DETROIT — One day after the Pirates pestered Justin Verlander with early baserunners and a high pitch count, the Detroit Tigers returned the favor against Juan Nicasio.

Nicasio could not consistently locate his pitches and the Tigers took advantage of the ones that did find the strike zone. Nicasio finished only three innings in an 8-2 loss Tuesday at Comerica Park.

Nicasio (1-1) needed 94 pitches, only 52 strikes, to record nine outs. Of the 19 batters Nicasio faced, 11 reached base. Five of them walked. Four scored.

“We really couldn’t get anything connected for an extended period of time,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “It’s one of those days, I think, when you look back at it, he just didn’t have it today.”

Advertise with us

Nicasio’s five walks matched the number he issued in 15 spring-training innings. His spring performance earned him a spot in the starting rotation. His Pirates debut was strong — he didn’t walk a batter in his first start of the regular season, when he struck out seven and allowed one run in six innings against the St. Louis Cardinals.

But Tuesday he could not locate his fastball. He often missed high.

“When you don’t have command of your fastball, it’s hard because you don’t want to throw your breaking ball for a strike,” Nicasio said. “Big hitter, big situation, you don’t want to throw your breaking ball for a strike.”

He did just that in the first inning, and it cost him.

Two batters in, Nicasio hung a 1-1 slider over the middle of the plate to Justin Upton. Upton hit it 451 feet into the camera well in center field. Francisco Cervelli wanted the slider on the outside corner. Nicasio threw it down the middle. That pitch was a harbinger of his command issues.

Advertise with us

Nicasio followed Upton’s homer with walks to Miguel Cabrera and Victor Martinez. He left another slider up and over the plate to J.D. Martinez, a slider that became an RBI single.

The Tigers scored two runs in the second even after Cervelli threw out Anthony Gose at third on the front end of a double steal for the inning’s second out. Josh Harrison dived to stop Upton’s grounder between first and second base. He had no play on Upton, but threw home to try to stop Ian Kinsler — whom Nicasio had walked — from scoring. The throw went into the stands and Upton reached third on a two-base error. Cabrera brought home another run, and the Tigers led 4-0 through five innings.

David Freese extended the Pirartes’ sixth inning when the throw on a two-out infield single pulled Cabrera off the bag. Starling Marte followed with his second homer of the season.

Marte went 2 for 4 with a homer and a double.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.