CINCINNATI — The show went on Sunday afternoon, same as it has for four years. An opposing pitcher hit Andrew McCutchen. The Pirates retaliated. The dugouts cleared, players were ejected and everyone afterward talked about pitching inside and protecting their teammates.
“More rugby than cage fighting,” is how Cincinnati Reds manager Bryan Price described the extended scrum on the field in the Pirates’ 3-0 victory at Great American Ball Park, and that is what it amounted to — pushing, shoving, shouting. Twice the tension evaporated and players began gathering their things, only to surround each other and begin shoving once more.
The issue started Saturday, when Pirates reliever Joe Blanton hit Marlon Byrd near his head. Really, it started in 2012, when Aroldis Chapman hit McCutchen with a 101 mph fastball, or when Brandon Phillips and Jared Hughes got into it, but Blanton renewed the issue.
“[Saturday] night they threw at my head — and they missed,” Byrd said.
In the eighth inning Sunday, Pedro Villarreal hit McCutchen in the right shoulder blade with the first pitch of the at-bat.
“I was a bit surprised that they would want to retaliate,” McCutchen said. “You should do that early in the game and get it over with. To wait until the eighth inning and face … not being cocky, but the best player on the team, and you hit the best player. I didn’t quite understand that. Unless Byrd’s the best player for them. I don’t know.”
Read More
In the bottom of the inning, Tony Watson retired Reds hitter Jason Bourgeois before drilling Phillips with the first pitch.
“I just pound fastballs in, you guys have seen that for the last four years,” Watson said. “Got away. I don’t need to sit here and explain.”
The dugouts and bullpens emptied. Pirates catcher Francisco Cervelli got into it with Todd Frazier and Skip Schumaker. Byrd and Sean Rodriguez came face-to-face. Byrd, Rodriguez and Joey Votto were ejected, and the benches were warned.
Rodriguez declined to comment on the situation.
In the ninth, Pirates closer Mark Melancon allowed a leadoff double to Jay Bruce. After a groundout, Melancon hit Tucker Barnhart. Doing so brought the tying run to the plate and it appeared unintentional, but home-plate umpire D.J. Reyburn ejected Melancon.
“As a closer, knowing the situation, guy’s already on base, tying run comes up to the plate if you hit him … I feel like the feel for the game is necessary there,” Melancon said.
The Pirates entered the game leading the majors in batters hit by their pitchers (53) and times they have been hit (59).
Joakim Soria recorded the final two outs for his first save with the Pirates, who earned a split of the four-game series with the Reds.
Pirates starter Charlie Morton did not walk a batter and struck out seven in seven scoreless innings. He paired an effective curveball with his sinker and got nine outs on the ground.
“I feel like my outings have been basically ruined by a first inning and then the last inning,” Morton said. “The body of work that I’ve done in innings two through six has been really, really good all year.”
Morton limited the Reds to four singles through six innings. They put one runner in scoring position in that time. Eugenio Suarez hit a two-out double in the seventh, but Morton struck out Ivan De Jesus Jr. with a curveball to strand the runner.
Rodriguez’s one-out double in the third led to a two-run inning. Gregory Polanco worked a two-out walk. Starling Marte lined a ball into the gap in left-center field.
Byrd, playing center Sunday instead of Billy Hamilton, did not cut the ball off until near the warning track. Third-base coach Rick Sofield sent home Polanco, who scored from first, and the Pirates led, 2-0.
Neil Walker hit the first pitch of the fourth inning off a railing above the outfield wall in right-center field. The ball ricocheted back toward the infield and by the time Bruce threw the ball in, Walker was on third. A crew chief review resulted in the call being overturned, and Walker had his 10th home run of the season.
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.