The Cincinnati Reds have been the only team this season to really get to Gerrit Cole. Wednesday night, they continued to do so, capitalizing on the opportunities Cole provided.

In the second-shortest outing of Cole’s career, he issued walks that turned into runs and did not put away batters with two strikes. Because of Cole’s outing and the Pirates’ offense not mustering much against Mike Leake, the Pirates lost for the fourth time in five games, 5-2, at PNC Park.

Cole threw 106 pitches in 4⅔ innings. He allowed five runs and eight hits, including a home run to Marlon Byrd, and issued three walks, two of which turned into runs. That homer came during a four-run first inning. Pirates starters have allowed 16 first-inning runs in the past three games.

“We were thin a little bit from yesterday,” Cole said. “That’s why it’s especially disappointing that I didn’t get deeper in the game.”

Advertise with us

The outing was a rare poor effort from Cole, who in his second full season in the majors has been one of the best starters in the game. He had not allowed more than three runs in any of his first 14 outings, entered the game with a 1.78 ERA and had allowed five earned runs in 42⅓ innings during his past six starts.

In Cole’s three starts against the Reds this season, he has allowed 11 earned runs in 142/3 innings for a 6.75ERA.

Leake’s seven innings of two-run ball weren’t surprising, considering he entered Wednesday’s game with a 2.59 ERA in his past 10 starts against the Pirates. He had a 3.10 ERA in 22 career games against them and a 2.54 ERA at PNC Park.

Cole paid the price for walking leadoff batter Billy Hamilton, a light-hitting but lightning-fast center fielder who had stolen a major league-high 33 bases entering Wednesday’s game. He took his 34th and 35th in the top of the first, reaching third with one out.

“It’s not fun to deal with, but it’s something that I obviously thought we could have got out of,” Cole said.

Advertise with us

Cole struggled to put batters away with two strikes and two outs. He threw a good pitch to Todd Frazier, a slider lower and outside, but Frazier poked it into shallow right field to score a run. Jay Bruce hit a full-count fastball into the gap in left-center, scoring another.

“There was a tipping point,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “He was one pitch away from getting out of the inning.”

Byrd hit a first-pitch fastball into the center-field shrubbery, and the Reds led, 4-0. By the time Cole finished the inning he had thrown 38 pitches to eight batters.

Cole walked the first two batters he faced in the fifth. Chris Stewart threw out Ivan De Jesus Jr. stealing, but Votto followed with another walk. Jordy Mercer couldn’t handle Bruce’s hard grounder up the middle and Byrd singled to score another run.

“I just didn’t have a good delivery,” Cole said. “I was kind of throwing across my body tonight. Didn’t really have a good change of planes on the fastball or the breaking ball.”

Advertise with us

Pedro Alvarez and Mercer executed a perfect hit-and-run in the bottom half, resulting in runners on first and third with nobody out. Leake fielded Stewart’s grounder and looked at Alvarez, but threw to second, allowing Alvarez to score and reduce the Reds’ lead to 5-2.

Chris Volstad, whom the Pirates promoted Wednesday to add a fresh arm to the bullpen, pitched in the majors for the first time since June 15, 2013. He pitched two scoreless innings.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.