Way back in 2011, when there was only one wild-card team, fans didn’t have to deal with nail-biters like the game tonight.

The team with the best record of any non-division winner would go straight to the playoffs against the team with the league’s best record. That’s the way it worked for 17 seasons starting in 1995 — and then some spoilsport noticed that wild-card teams were not only getting to the World Series more often than not, but they also were winning it too much.

The Marlins won the World Series in 1997 and 2003, yet that franchise still hasn’t won a division. The Angels in 2002, the Boston Red Sox in 2004 and the St. Louis Cardinals in 2011 also became World Champs as wild cards.

Five other wild cards made it to the World Series and lost, with Angels-San Francisco Giants in 2002 being all wild card.

Advertise with us

Major League Baseball decided wild cards shouldn’t be so successful, and so it added this second wild card to put more emphasis on the regular season and set up these annual death matches. Baseball isn’t well designed for a one-game decision — the ball takes too many funny bounces — but tough noogies. Every fan loves watching a win-or-go-home game.

So far, the new design has worked against the wild-card winner, not that there is a great pile of evidence.

The Cardinals won the first play-in game in 2012 and got as far as the seventh game of the NLCS before falling to the eventual World Series champion Giants. The Pirates beat the Reds and Johnny KWAYYYYY-toe last year, only to fall to the Cardinals in five games in the NLDS.

In the American League, the wild-card winners couldn’t get through the division series either year.

Russell A. Carleton of Baseball Prospectus had a long, statistics-laden piece Tuesday, “The Wild Card Penalty,” that attempted to quantify just how big the disadvantage now is.

Advertise with us

But one of his criteria concerned a predicament the Pirates aren’t in: burning the ace pitcher in the wild-card game and then not being able to use him in the first game of the division series.

The way this season played out, with the Pirates trying and failing to win the division on the last weekend of the season, they might be left with a better chance to win the NLDS against the Washington Nationals — if the Pirates can beat the Giants tonight.

Look at it this way: The Pirates will pitch Edinson Volquez, who had a good season and finished strong, because they burned Cole Sunday.

Gerrit Cole, that is.

A lot of fans see Cole as the Pirates’ best big-game pitcher because of his strong performances last October against the Cardinals: two playoff starts, 11 innings pitched, 10 strikeouts and only two walks and five hits. That’s a 2.45 ERA and miniscule WHIP of 0.636.

Advertise with us

Manager Clint Hurdle pitched Cole Sunday against Cincinnati because the Pirates were still trying to win the division and avoid this wild-card game altogether.

Because Francisco Liriano pitched Saturday and Cole the next day in that failed quest, those two pitching heroes from the postseason last year would have five and four days of rest, as the division series begins Friday.

Liriano won the wild-card game last year and gave up only two runs in six innings in the home NLDS game that the Pirates won, 5-3. Liriano’s ERA and WHIP last October were 2.08 and 0.769 — stellar stuff.

Cole and Liriano could pitch the first two games of the NLDS in Washington and Volquez would be ready to pitch Game 3 Monday in PNC Park. Vance Worley would be ready for Game 4 Tuesday if necessary.

Cole could pitch again in Game 5 in Washington if there is one — something he couldn’t do had he pitched in this wild-card game.

Advertise with us

All that will be meaningless if the Pirates don’t win tonight, but these are the hypotheticals that keep sports radio going 24/7.

It should be pointed out that the one-game playoff is not entirely new to baseball.

In 1948, the Cleveland Indians and the Red Sox ended the regular season in a tie, and the Indians beat the Red Sox in a one-game playoff, 8-3, to go to the World Series, which they won against the Boston Braves. (You should still be able to find an oldtimer in Swampscott, Mass., or Worcester, Mass., moaning because his Sawx didn’t pitch Mel Parnell.)

The 1978 AL East also ended in tie, and the New York Yankees beat the Red Sox in the one-game playoff with a home run by Bucky (New Englanders insert bad word here) Dent.

Seven times since then, a division or a wild-card spot has been decided by a one-game playoff. The Tampa Bay Rays had to beat the Texas Rangers last year just to get to the wild-card game they won against the Indians.

Advertise with us

Pirates fans hope tonight is just the first step, but if they slip there is no second chance.

•Wild cards in the World Series, with champions in bold: 1997 Marlins; 2000 Mets; 2002 Giants and Angels; 2003 Marlins; 2004 Red Sox; 2005 Astros; 2006 Tigers; 2007 Rockies; 2011 Cardinals.