn't look like we're seeing the same thing this year.
Bill Brink: Yes. We're past the quarter mark of the season, so small sample size begins to ebb and we can take a little something from what's been happening. I still defer to McCutchen's long track record and believe eventually he will get back there, but we can't deny what's going on. He's walking less and striking out more. He's swinging at more pitches and making less contact. Last spring it was the knee, not so much the ribs, that troubled him; this year we don't really know what it is.
Jim: Bill, given Joyce's hot bat and Palonco's nonchalant ways in right. Is there a chance Clint will send a message to the young Palonco? If he hustled out there....he'd be dangerous, all the time!
Bill Brink: The coaching staff will talk to Polanco when he makes mistakes, but I don't think they'll send a message by benching him for Joyce. Polanco has been one of their best players.
Mark: Why don't the Pirates/anyone know when the Super Two deadline is?
Bill Brink: Good question — because it's not really a deadline. There's no date attached to it. Each year, the top 22 percent of players with at least two but fewer than three years of service time qualify for Super Two, meaning they get four years of arbitration instead of three. The point was so that teams could not manipulate service time. When they call up players, they have to estimate a moving target three years in the future based on how many other teams call up other minor leaguers. But teams have reverse-engineered the formula, giving us the late May - early June window we currently have.
Bill Brink: what other questions do we have today?
Matt: Is Jaso the emergency catcher or have his concussions ruled out any time behind the plate?
Bill Brink: He has said he can go back there, but Hurdle has said there'd be some reluctance due to the concussion history.
Sweens: How do you see the NL Central race playing out down the stretch? Think we get 3 teams in the playoffs again this year
Bill Brink: Good chance, but it won't be easy. I like the Giants a lot (easy to say now, I know, but ask Nesbitt, I liked them pre-season) and if the Dodgers can find a way to win when Kershaw doesn't pitch, we could see two teams from the West. Mets and Nats will be tough in the East. I bet at least two NL Central teams.
Alan in Columbus: Do you think batting 2nd has affected Cutch one way or the other. Has Cutch commented on batting second lately?
Bill Brink: He has not, at least not when I've spoken with him. I don't think McCutchen is a batter that thinks about that stuff all that much. Whenever I ask him about hitting, good or bad, he stays pretty even keeled, and trusts his skills and his process.
Matt: Early predictions for Pirates that make the all star game?
Bill Brink: Marte, Polanco, Melancon. Harrison a maybe. Cole could get there.
Matt: Best PNC park food item?
Bill Brink: Been a while since I've ventured out, but I think there's a sandwich on the first level down the left-field line with chicken and a pierogie on it. I like Manny's BBQ as well. I hear there's a new pizza place that's good, and club level now has street tacos and nachos that are on my list to try.
Bill Brink: I'd go Manny's as my favorite.
Jim in VT: Bill, I believe that for Super two status to apply, a player must have at least 140 MLB service days in the rookie season, but parsing the rule isn't easy
Bill Brink: Nothing about 140 days, but you must have 86 days in the season immediately preceding the offseason where you're eligible for Super Two.
Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.
Sweens: Do you have a favorite minor league ballpark?
Bill Brink: I haven't been to enough for a true sampling. In the Pirates' system, I like Appalachian Power Park (low-A West Virginia) because of the Toastman.
Matt: Favorite craft beer?
Bill Brink: How much time do we have? Anything Stone brews. Probably a tie between 21st Amendment Hop Crisis and Alpha King Three Floyd's.
Bill: Does the Cervelli extension reflect any doubts on Diaz's potential as an starting catcher? If he's projected as a #2 (like Stewart), wouldn't that mean they took a real risk at a critical position by not locking up Martin? Cervelli wasn't a lottery ticket but no one could have foreseen this high level of production.
Bill Brink: The Cervelli acquisition was related to Martin's departure, but the extension was not. Huntington also said it wasn't related to Diaz, or his surgery, though keeping Cervelli around makes the team better during a window when they have McCutchen, Liriano, Cole, Marte, Kang, Harrison and Polanco around.
Bill Brink: That's it for today, thanks for all the questions. Stephen Nesbitt will do a mailbag on Thursday, so send him questions at snesbitt@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.