In this weekly Monday feature, Post-Gazette writers Bill Brink and Stephen J. Nesbitt look back at the week that was and grade the Pirates’ performances in a few key areas.
The losing streak reached eight games this week before the Pirates ended it, but they still went 2-5 at home against the Cardinals and Reds. They went 2-8 on the homestand and have lost 11 of 13 to reduce their record to three games below .500; at six games back of the wild card, they are as close to the Brewers in the standings as they are to the playoffs. This week they begin a three-city, 11-game road trip against the Phillies, Reds and Brewers.
Offense
The one thing the Pirates did this week was hit (except Sunday). Their .307 average and .382 on-base percentage ranked first in the league, as did their .357 weighted on-base average (wOBA, an advanced metric that attempts to provide a value for each outcome of a plate appearance and is scaled to OBP). They finished the week second in walk rate and third in strikeout rate. Jung Ho Kang went 12 for 23 with four homers, and Josh Harrison went 10 for 24 with four doubles before getting hurt. Andrew McCutchen struggled, going 3 for 23. They scored 4.4 runs per game (31 total), right around league average and right around their season average. But they went 1 for 11 with runners in scoring position Friday, 1 for 10 Sunday and left 20 men on base between Saturday and Sunday.
Grade: B
Defense
Read More
David Freese and Josh Bell made errors Monday, and McCutchen let a single go through his legs Sunday for a two-base error. Bell might or might not have been able to get to the triple over his head or the double to his left Sunday, but his defense in right field was not great. Playing left field while Starling Marte is out, Gregory Polanco has taken some subpar routes to balls. Nobody recorded an out on a bunt Saturday.
Grade: C
Pitching
Scoring 4.4 runs per game won’t cut it when you allow 6.4 per game. The staff’s 5.86 ERA ranked 14th in the NL and their 6.00 strikeouts per nine was dead last, as was their .313 batting average against. The rotation had a 6.27 ERA despite Ivan Nova’s one-run complete game. Ryan Vogelsong allowed 11 runs and 13 hits in eight innings across two starts this week, and Tony Watson gave up five runs and seven hits in 3⅔ innings. Drew Hutchison had a four-run lead and gave it right back. Three of those hits were home runs as he blew a lead, and he also allowed the go-ahead run in a tie game. The bullpen allowed 22 runs in 30 innings.
Grade: F
Coaching
Every game is important, but the Pirates are running out of time. In these games while they are, despite poor play, still technically alive in the wild-card race, the Pirates started Hutchison and used Trevor Williams in his second major league appearance in relief in a tie game. They also pulled some starters while trailing by seven Sunday. How has the coaching staff balanced using young players while trying to win?
“Probably as well as we could ask,” GM Neal Huntington said before Sunday’s game. “Everybody in that clubhouse wants to win every game that we play. Everybody in that clubhouse wants to put the best lineup that gives the best chance to win every game that we play, and that’s an interesting balance to walk, is how do we put ourselves in a position to win the most [games] in a 162-game season so a day of rest in April may be crucial even though a player’s playing well or a pitcher’s on a nice run. When you’re fighting for your playoff life in September, it’s hard to take a player out of the lineup. It’s hard to skip a start. We are all in this thing with a bigger picture in mind and we don’t ever take for granted that we have a playoff chance this year. At the same time, our jobs are to put this organization, this club, in a position to have a playoff chance next year.”
Hurdle deserves praise for not running his starters into the ground (Hutchison started because of workload concerns for Chad Kuhl, who lasted only two innings in his previous start). But there has to be a better way to navigate important late-season games, especially with an expanded roster.
Grade: C-





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.