Add Josh Harrison to the list of players the Pirates are reportedly dangling as trade bait this winter. A report from FOX Sports’ Ken Rosenthal Monday night suggested the Pirates remain open to trading their starting second baseman, even with Sean Rodriguez off the market.
Harrison, 29, is guaranteed $18.5 million over the next two seasons, and his contract — an extension signed early in the 2015 season — includes club options worth $10.5 in 2019 and $11.5 million in 2020. He earned the extension with an All-Star season in 2014, a year in which he hit 13 home runs and posted an .837 OPS. He has produced eight total homers and a .707 OPS in two years since the signing.
Rosenthal reported the Pirates pursued re-signing Rodriguez this offseason — a portion of the report our sources corroborated earlier this month — with the intention of moving Harrison and spending the saved money elsewhere. But Rodriguez, coming off a big contract year, is headed to Atlanta after having signed a two-year, $11.5 million deal with the Braves, pending a physical.
Harrison started the 2016 season well, carrying a .329 average and .798 OPS into June, but he had a .506 OPS over the next two months as the Pirates hit their midsummer skid. Harrison turned the burners back on late in the year, with a .767 OPS in August and September. His season ended early, however, after he suffered a groin injury Sept. 10.
The Pirates’ internal options to replace Harrison, should he be traded, are Adam Frazier and Alen Hanson. Frazier is nowhere near as reliable of a defender as Harrison, but he batted .301 in 160 plate appearances as a rookie this season and could eventually earn more than a utility role. Hanson is out of minor-league options, but it would be a stretch to hand him a starting job right now; he had OBPs of .313 and .318 in two seasons at Class AAA Indianapolis and needs to get on base consistently for his elite speed to play at the major league level.
No reunion tour
Read More
Any plans for a reunion between free agent right-hander Edinson Volquez and the Pirates were scotched Monday night when the Miami Herald and others reported Volquez had reached an agreement with the Miami Marlins on a two-year contract worth $22 million guaranteed.
The price tag isn’t obscene for the 33-year-old Volquez, though he was about half what the Kansas City Royals hoped for two years ago when they gave him a two-year, $20 million deal with a 2017 mutual option. Volquez followed a 3.55 ERA in 2015 with a 5.37 mark this past season, then declined the option. Despite the down year, he has made at least 31 starts in each of the past five years, and there are plenty of takers around the league for durable veterans.
In Miami, Volquez will work again with pitching guru Jim Benedict, who was hired away from the Pirates by the Marlins last winter.
Cutch a Dodger?
At this point, the baseball world is still trying to gauge what it will take to pry Andrew McCutchen from the Pirates. ESPN’s Jim Bowden attempted to draw up some potential trades to be made at the winter meetings, and he had McCutchen going to the Los Angeles Dodgers for two prospects — right-hander Jose De Leon and first baseman Cody Bellinger.
De Leon, 24, was rated by Baseball America last spring as the Dodgers’ No. 23 prospect. He had a 2.61 ERA in 16 starts last season for Class AAA Oklahoma City. He probably isn’t ready for the majors yet, as he allowed 17 runs, 12 earned, in 17 innings for the Dodgers this fall.
Bellinger, 21, was a fourth-round pick in 2013 and was ranked by Baseball America last spring as the Dodgers’ No. 54 prospect. In 2016, he slugged 26 home runs with an .872 OPS in 114 games for Class AA Tulsa and three games for Oklahoma City. He projects as a power-hitting first baseman, and his plate discipline so far has been OK.
Given that the Dodgers reportedly are being asked to shed salary — though this notion was disputed by the club this week — a straight swap of McCutchen and two prospects seems unlikely. For this trade to happen, the Pirates probably would probably have to take on some of the Dodgers’ salary to even things out a bit.
From discussions with those in McCutchen’s camp and those within the organization, neither side expects McCutchen to remain with the Pirates beyond his current contract, but both parties expect it’ll take quite a haul for the Pirates to trade their franchise player. For the Pirates, there is no downside in listening to offers. If they are overwhelmed by an offer, they will be willing to trade McCutchen and try to fill his spot in the lineup and in the outfield. But if that overwhelming offer does not come — and that would not be a total shock, given how bad he was for two-thirds of this season — there’s no need for a trade.
Also, MLB.com's Statcast expert Mike Petriello took a look at why McCutchen could be a good fit in right field for the Pirates, with Starling Marte in center and Gregory Polanco in left.
Something Brewin’
The Milwaukee Brewers pulled a fascinating swap Tuesday morning. They designated for assignment power-hitting first baseman Chris Carter, effectively non-tendering a guy who just hit 41 home runs, and signed Eric Thames to a three-year contract to replace Carter.
Carter would have made roughly $10 million in arbitration.
Thames, 30, played in the majors in 2011 and 2012, batting .250 with 21 homers in 181 games, and then spent three seasons in the Korean Baseball Organization. He hit 37, 47 and 40 home runs while playing for the NC Dinos and had an OPS better than 1.100 each season. That is in the KBO, of course, which typically has pretty inflated power numbers. But Thames is cheaper than Carter, so perhaps it is a risk worth taking to see whether his power will play in the majors.
Carter and Pedro Alvarez are pretty mighty bats available in free agency, if you need a DH.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.