For a while Friday night, it looked as if the Pirates might overcome their baserunning mistakes. Possibly their inability to retire the opposing starter at the plate, too, and even another ninth-inning run allowed by closer Tony Watson.

But all those, plus the inability to drive in runners in scoring position, was too tall a task.

The Cincinnati Reds broke a tie against Watson in the ninth inning of a 4-3 loss, the ninth in the Pirates’ past 11 games. They went 1 for 11 with runners in scoring position and stranded eight runners, including three in the ninth, when they loaded the bases with one out. Again under .500, the Pirates are five games out of the second wild-card spot.

“We don’t have that safety net of a one-swing, three-run homer very often,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “You don’t want to give up outs on the bases, number one. You’d like to have some opportunities to string some things together.”

Advertise with us

Watson also struggled Tuesday, when he allowed four runs and three home runs in ⅔ of an inning. He recorded the save Wednesday. Friday, he entered in a non-save situation, with the score tied, 3-3, and allowed a leadoff single to Eugenio Suarez.

Ramon Cabrera bunted Suarez to second and Tyler Holt fisted a soft single to right. Andrew McCutchen caught Jose Peraza’s line drive to center, but the ball was deep enough to allow Suarez to score.

Trying to reel in the New York Mets, who hold the second wild-card spot, becomes a lot harder when the opposing pitcher goes 2 for 2 with a double and an RBI and two runners get themselves picked off. After Gregory Polanco doubled in the second, Reds starter Tim Adleman caught him straying too far from second base.

“Polanco probably got picked by the best second baseman in the league as far as a pickoff guy goes,” said Hurdle, referring to Brandon Phillips, who homered Friday.

“… We talked to him, if you’re going to steal third base, you’d like to get there with one out, not with two strikes and one out. It’s a little late right then, you’re not giving the hitter a whole lot of a chance to do something.”

Advertise with us

“I slipped when I tried to get back,” Polanco said.

Jung Ho Kang, on first with two outs in the sixth, found himself too far off the bag when Adleman’s pickoff throw came.

“He went early enough and made a fake break; it brought attention to him,” Hurdle said. “If we see it, they see it. He got in no-man’s land and on the wrong foot. That didn’t help our cause.”

The Pirates surrendered three outs with position-player bunts. With runners on first and second and nobody out in the fifth, Hurdle had Josh Harrison bunt the runners over.

With a runner on first and no outs in the seventh, Jordy Mercer tried to bunt and, bunting with two strikes despite the sign being removed, fouled the ball away and struck out.

Advertise with us

“We’ve had these conversations, I’ve never put a two-strike bunt on for a position player,” Hurdle said. “ … He just said, I felt compelled to get the man to second base.”

Leading off the third, Adleman doubled to the gap in right-center field. Pirates starter Steven Brault walked Jose Peraza and Zack Cozart bunted the runners into scoring position. Joey Votto singled, and the Reds led, 1-0.

The Pirates tied the score in their half of the third, but Adleman ensured the tie didn’t last. Suarez doubled with two outs in the fourth. With a base open, Brault intentionally walked Cabrera to pitch to Adleman.

Brault got two strikes on Adleman, but Adleman still singled to right, driving in a run and giving the Reds a lead.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.