PNC Park, Heinz Field, Consol Energy Center and other new major league sports stadiums have drained as much as $3.7 billion from federal tax revenue since 2000, according to a study by the Brookings Institution.
The Washington, D.C., think tank said the lost revenue stemmed from $13 billion in tax-exempt bonds issued to build or perform major renovations at 36 professional sports venues over the past 16 years.
Brookings found the amount of federal tax revenue lost, estimated at $3 billion to $3.7 billion, exceeded the savings that stadium builders receive because of the lower interest rates that tax-exempt financing provides. The report estimated those savings at $2.6 billion to $3.2 billion.
The New York Yankees topped the list of major league teams benefiting from federal tax subsidies at $431 million, according to the report. Yankee Stadium, completed in 2009, accounted for lost federal tax revenue of $492 million, or nearly a third of the $1.6 billion in lost revenue stemming from Major League Baseball stadium projects, Brookings said.
By comparison, Pittsburgh’s three major league teams collected $144 million in subsidies: $64 million for the Penguins, and $40 million each for the Steelers and Pirates.
The Penguins received the second biggest subsidy among National Hockey League teams, topped only by the New York Islanders at $122 million.
Read More
Tax-exempt bonds carry lower interest rates than conventional borrowing, like a home mortgage or corporate bond, because bond investors are willing to accept lower interest payments in exchange for not having to pay taxes on their interest income. Typically, tax-exempt bonds are more attractive to higher income taxpayers.
The report cites several studies that unanimously agreed there is little relationship between new stadiums and economic development, income growth or job creation. The reason: if people weren’t going to a game, they would be spending their entertainment dollars somewhere else.
Brookings said federal law requires that local taxpayers have to be willing to cover at least 90 percent of the costs of paying off the bonds in order to qualify for the federal tax exemption. However, that taxpayer money cannot come from revenue related to the stadium.
“Residents of, say, Wyoming, Maine or Alaska gain nothing from the Washington-area football team’s decision to locate in Virginia, Maryland or the District of Columbia,” the report states. “Yet, under current federal law, taxpayers throughout the country could ultimately subsidize the stadium, wherever it is located.”
The report said the easiest way to eliminate the subsidy is for Congress to require that any stadium used primarily for private business use is ineligible for tax-exempt financing.
Stadium bonds could also be lumped in with so-called qualified private activity bonds issued to build airports, mass transit facilities, sewage plants and other projects that serve a broader public interest.
The federal government caps the amount of qualified private activity bonds that states can issue based on population, meaning teams seeking the tax-exempt financing would have to compete with those other projects.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.