The paradigm had been shifting for two weeks now. Blown leads, shutouts, errors and baserunning mistakes tugged the Pirates farther and farther from contention. Sunday’s mess completed the transition.
For months now, the question was where the Pirates would wind up in the wild-card race. The Chicago Cubs ruled out the division pretty quickly, so the best the Pirates could hope for was the opportunity to host their fourth consecutive wild-card game and roll the dice against Madison Bumgarner, Noah Syndergaard or Carlos Martinez.
After a disastrous two-week span, the question has changed: Can the Pirates finish better than .500?
Consider this scene at PNC Park Sunday afternoon, in the 8-0 loss to the Cincinnati Reds, with 21 games remaining and the Pirates ostensibly within range of the wild card, although they are now the same number of games away from the second play-in spot as they are from the Milwaukee Brewers in the standings: an infield including Adam Frazier, Pedro Florimon and Alen Hanson, with Sean Rodriguez in center field. Andrew McCutchen, Jordy Mercer and Jung Ho Kang got the late innings off.
“I do think there comes a point in time, when you’ve got experience in this game, you look at chasing a 7-0 shadow, because that’s kind of what it is right now, get them out, get them unplugged, get them plugged back in tomorrow, rally up the wagons and go from there,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “Because today, you get them all fired up, they’re ready to go, and in the blink of an eye we’re down, 5-0.”
The question is odd for a team that won 98 games last season. But after the Pirates (69-72) lost their third in a row to the last-place Reds and dropped their 11th game in 13 tries, the question is also realistic.
Read More
“If we can flip a switch and fix it, we certainly would,” general manager Neal Huntington said. “But every time we seem like we’re falling in the wrong direction, we seem to right ourselves. Every time we right ourselves, we seem to take a misstep. We’ve been the streakiest team in baseball this year, and our goal is to spend some time figuring out how we become more consistent.”
He is correct about the vacillation. As recently as Aug. 28, the Pirates had won four in a row, were six games better than .500 and trailed in the wild card by only half a game. Since then they have won only twice.
“We’ve talked for weeks, the team that goes 8-2 is going to separate itself,” Huntington said. “Unfortunately we’ve been the team that’s gone 2-8.”
There is no good way to lose 11 of 13, but the Pirates have done so in blatantly poor fashion. They were shut out four times and allowed seven or more runs seven times. Closer Tony Watson allowed runs in the ninth, including a four-run, three-homer mess against the Cardinals. They blew a four-run lead Saturday. Sunday, Ryan Vogelsong allowed five second-inning runs; Andrew McCutchen let a ball go through his legs and missed another on a dive, and Josh Bell could not reach a triple to the wall in right-center.
They loaded the bases twice against Reds starter Brandon Finnegan, once with nobody out, and couldn’t score. After allowing five runs in the second inning, Hurdle allowed Vogelsong to hit with the bases loaded and one out in the bottom half. He struck out.
“There were a number of [relievers] who weren’t available today, so yeah, it was too early” to pinch-hit, Hurdle said.
Hurdle said the six-game deficit in the wild-card standings would not yet influence his lineup decisions in terms of looking ahead to 2017. For 2016 to matter, the manner in which the Pirates pitch, hit, run the bases and field needs rapid improvement.
“We are where our feet are,” McCutchen said. “That’s what Hurdle always says. Where are we? We’re here. Where are we going? Philly. So get ready for Philly. That’s all you can do.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.